Court of Appeal judge Datuk Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat was today recused from presiding on the three-man bench to hear the prosecution's appeal against Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's acquittal on a charge of sodomising his former aide.
Justice Datuk Ramly Ali, chairing the panel, said the court would appoint another judge to replace Tengku Maimun.
The panel, also comprising Datuk Mohd Zawawi Salleh, had allowed Anwar's preliminary objection on the grounds that she heard Anwar's defamation suit against former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad in 2007.
"We've deliberated on the issue. We allowed the preliminary objection. Tengku Maimun, with her consent, will recuse herself," Justice Ramly said.
He fixed tomorrow to hear the opposition leader's application to have senior lawyer Datuk Seri Muhammad Shafee Abdullah disqualified from appearing as public prosecutor to lead the prosecution in its appeal against Anwar's acquittal.
However, Justice Ramly said the prosecution's appeal proper over Anwar's acquittal would not be heard tomorrow, but at a later date by the same panel.
Muhammad Shafee was appointed public prosecutor by the attorney-general by way of a "fiat" to lead the prosecution in its appeal against the Kuala Lumpur High Court's decision on Jan 9, last year which acquitted and discharged Anwar, 64, on a charge of sodomising Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan, 26.
Anwar was accused of committing the offence at a Desa Damansara condominium unit in Bukit Damansara between 3.10pm and 4.30pm on June 26, 2008.
In today's proceeding, Anwar's lawyer Karpal Singh sought the recusal of Tengku Maimun as he said she had, in her judgment in the defamation suit, adopted the finding of facts made by the Federal Court in the first sodomy case where Anwar and his adopted brother Sukma Darmawan Sasmitaat Madja were accused of sodomising his (Anwar's) family driver Azizan Abu Bakar.
In the first sodomy case, the Federal Court had on Sept 2, 2004, in a two-one majority decision, acquitted Anwar and Sukma Darmawan.
However, there was a specific finding by the judges of the majority judgment stating that the court had found evidence to confirm that the appellants (Anwar and Sukma Darmawan) were involved in homosexual activities and that the court was more inclined to believe that the alleged incident in Tivoli Villa did happen.
Karpal submitted that there was a likelihood of bias if Tengku Maimun sat on the panel to hear the prosecution's appeal as she had held the Federal Court's view.
Muhammad Shafee argued that Tengku Maimun should not be recused from presiding on the panel.
He said the case was six years ago and involved a striking-out application resulting in the matter not proceeding through a full trial.
He said she did not make the finding of facts but only adopted the Federal Court's finding of facts.
On Jan 9, last year, High Court judge Datuk Mohamad Zabidin Mohd Diah, in acquitting Anwar, ruled that there was penile penetration but it was uncorroborated by other evidence.
He had held that the court could not be 100 per cent certain on the integrity of samples taken for DNA testing from Mohd Saiful as the samples could have been compromised before they reached the chemistry department for analysis.
Bernama
Tue Sep 17 2013
Mohd Saiful Bukhari Azlan
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Jenazah semua mangsa selamat tiba di HRPB, Ipoh
Jenazah mangsa dibawa ke hospital menggunakan van jenazah dengan diiringi empat motosikal dan lima kenderaan PDRM dan Angkatan Tentera Malaysia (ATM).
Nahas helikopter Lumut: 2 Pegawai Memerintah Skuadron, ini senarai mangsa terkorban
Tiga anggota Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia (TLDM) wanita dan dua Pegawai Memerintah Skuadron antara 10 yang terkorban dalam nahas dua helikopter bertembung dan terhempas di Pangkalan TLDM Lumut.
Bursa Singapura: Perubahan peraturan bantu pelabur panggil mesyuarat khas
Peraturan baharu itu boleh menjadi langkah positif dalam usaha memperbaik tadbir urus korporat.
Airasia Consulting teruskan libat urus bagi nyahlabur Srilankan Airlines
AirAsia Consulting berhasrat untuk meneruskan libat urus dengan pihak International Finance Corporation (IFC) yang diberi mandat memberi nasihat kepada kerajaan Sri Lanka berhubung usaha nyahlabur dalam SriLankan Airlines Ltd.
