KUALA LUMPUR: The decision to place Lembaga Tabung Haji (TH) under the regulation of Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) has created a passionate response among the Muslims here, despite the assurance that it is an interim solution until the findings of the Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) are presented to the government for further actions.
No surprise here on why it has created a passionate response. When TH was first established in 1963, it was the only institution – one of its kind – where you can never find it anywhere else in the world including Muslim countries. Since then, it has become a model for some Muslim countries which went on to establish similar institution.
The government has emphasised the regulatory improvement of TH that it has in mind is in line with its intention for TH to return to its original mandate of managing depositors' savings for the purpose of performing hajj, in addition to savings for investment.
“BNM's regulatory scope at present, pending the completion of the RCI, is focused only on deposit taking, as well as risk and liquidity management, with a different regulatory framework from the general rules imposed on other banking institutions," said the Ministry of Finance in a statement.
The government has good grounds to place TH under the supervision of BNM. The simple incontrovertible fact it needs government intervention to prop up TH’s financial resources after an economic downturn hits the country is a good enough reason that the fund, which manages some RM82 billion in assets, requires major changes to the way it operates.
Hence, the proposal to improve TH’s management and operations would involve a new policy model and a review of amendments to the Tabung Haji Act 1995.
It cannot still operate under the present structure where politicians sitting on the board had played a pivotal role over its management and investment panel that had led to the sorry state of affair, resulting in government intervention via a recovery and restructuring plan.
Under Bank Negara’s Fit and Proper Criteria, politicians are not allowed to be on the board of companies under its watch. And the board is required to grill the management and investment panel on their decisions, not for the board to take over the roles and functions of the management and investment panel.
The establishment of RCI announced on July 14 by Deputy Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob, was precisely because under the present structure there were issues that arose from audits carried out in the board.
Hence, among the scope of the RCI is to focus on findings by the consultants on issues related to Tabung Haji from 2014 to 2020, but would not involve the Tabung Haji Recovery and Restructuring Plan.
According to the deputy premier, “the RCI is also to determine if there were elements of cover up and if misleading information was provided” apart from recommending appropriate action to be taken against parties that were either directly or indirectly involved in any wrongdoings, or had violated laws.
"The commission is to present to the government its findings and recommendations on the next course of action, if necessary, within three months," he said.
TH’s RM82 billions of assets under management is a huge amount that will have a knock-on effect on the economy, especially the financial markets, if it is not properly managed.
BNM has an interest in this because among its roles and functions are to ensure monetary and financial system stability, developing the financial system infrastructure in advancing the financial inclusion agenda, and providing advice on macroeconomic policies and the management of public debt.
The RM82 billion deposits of TH – the highest since its establishment in 1963 – represents 10% of the entire deposits within the country's Islamic banking industry which must be governed with concomitant checks and balances mechanisms in place because the deposits are placed in Islamic banking institutions.
Since the government guarantees the depositors' savings in TH under Section 24 of the Tabung Haji Act 1995, it has a bigger stake and responsibility to ensure the savings are better regulated to ensure prospective pilgrims will be able to perform the hajj, and TH can continue to generate income from shariah-compliant investments.
The government also has given its pledge the absolute rights of the management and operations of the hajj would still be carried out by TH while it is under the supervision of BNM.
All the above reasons alone are more than sufficient to allow TH be under the supervision of BNM because it will result in a stronger, financially healthier and better TH of the future, especially in a post Covid-19 world.
But why were there strong passionate arguments against placing TH under BNM’s supervision, especially when most of the arguments are already addressed by the government and TH themselves?
If we analyse these arguments, the common thread in all of them is a plea not so much for the government not to implement its idea but rather to take the time to consult all stakeholders before coming to a decision, and also for the government to wait for the outcome of the RCI and its recommendations before implementing its decision of a new policy model and a review of amendments to the Tabung Haji Act which the supervision of BNM entails.
This is a fair concern in light of the need for inclusivity especially when the highest deposit currently attained at RM82 billion is a clear sign of the people’s confidence and trust in TH.
So, if time is of the essence, the onus is on the government to speed up on the meetings of the RCI by quickly getting its members, terms of reference and schedule of its deliberations announced soonest possible.
The government has already said it expects the RCI to present its findings and recommendations on the next course of action, if necessary, within three months. But three months can be a long time if the first meeting of the RCI takes a longer time to materialise.
While the RCI is having its deliberations, the government should be on a consultation spree with TH’s stakeholders to assure them and to quickly work on TH’s proposal that a comprehensive study be conducted by the Prime Minister’s Department, Finance Ministry, and Bank Negara to evaluate the proposed new policy model by taking into account the existing capacity including assets, liability, human resources expertise and others.
