IN times of crises, including at the present, we shouldn’t expect the political elite of the day to continue with pre-existing perks/benefits/privileges and pensions – and even salaries – which gives out the perception of “unbridled” enjoyment of “lavish” treatment, rightly or wrongly.
Of course, this is always at the expense of the money belonging to the rakyat.
And yet, as recently revealed by Member of Parliament (MP) for Muar, Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman and leader of the Muda (Malaysian United Democratic Alliance) party, there’s been no let up in the provisioning of ministers’ salaries and perks during what’s an unprecedented spell and the most devastating economic impact ever – brought about by COVID-19.
In fact, ministers have doubled down on their claims and self-entitlements which have created anxiety and unease among MPs giving their due response on behalf of the rakyat – who have been put through the most severe economic and socio-economic upheaval so far.
This is set against a real-world backdrop where it’s been estimated that unemployment together with under-employment could well have reached more than two million by now. Some have had to endure pay cuts before the wage subsidy kicked in. Worst still are those whose pay cuts were never restored.
Tragically, thousands of businesses have shut down simply because they were unable to withstand the impact from the movement control orders (MCOs) or lockdowns that had caused such a drastic drop in sales in conventional or face-to-face transactions. Hundreds of thousands more are on the verge of bankruptcy and closure.
For businesses that have adapted to and adopted digitalisation by way of low contact transactions, some (i.e., high growth businesses) have found success and their niche in the market through e-commerce platforms such as Shopify Plus, and digital marketing solutions providers in the form of Meekco, among others.
Whereas for the wider real economy, getting onboard delivery platforms like Grab, Food Panda, Shopee, Lazada, it’s been a mixed picture. Many continue to struggle and sales from digital orders barely cover the losses from the conventional or face-to-face transactions.
On top of that, businesses suffer from the perennial cashflow problem that’s compounded by high gearing ratios or highly leveraged financial positions (i.e., high debt) as well as outstanding rental payments to landlords, among others.
A staggering 580,000 households from the M40 classification have slipped into the B40 category whereas there are now 639800 households that are deemed as poor as of 2020. Incidences of absolute poverty – that’s supposed to have abolished a long time ago – increased to a scandalous 8.4%. All of these data are from the Department of Statistics (DOSM) applying the current Poverty Line Income (PLI) set at RM2,208 per month.
In short, statistics after statistics from our socio-economic data point to a grim outlook. For the vast majority of the rakyat, they continue to struggle to survive and cope whilst some have barely enough to put food on the table.
According to Syed Saddiq, “… a cabinet member gets paid RM50,000 a month. On top of this, a minister also gets a lavish home in Putrajaya, a car, a driver, a licence plate that is worth hundreds of thousands, an approved permit (AP) to bring in luxury cars, and a plot of land in Putrajaya, among others” (“Syed Saddiq shines spotlight on how MPs, ministers make big bucks via long service”, Malaysiakini, September 29, 2021).
Furthermore, “… ministers can also claim for meal expenses, and holiday allowances” which can range from RM100,000 and RM200,000 for holidays per year.
And “… when a minister steps down, they get gratuity pay which is based on the minister's term as an MP. If an MP has served four to five terms, even if they served as a minister for one day, their gratuity payout exceeds RM1 million”.
These are revelations that’s bound to raise the ire and irk the rakyat even more as they reel under the effect of the restrictions imposed upon them as a result of the government’s having to balance between lives and livelihoods as part of the measures to contain and manage the transmission of the virus.
To further accentuate the contrasting standards and backdrop, perhaps we can point to the situation where austerity had been unfairly imposed on the populace.
We have learnt from the lessons of other countries that austerity shouldn’t be imposed on the rakyat during times of economic difficulties. Countries such as Greece that experienced austerity saw its gross domestic product (GDP), and output and employment contracting and shrunk massively.
In the UK, the austerity measures (timed over a five-year period) were unable to go on full swing as it stalled by 2012 when GDP fell to 0.2% (in inflation-adjusted GDP – this is below the level in 2007, i.e., the year before the onset of the Great Recession of 2008/09).
But savings and cuts should be made by the government on itself. If at all, any self-imposed constraints and restraint should be upon the government’s internal expenditure. Whatever one wants to call it – “efficiency savings” and what-not.
Specifically, the government should go all out in plugging the leakages and wastages from public expenditure as reported in the Auditor-General’s Report year after year by tightening up the screws on the procurement process and implementing a zero-based budgetary system (introduced by former Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng).
More to the point, and to put it simply – ministers’ pay, perks and pensions should be revisited and subject to a reasonable reduction, accordingly.
For one, there should be a temporary or time-limited cap on ministerial pay, perks and pensions across the board. On top of that, there shall be a freeze or halt to any proposed rises.
Just because the government is “splashing” or rather to be more precise allocating funds to the rakyat to help them tide over the impact from the pandemic, it, therefore, doesn’t mean that ministers are “equally” entitled to a “helping” as “reward” for what they’re doing.
Such casuistry, if at all, is only self-serving above all.
A mild or modest belt tightening of this kind on our ministers doesn’t hurt them in any way at all. In fact, it’ll elevate their standing in the eyes of the rakyat and assure them that our political elite and masters truly empathise with their situation.
A big thanks again to Syed Saddiq for raising and highlighting this matter.
The MP – and former Minister for Youth and Sports himself – is a stellar wakil rakyat who’s gone all out to help his constituents in every possible way with much of the costs being borne personally.
Please, dear ministers, can we see some show of real empathy here?
