FACEBOOK has recently taken a harsher tone toward whistleblower Frances Haugen, suggesting that the social network could be considering legal retaliation after Haugen went public with internal research that she copied before leaving her job earlier this year.
US law protects whistleblowers who disclose information about potential misconduct to the government. But that protection doesn’t necessarily cover taking corporate secrets to the media.
Facebook still has to walk a fine line. The company has to weigh whether suing Haugen, which could dissuade other employees who might otherwise speak out, is worth casting itself as a legal Godzilla willing to stomp on a woman who says she’s just doing the right thing.
Haugen may face other consequences. Whistleblowers often put themselves at risk of professional damage — other firms may be reluctant to hire them in the future — and personal attacks from being in the public eye.
Facebook did not respond to emailed questions.
WHAT DID HAUGEN DO?
Haugen secretly copied a trove of internal Facebook documents before leaving the company and subsequently had her lawyers file complaints with the Securities and Exchange Commission alleging that Facebook hides what it knows about the negative effects of its platform.
John Tye, her lawyer, said the team gave redacted documents to Congress, where Haugen testified on Tuesday, and also informed officials in California. Haugen also shared documents with the Wall Street Journal, which she started talking to in December, leading to a series of explosive stories that began in mid-September.
WHAT WAS FACEBOOK’S RESPONSE?
The company says it has been mischaracterized. “I think most of us just don’t recognize the false picture of the company that is being painted,” CEO Mark Zuckerberg wrote to employees on Tuesday.
Some company officials have also begun using harsher language to describe Haugen’s actions that could be interpreted as threatening.
In an Associated Press interview Thursday, Facebook executive Monika Bickert repeatedly referred to the documents Haugen copied as “stolen,” a word she has also used in other media interviews. David Colapinto, a lawyer for Kohn, Kohn and Colapinto who specializes in whistleblower cases, said that language was threatening.
In the same interview, asked if Facebook would sue or retaliate against the whistleblower, Bickert said only, “I can’t answer that.”
A week earlier, Antigone Davis, Facebook’s head of global safety, testified in the Senate that Facebook “would never retaliate against someone for speaking to Congress,” which left open the possibility that the company might go after her for giving documents to the Journal.
IS HAUGEN PROTECTED?
Various laws offer whistleblower protection at both the state and federal levels. The federal laws applicable to Haugen are the Dodd-Frank Act, a 2010 Wall Street reform law, and the Sarbanes Oxley Act, a 2002 law that followed the collapse of Enron and other accounting scandals.
Dodd-Frank expanded protections for whistleblowers and empowered the SEC to take action against a company that threatens a whistleblower. Protections exist for both employees and former employees, experts say.
Asked about her risk because she went to the media, Haugen’s lawyer, Tye, maintains that because Haugen went to the SEC, Congress and state authorities, she’s entitled to whistleblower protections. He said any suit from Facebook would be “frivolous” and that Facebook has not been in touch.
WHAT ABOUT HER LEAKS TO THE MEDIA?
Courts haven’t tested whether leaking to the media is protected under Dodd-Frank, but Colapinto said the U.S. Secretary of Labor determined decades ago that environmental and nuclear-safety whistleblowers’ communications with the media were protected. He argues that the language of Sarbanes-Oxley is modeled on those earlier statutes, and Haugen should have the same protections for any of her communications with reporters.
Facebook could allege that Haugen broke her nondisclosure agreement by sharing company documents with the press, leaking trade secrets or just by making comments Facebook considers defamatory, said Lisa Banks of Katz, Marshall and Banks, who has worked on whistleblower cases for decades. “Like many whistleblowers, she’s extraordinarily brave and puts herself at personal and professional risk in shining a light on these practices,” she said.
Haugen effectively used leaks to the media to turn up the pressure on Congress and government regulators. Colapinto said her disclosures had a public-interest purpose that could complicate enforcing the NDA if Facebook chose to do so.
COULD FACEBOOK FACE BLOWBACK?
Facebook probably wants its veiled threats to unnerve other employees or former employees who might be tempted to speak out. “If they go after her, it won’t be because they necessarily think they have a strong case legally, but sending a message to other would-be whistleblowers that they intend to play hardball,” Banks said.
But she said it would be a “disaster” for Facebook to go after Haugen. Regardless of potential legal vulnerabilities, Facebook might look like a bully if it pursued a legal case against her.
“The last thing Facebook needs is to rouse the ire of governmental authorities and the public at large by playing the role of the big bad giant company against the courageous individual whistleblower,” said Neil Getnick, whose firm, Getnick and Getnick, represents whistleblowers.