Harga minyak: Peningkatan harga beri kesan positif dan negatif - SERC
Terdapat kebimbangan mengenai "kesan pesanan kedua" bekalan minyak yang dijangka menyebabkan kenaikan harga tenaga dan seterusnya inflasi. Ini akan melemahkan perbelanjaan pengguna dan permintaan pelaburan.
Victoria Beckham sifatkan reunion Spice Girls hadiah terbaik sambut usia ke-50
Victoria Beckham Sifatkan Reunion Spice Girls Hadiah Terbaik Sambut Usia 50
Kerajaan perlu ambil kira graduan sedia ada di pasaran
Kerajaan perlu mengambil kira graduan Pendidikan dan Latihan Teknikal dan Vokasional (TVET) yang sedia ada dalam pasaran ketika ini jika mahu melihat keberkesanan penetapan gaji premium untuk graduan dalam bidang itu secara optimum.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: PM akan umum bantuan untuk waris mangsa - TPM
Kerajaan akan mengumumkan bantuan khas kepada waris 10 anggota dan pegawai Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia (TLDM) yang terkorban dalam nahas dua helikopter di Pangkalan TLDM Lumut.
Pasaran buruh: Produktiviti tenaga kerja masih perlu dipertingkat
Kadar pengangguran telah menurun kepada paras sebelum wabak Covid-19 sebanyak 3.3 peratus pada suku keempat 2023, namun, kadar pengangguran berasaskan kemahiran berada pada 37.4 peratus dalam tempoh yang sama.
Kewangan: Golongan Millenial, Gen Z Malaysia teraju perbankan Islam
Malaysia juga mempunyai kadar tertinggi pengguna yang hanya menggunakan perbankan Islam (42 peratus), berbanding hanya lebih suku (26 peratus) daripada responden global.
PM Anwar meriahkan sambutan ulang tahun ke-15 UKAS
Perdana Menteri menyantuni Unit Kerjasama Awam Swasta (UKAS) di bawah Jabatan Perdana Menteri, yang menyambut ulang tahun ke-15 mereka.
PM Anwar tubuh Jawatankuasa Penasihat Dasar Kepada Perdana Menteri - PMO
Perdana Menteri menubuhkan Jawatankuasa Penasihat Dasar Kepada Perdana Menteri untuk memberi khidmat nasihat terkait soal pembangunan negara dan daya tahan ekonomi.
KL20 2024: Pelabur asing iktiraf masa tepat untuk melabur di Malaysia - PM
Ia bersandarkan kepada kestabilan dalam kerajaan dan tadbir urus yang baik, selain sifat pro-perdagangan dan pendirian neutral oleh Malaysia.
Sidang Kemuncak KL20 2024 bermula hari ini
Sidang kemuncak dua hari itu bakal mendedahkan kertas tindakan KL20 yang akan dilancarkan oleh Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Isu DNB diputuskan minggu depan - Anwar
Isu berhubung dakwaan Digital Nasional Bhd (DNB) bertindak tidak telus dalam menjalankan operasi dalaman, akan diputuskan kerajaan pada minggu depan.
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: Pendirian Malaysia kekal tegas dalam isu Palestin - Duta Malaysia ke Turki
Pendirian Malaysia dalam isu melibatkan kekejaman rejim Israel terhadap penduduk di Gaza kekal tegas di bawah kepimpinan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Presiden MIC janji turun berkempen esok - Anwar
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menolak dakwaan yang mengatakan MIC tidak akan turun berkempen pada Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Kuala Kubu Baharu.
Agenda reformasi kerajaan adalah tekad politik bantu rakyat - Anwar
Agenda reformasi yang dilaksanakan Kerajaan Madani merupakan tekad politik untuk membantu golongan rakyat yang memerlukan.
Hubungan parti dalam Kerajaan Perpaduan tak retak, kekal kukuh - PM
Hubungan antara parti dalam Kerajaan Perpaduan kini adalah sangat kukuh dan mantap, dengan masing-masing sentiasa mengukuhkan hubungan tersebut, kata Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Peruntukan pembangkang: 'Kalau ikhlas, tak perlu ada MoU' - Muhyiddin
Tidak perlu ada memorandum persefahaman (MoU) jika Kerajaan Perpaduan ikhlas untuk memberikan peruntukan kepada Ahli Parlimen pembangkang, kata Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin.