THE recent allegations made against the Chief Commissioner of the MACC and the resulting defamation suit filed by him has certainly captured not only the interests of the public but my own interest. This is due in no small part to the investigation that was commenced by a Parliamentary Select Committee. The particular Committee carrying out the investigation is the “Special Select Committee on Agencies under the Prime Minister’s Department” or (PSSC).
I also read with speechless curiosity and utter disbelief at the way many interpreted the call by Special Select Committee to have the Chief Commissioner of MACC face the committee. The likes of Lim Kit Siang stresses that Tan Sri Azam Baki could be jailed for contempt of Parliament if he defies its notice to appear before the Parliamentary Special Select Committee (PSC) on the Agencies under the Prime Minister’s Department on January 19” (READ Here). And that Tan Sri Azam “could be jailed for contempt if he defies the parliamentary subpoena to appear before the Parliamentary Select Committee (PSC) on the Agencies under the Prime Minister’s Department…” (READ HERE). The question here whether it was a subpoena or was it an invitation to attend? The last time one can check, in layman’s term, is that if it is an invitation and not a subpoena, anyone who received an invitation is not compelled to attend. Has anyone had sight to the “letter of invitation” or purported subpoena?
From my understanding, the PSC was established under Order 76(1) and Order 81(1) of Dewan Rakyat Standing Orders. On 11.11.2020, Parliament has passed a motion to established 9 PSCs for the 14th parliament, which are; (a)Special Select Committee on Finance and Economy; (b) Special Select Committee on Security; (c) Special Select Committee on Agencies under the Prime Minister's Department; (d) Special Select Committee on Agriculture and Domestic Trade; (e) Special Select Committee on Infrastructure Development; (f) Special Select Committee on Education; (g) Special Select Committee on Health, Science and Innovation; and (h) Special Select Committee on Women and Children Affairs and Social Development
On hearing of the Parliamentary Special Select Committee (PSSC) investigation, I have also been looking into its role, powers and as well as jurisdiction. For those uninitiated, including myself previously, the powers of the PSSC are detailed in the Houses of Parliament (Privileges and Powers) Act 1952 (Act 347). Under Order 83(2) of Dewan Rakyat Standing Orders, PSSC shall have power to send persons, documents or papers and shall have leave to report its opinion and observations, together with the minutes of evidence taken before it to the House. In short, each of the PSC shall have the authority to call individuals to have their statements taken, or to gather opinions and views on matters related to the field stated in the respective PSC's term of the reference. Subsequently, inquiry reports prepared by the PSSC, would be tabled in the Lower House which then could be debated in accordance with Dewan Rakyat Standing Order 86(1).
Based on the terms of reference it is clear that the PSSC cannot act in its own capacity except either with the reference of the Dewan Rakyat or Minister through a motion, petition, report and document affecting the affairs of Sabah/Sarawak, parliament, law or religion under JPM. Here the question remains. Firstly, the issue that arises is whether the PSSC has received any referral from the Dewan Rakyat/ Minister? Secondly, whether the PSSC has the authority to investigate matters related to the Chief Commissioner. So far, the matter of Tan Sri Azam is regarding the use of his CDS account in the purchase of shares. This is now the subject of investigation by the Securities Commission (SC). One needs to wait for the conclusion of the SC’s findings on the matter. Another question that needs to be asked and for the PSSC to clarify on the matter is on the terms of reference of the Committee. Otherwise, could it be that the Chief Commissioner can opt not to attend the proceedings of the PSSC as the Committee may have exceeded the powers conferred to it by the terms of reference it was established in the first place?
It is also noteworthy to highlight that the current situation of the PSSC investigating the Chief Commissioner of the MACC in light of the recent articles published may not have been commenced lawfully, in that it is highly doubtful and suspect if a referral was made by the whole House to the PSSC to investigate. This is a necessary requirement of Order 83(4) of the Standing Orders of the Dewan Rakyat. If no such referral from the whole House was made, then the PSSC’s investigation into the Chief Commissioner of the MACC is unlawful and must stop, and only commenced following the correct procedures.
One could argue that these sorts of knee-jerk reactions stemming from articles that were published before verification are reckless and dangerous to say the least. This is why as I have highlighted before that journalist must verify any allegations before going to print, and procedures to investigate must be followed correctly. Failure to do so is highly likely to result in a miscarriage of justice and has the effect of tarnishing the good standing of not only high-ranking public officials and the organisations they lead but other civil servants thus opening a Pandora Box? For all we may know, the only offence that the Chief Commissioner committed was not committing any offence at all.
*Dr Kassim Noor Mohamed is a criminologist base in United Kingdom.
**The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the position of Astro AWANI.
Dr Kassim Noor Mohamed
Sun Jan 16 2022
The recent allegations made against the Chief Commissioner of the MACC and the resulting defamation suit filed by him has captured the interests of the public. - FILEpic/BERNAMA
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: Misi sekali lagi ditangguhkan, dijangka berlepas pada Jumaat
Ketika ini lokasi kapal memulakan pelayaran akan ditukarkan ke satu lokasi yang akan diumumkan dalam masa terdekat.
Pihak produksi masih terima Naim Daniel jika ubah fikiran
Ketua saluran Astro Ria, Norzeha Mohd Salleh memberitahu bahawa pihak produksi masih lagi memberi ruang kepada penyanyi tersebut untuk mempertimbangkan semula tawaran yang diberikan.