AP Newsroom
Sun Oct 10 2021
Former Facebook data scientist Frances Haugen, center, departs after a hearing of the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Subcommittee on Consumer Protection, Product Safety, and Data Security, on Capitol Hill. AP photo
Banyakkan program, tarik minat pelajar dalam bidang STEM - Wan Azizah
Pendedahan pelbagai program berasaskan Sains, Matematik, Kejuruteraan dan Teknologi (STEM) perlu dilaksanakan secara berterusan.
Pusat data membentuk sebahagian besar daripada pelaburan digital dilulus berjumlah RM144.7 bilion
Pada 2021 pelaburan dilulus dalam pusat data berjumlah RM3.4 billion, RM80.8 bilion pada 2022 dan RM60.5 bilion tahun lepas.
Bertrand mengembara 'serap' ilmu terjun
Bertrand kini jalani latihan di Singapura bermula hingga 30 Mei ini dan kemudiannya akan ke Australia untuk menyertai kejohanan terjun di Brisbane.
Lelaki lemas ketika bercuti di Air Terjun Sekayu
Mangsa dipercayai lemas selepas menyelamatkan rakannya yang terjatuh ke dalam air sewaktu mendaki laluan berbukit di tepi kawasan air terjun itu.
Ahli lembaga pengarah, hala tuju DNB diumum esok - Fahmi
Fahmi menjelaskan dalam mesyuarat Kabinet pada Rabu, Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim telah memberi penegasan mengenai pelaksanaan rangkaian 5G dan perkara-perkara yang dipersetujui.
AWANI Ringkas: Laporan interim nahas helikopter TLDM dalam dua minggu
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Semua jenazah dibawa keluar dari HRPB
Semua jenazah anggota TLDM yang maut dalam nahas helikopter di Lumut dibawa keluar daripada Jabatan Forensik Hospital Raja Permaisuri Bainun pada Rabu.
Lebih sebulan berlalu, polis masih kesan pemilik sebenar wang RM500,000 dalam bagasi
Polis masih mengesan pemilik sebenar wang tunai lebih RM500,000 yang ditemui dalam bagasi di tempat letak kereta sebuah pusat beli-belah di Damansara pada 20 Mac lalu.
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: "Ini panggilan daripada Allah" - Dr Sharifah Mazlina
Beliau bersyukur kerana permohonan menyertai misi ini diluluskan biarpun hanya sempat mengisi borang penyertaan di saat akhir.
Bersatu beri bayangan ketengah calon Melayu
Bersatu beri bayangan calon yang akan diketengahkan Perikatan Nasional (PN) pada Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu Mei ini ialah calon Melayu.
Meta tawarkan sistem operasi yang menguasakan Quest kepada pengeluar lain
Ini sekali gus menjadikan Horizon OS akan menerajui arena set realiti maya, lebih kurang seperti Android yang menguasakan telefon pintar.
Di tangga ketiga manusia paling kaya dunia, Zuckerberg kini atasi Musk
Mark Zuckerberg mempunyai nilai kekayaan mencapai $187 bilion, mengatasi Elon Musk dengan nilai kekayaan $181 bilion.
Pra-perkahwinan Anant Ambani: Rihanna, Gates dan Zuckerberg antara jemputan
Dengan lebih 500 hidangan, 1,000 tetamu dan perbelanjaan mencecah jutaan dolar, inilah cara anak lelaki individu terkaya Asia dilaporkan meraikan pra-perkahwinannya mereka.
Mark Zuckerberg bincang risiko AI dengan PM Jepun
Ketua Meta dan pengasas Facebook sangat teruja dengan perkembangan yang berlaku di Jepun.
Mark Zuckerberg melonjak ke tempat ke-4 dalam senarai bilionair dunia
Nilai bersih kekayaan Zuckerberg mencecah AS$167 bilion iaitu peningkatan sebanyak A$27.6 bilion atau 19.88 peratus.
Tangani eksploitasi kanak-kanak: Lima CEO syarikat teknologi utama beri keterangan di Dewan Senat AS
Mereka terdiri daripada CEO TikTok, Discord, Snap, Meta dan X.
Meta ingin bangunkan AGI sumber terbuka untuk semua
Zuckerberg umum menerusi Threads bahawa Meta ingin membina AGI yang menggunakan sumber terbuka bagi memberikan kebaikan kepada semua.
Threads akhirnya dilancarkan di Eropah
Setakat ini Threads dikatakan mempunyai 100 juta pengguna aktif bulanan.
Pertarungan Zuckerberg-Musk mungkin tidak berlaku - Pemilik Meta
Menerusi Meta Threads pada Sabtu, Zuckerberg berkata sudah tiba masanya untuk melupakan pertarungan itu.
Musk, Zuckerberg bertarung di Rom?
Elon Musk mengumumkan pertarungan seni bela diri campuran (MMA) yang dinanti-nantikan dengan Ketua Pegawai Eksekutif (CEO), Mark Zuckerberg akan berlangsung di Itali.