Jason Loh Seong Wei is Head of Social, Law & Human Rights at EMIR Research, an independent think tank focussed on strategic policy recommendations based on rigorous research.
** The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
AWANI Columnist
Fri Oct 08 2021
For the vast majority of the rakyat, they continue to struggle to survive and cope whilst some have barely enough to put food on the table. - REUTERS photo
Bedah siasat: PSM libatkan jururunding, kontraktor padang SNBJ
Perbadanan Stadium Malaysia akan mengadakan mesyuarat 'post mortem' bersama juruperunding dan kontraktor padang Stadium Nasional Bukit Jalil (SNBJ) minggu hadapan.
Pelapor Khas PBB kumpul bukti genosid Israel diugut
Pelapor Khas PBB mendedahkan beliau menerima ugutan ketika cuba mengumpulkan bukti genosid dilakukan Israel di Genting Gaza.
Keliling kampung, ketuk buluh kejut penduduk bersahur
Pasukan gerak sahur di Teluk Bahang di sini masih mengejutkan penduduk di kawasan itu untuk bangun bersahur walaupun sudah dua minggu umat Islam berpuasa.
PADU: Kerajaan perlu lebih fokus mengenai cara untuk mempertingkatkan keyakinan - Pakar
Kerajaan perlu lebih fokus mengenai cara untuk mempertingkatkan keyakinan pengguna untuk memastikan pendaftaran sistem PADU berjaya.
7,348 kes jenayah komersial direkod hingga Mac, kerugian lebih RM770 juta
Belum sampai tiga bulan, polis sudah merekodkan 7,348 kes jenayah komersial melibatkan kerugian lebih RM770 juta.
Pihak berkuasa pelabuhan Singapura siasat insiden jambatan di Baltimore runtuh
Penguasa Maritim dan Pelabuhan Singapura akan menjalankan siasatan susulan insiden Jambatan Francis Scott Key di Baltimore, Maryland runtuh.
Kahwini warga tempatan, jadi dalang sindiket pekerja asing
Dua warga asing yang mengahwini rakyat tempatan dan menjadi dalang sindiket pekerja asing terbongkar selepas dicekup di Jalan Duta, di sini, pada Rabu.
Raja Permaisuri Agong berkenan agih bubur lambuk di Kampong Bharu
Raja Permaisuri Agong Raja Zarith Sofiah hari ini berkenan berangkat ke Majlis Pengagihan Bubur Lambuk di Masjid Jamek Kampong Bharu.
Kemarau: Kerajaan Kelantan gali 100 telaga tiub bantu pesawah
Kerajaan Kelantan akan menggali 100 buah telaga tiub bagi mengatasi masalah kekurangan bekalan air yang menghantui pesawah di negeri ini akibat kemarau.
Lelaki Myanmar dan Bangladesh dalang sindiket pekerja asing
Dua lelaki dari Myanmar dan Bangladesh disyaki dalang utama sindiket pekerja asing ditahan Jabatan Imigresen menerusi operasi khas di ibu negara.
Malaysia sekali lagi tewas 0-2 kepada Oman
Malaysia gagal membalas kekalahan kepada Oman di Muscat pada Jumaat lepas setelah sekali lagi tewas 0-2 dalam saingan Kumpulan D Kelayakan Piala Asia 2026.
Malaysia, Korea Selatan sambung semula perjanjian perdagangan bebas - MITI
Malaysia dan Korea Selatan menyambung semula Perjanjian Perdagangan Bebas Malaysia-Korea (MKFTA) yang dijangka dapat meningkatkan perdagangan dan pelaburan dua hala antara kedua-dua negara.
Gencatan senjata di Gaza: Malaysia sambut baik resolusi Majlis Keselamatan PBB
Malaysia sambut baik resolusi Majlis Keselamatan PBB berhubung gencatan senjata serta-merta di Gaza, pada Isnin.
Malaysia-Oman: Pan Gon tuntut janji padang dalam keadaan terbaik
Ketua Jurulatih Harimau Malaya Kim Pan Gon menuntut janji yang diberikan bahawa kualiti padang akan berada dalam keadaan terbaik.
Malaysia kecam serangan keganasan di Rusia
Malaysia menyertai masyarakat antarabangsa mengecam sekeras-kerasnya serangan keganasan di Moscow, Rusia.
Kelayakan Piala Dunia: Jurulatih Oman nak tengok dulu keadaan padang
Oman tidak melatah di sebalik desas-desus mengenai keadaan padang di Stadium Nasional Bukit Jalil (SNBJ) bagi perlawanan Selasa ini.
Malaysia terima 348 penilaian susulan pembentangan UPR Keempat di Geneva
Malaysia menerima sebanyak 348 penilaian daripada 130 negara susulan pembentangan laporan negara dalam sesi Penilaian Berkala Sejagat (UPR) Keempat, Januari lepas.
Malaysia mungkin salur bantuan kemanusiaan di Gaza melalui "air drop"
Malaysia tidak menolak kemungkinan untuk menyalurkan bantuan kemanusiaan bagi penduduk di Gaza secara 'air drop' atau digugurkan melalui ruang udara.
Astro catat keuntungan RM44 juta pada suku keempat 2024
Astro berkata, meskipun dibelenggu keadaan makroekonomi tidak menentuia telah mencatatkan hasil dapatan sebanyak RM820 juta, suku ke suku.
Inisiatif kod QR: ICA Singapura ingatkan pengembara berkereta bawa pasport
ICA berkata pengembara juga memerlukan pasport mereka untuk pengesahan identiti di pusat pemeriksaan Malaysia.