Jamari Mohtar is Director, Media & Communications at EMIR Research, a think tank focused on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Jamari Mohtar
Fri Jul 30 2021
The regulatory improvement the government has in mind is in line with its intention for TH to return to its original mandate of managing depositors' savings for the purpose of performing hajj, in addition to savings for investment. - AWANI
Malaysia gesa masyarakat antarabangsa terus menekan Israel
Wisma Putra menjelaskan keganasan Israel terhadap Palestin di Gaza yang menyebabkan kini dilanda kebuluran, malnutrisi dan penyakit.
10 Berita Pilihan - (29 Mac 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Kementerian bercadang anjur jelajah tingkat kesedaran kanak-kanak guna media sosial - Fahmi
Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil berkata beliau telah berhubung dengan pejabat Menteri Pendidikan bagi menyatakan hasrat itu.
Sistem PADU selamat - Fahmi
Antara pihak yang terlibat dalam menguruskan keselamatan siber negara termasuklah Agensi Keselamatan Siber Negara (NACSA) dan Cybersecurity Malaysia.
Tumpuan Sabtu - 30 Mac 2024
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan di Astro AWANI.
KPM pertimbang perjawatan warden bukan dalam kalangan guru
Kementerian Pendidikan Malaysia (KPM) sedia mempertimbangkan untuk mewujudkan perjawatan warden bukan dalam kalangan guru di sekolah berasrama, dalam menangani pelbagai isu termasuk kes buli.
Seluruh Perlis, 30 kawasan lain catat suhu panas tahap berjaga-jaga - MetMalaysia
Suhu panas tahap satu atau berjaga-jaga merujuk kepada suhu maksimum harian 35-37 darjah Celsius bagi tempoh sekurang-kurangnya tiga hari berturut-turut.
Louis Gossett Jr meninggal dunia pada usia 87 tahun
Louis Gossett Jr., lelaki kulit hitam pertama memenangi Anugerah Akademi sebagai pelakon pembantu terbaik, meninggal dunia pada usia 87 tahun.
Anggota polis maut dalam perjalanan bertugas
Seorang anggota polis maut selepas motosikal yang ditunggangnya terbabit dalam kemalangan dengan sebuah treler di Kilometer 6, Jalan Bahau-Kemayan tengah hari tadi.
Wanita Malaysia perlu peka terhadap golongan memerlukan - Dr Wan Azizah
Wanita di Malaysia perlu sentiasa peka dan membuat kebaikan kepada golongan yang memerlukan lebih-lebih lagi pada Ramadan ini, kata isteri Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail.
TH terima permohonan maaf pengadu, dakwaan wang hilang selesai
TH menerima permohonan maaf daripada seorang bekas pegawai kanan kerajaan yang sebelum ini mendakwa wang lebih RM30,000 dalam akaun TH miliknya hilang.
TH diarah perkukuh keselamatan aplikasi THiJARI
Mohd Naim berkata, TH telah membuat laporan polis berhubung dakwaan wang lesap melibatkan aplikasi THiJARI.
Pendeposit diingatkan tidak buka mesej, hantaran meragukan - TH
Sebelum ini media melaporkan seorang bilal sebuah masjid di Ulu Yam Bharu, Hulu Selangor kerugian RM12,000 selepas wang di dalam akaun TH miliknya disyaki dipindah ke akaun milik orang lain.
Dividen Tabung Haji dijangka umum April ini - Mohd Na'im
Pengumuman dan agihan dividen Tabung Haji (TH) bagi tahun kewangan 2023 dijangka pada April ini iaitu setelah audit penuh dijalankan.
TH sangkal dakwaan agih kuota haji kepada PJH
Kuota haji berjumlah 31,600 yang telah diberikan kerajaan Arab Saudi adalah mengikut sistem pendaftaran haji terbuka berdasarkan konsep "Mendaftar Dahulu, Didahulukan".
Peningkatan kos haji disebabkan beberapa faktor - Zulkifli
Kenaikan kos haji kali ini adalah wajar dan masih berpatutan berikutan kos ditanggung oleh Lembaga Tabung Haji (TH) semakin bertambah.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Jumaat, 19 Januari 2024.
Kerajaan beri bantuan RM1,000 untuk jemaah haji Muassasah golongan B40
Jemaah haji Muassasah golongan B40 akan membayar kos haji berjumlah RM12,356, berbanding RM13,356 yang ditetapkan kerajaan sebelum ini.
Bayaran haji B40 tahun ini RM12,356 - TH
TH mengumumkan kadar bayaran bagi bakal haji muassasah kumpulan B40 yang akan menunaikan ibadah itu buat kali pertama, ditetapkan pada RM12,356 seorang tahun ini.
31,600 jemaah terima surat tawaran, TH biaya kos RM350.1 juta
Seramai 31,600 jemaah Haji bagi tahun 1445 Hijri bersamaan 2024 Masihi bakal menerima surat tawaran haji bermula 19 Januari 2024.