The Hardest Singing Show cabar kreativiti penyanyi tempatan
Program The Hardest Singing Show mencari satu juara yang mampu menyahut cabaran kreativiti luar limitasi.
Pekerja Ahli Parlimen EU disyaki jadi pengintip China
Polis Jerman telah menahan seorang pekerja ahli politik Parlimen Eropah Alternative for Germany (AfD) kerana disyaki menjadi pengintip China.
Amaran ribut hujan tahap tertinggi dikeluarkan di Guangdong, selatan China
Lebih 100,000 orang sudah dipindahkan akibat hujan lebat dan banjir yang boleh membawa maut di selatan China.
Jokowi dan anaknya bukan lagi ahli PDIP
Presiden Indonesia Joko Widodo atau Jokowi dan anaknya, bakal naib presiden Gibran Rakabuming Raka, bukan lagi ahli parti terbesar negara itu selepas mereka menyokong calon pesaing yang juga pemenang pilihan raya Prabowo Subianto.
Lima migran maut ketika cuba memasuki Perancis
Lima termasuk seorang kanak-kanak, maut dalam cubaan menyeberangi Selat Inggeris dari Perancis pada Selasa.
Polis New York lakukan penahanan himpunan lewat malam
Polis New York bertindak melakukan penahanan membabitkan peserta yang terlibat dalam himpunan solidariti terhadap Palestin di Universiti New York (NYU) pada lewat malam Isnin. Penahanan itu dibuat selepas mereka didakwa mengingkari arahan amaran pihak universiti untuk bersurai dan mengosongkan plaza yang menjadi tempat mereka berkumpul.
Break The Siege: Ada kemungkinan lokasi pelepasan kapal ditukar
Jawatankuasa Pemandu Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC), Kamarul Zaman Shaharul Anwar memaklumkan, wujud kemungkinan lokasi pelabuhan bagi pelepasan kapal yang terlibat dalam misi Break the Siege of Gaza Freedom Flotilla ditukar.
Benarkan syarikat milik bukan Islam cetak Al-Quran, pengarah syarikat didenda
Seorang pengarah syarikat percetakan dijatuhi hukuman denda RM8,000 atau penjara lima bulan oleh Mahkamah Majistret Petaling Jaya pada Selasa selepas mengaku salah tidak mematuhi syarat-syarat lesen untuk mencetak atau menerbitkan Teks al-Quran, bulan lepas.
SPRM pastikan titah Agong dilaksanakan sepenuhnya, penuh integriti - Azam Baki
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) akan memastikan titah Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Ibrahim dilaksanakan sepenuhnya, dan menjalankan tanggungjawab itu dengan penuh integriti.
'Bulan madu dah tamat, sekarang pergi tangkap lebah' - titah Agong kepada Azam Baki
Yang di-Pertuan Agong, Sultan Ibrahim pada Isnin bertitah bahawa memerangi rasuah sebagai musuh nombor satu negara adalah antara tumpuan utama dalam pemerintahan Baginda.
PM terkesan dengan kes rasuah Kastam di KLIA
Katanya, kecurangan masalah rasuah, biarpun membabitkan jabatan kecil di JKDM, masih boleh menyebabkan kerugian hampir RM2 bilion.
Kegiatan haram di KL: Lebih daripada seorang pegawai kanan polis dipercayai terlibat - Azam Baki
Lebih daripada seorang pegawai kanan Polis Diraja Malaysia dipercayai terlibat dalam aktiviti melindungi kegiatan haram di ibu negara, tegas Ketua Pesuruhjaya SPRM Tan Sri Azam Baki.
Ops Samba 2.0: Ketirisan akibat penyeludupan di Kargo KLIA cecah RM2 bilion - KP SPRM
Jumlah ketirisan akibat kegiatan sindiket penyeludupan babitkan beberapa anggota Jabatan Kastam Diraja Malaysia di Kargo KLIA mencecah RM2 bilion bagi tempoh tiga tahun lepas.
SPRM tahan pegawai kanan polis lindung aktiviti haram
SPRM menahan seorang pegawai kanan di Ibu Pejabat Polis Kontinjen Kuala Lumpur kerana disyaki terlibat melindungi aktiviti haram.
SPRM terima 17 kenderaan berteknologi tinggi, mantapkan penugasan bawa OKT
SPRM menerima 17 kenderaan SPV dilengkapi sistem teknologi tinggi bagi memantapkan beberapa operasi penugasan termasuk membawa OKT.
Kes menantu Muhyiddin: Tuduhan tanpa kehadiran pilihan terakhir - Azam Baki
Tuduhan tanpa kehadiran menjadi pilihan terakhir SPRM untuk mendakwa menantu Muhyiddin, iaitu Datuk Seri Muhammad Adlan Berhan.
Dakwaan ditawar habuan: Tiada pegawai SPRM hubungi Wan Saiful - Azam Baki
SPRM nafi terdapat pegawainya menghubungi Datuk Wan Saiful Wan Jan selepas pendedahan beliau mengenai tawaran habuan untuk menyokong Perdana Menteri.
SPRM nafi tuduh Muhyiddin terbabit kontrak Spanco
Tan Sri Azam Baki berkata, kenyataan yang dikeluarkan sebelum ini bersifat umum dan tidak pernah mengaitkan Muhyiddin dalam kes berkenaan.