In a country still struggling to deal with widespread violence against women, an Indian judge has touched off a firestorm by suggesting that a rape victim and her attacker try to heal their rift in the hope of a happy ending.
When Madras High Court Judge P. Devadass recently let a rapist out of prison on bail so he could "mediate" with his victim, it caused an uproar among legal scholars and women's rights activists.
The move was deemed "retrograde," "misogynistic" and simply bad jurisprudence. Lawyers who work in the courthouse's mediation center wrote a letter to the chief justice, demanding that Devadass's order be rescinded. India's Supreme Court, weighing in on a different case, said last week that any compromise between a rape victim and a perpetrator would be a "spectacular error."
Devadass, a former family court judge, declined through staff members to discuss his order. But critics say it provides a glimpse of the patriarchal attitudes still prevalent in the male-dominated Indian judiciary.
More than two years after the fatal gang-rape of a student brought protesters to the streets and a clarion call for change, judges in India continue to create controversy with their comments in rape cases. One judge asserted that child prostitution is not rape, and another suggested that women who have premarital sex are prone to make accusations of rape or kidnapping later.
The lawyers in the Madras High Court mediation center, an alternative to the overburdened court system, arbitrate mostly civil cases and have called Devadass's order "highly inappropriate." They said it reinforces centuries-old Indian cultural stereotypes — that a woman who is the victim of sexual violence should marry her assailant to protect her honor, especially if a baby is born as a result of the assault.
"The thinking is if there has been a rape, there has been sexual contact and, therefore, the best solution for her would be to marry the man," said Geeta Ramaseshan, a Madras High Court lawyer and mediator. "It's a very patriarchal mind-set."
The victim, now 22, vividly remembers what happened to her in 2008. The aunt who raised her was at a funeral in a nearby town, she said, leaving her to baby-sit children at a neighbor's house.
The neighbor's son, V. Mohan, a college student, had been nasty to her in the past but was friendly this time, offering her a cold beverage. She soon became dizzy and passed out. When she came to, she was lying on the floor. Mohan beckoned her over to show her his cellphone. He had photographed the assault and threatened to use the images to blackmail her, she said.
"To this day, I do not know the reason why he raped me," the woman said recently.
A week after the rape, she broke down and told a friend. Word spread in the village, a cluster of just three lanes in the southern state of Tamil Nadu. Her father, an alcoholic who was an itinerant presence in her life, beat her. "Why did you not tell us?" relatives demanded.
Her family went to the police to file a report. The situation worsened when it became clear that she was pregnant. A DNA test later confirmed Mohan's paternity. He and his parents offered to pay a $3,000 settlement if she had an abortion. Even the village elders weighed in, also urging her to terminate the pregnancy.
Mohan was convicted in 2009 and sentenced to seven years in prison. Last year, he filed an appeal.
In his recent order, Devadass ruminated that women are often the "soft targets of male lust" and lamented that there were two victims in this case: the woman as well as the child born as a result of the rape.
"Now, [the victim] has become mother of a child," the judge wrote. "But as on date, she is nobody's wife. So, she is an unwed mother. Now there is a big question mark looming large before [the victim] as well as her child, who is completely innocent."
The judge deemed that mediation was the best option in this case, noting that he had recommended it on another occasion earlier this year, with the rapist agreeing to marry the victim, a case now heading toward a "happy conclusion."
Sriram Panchu, a senior lawyer, said the judge's order is being protested partly because mediation is normally used to resolve marital or commercial disputes, not violent crimes.
The victim said that the judge's directive caught her by surprise and that she has been living in fear that her attacker would find and harm her.
"If I meet the judge, I would ask him, 'Do you know the pain I suffered as a child and was raped, and raising this child?' " she said. "You are sitting in an air-conditioned hall writing your judgment. Have you ever thought of me? How I have suffered? The scar still remains."
Mohan said in a brief telephone interview that he wants to pursue mediation, and his attorney, C. Arunkumar, said they would participate. Neither discussed the case in detail, although Mohan had earlier said that the sex was consensual.
Karuna Nundy, a Supreme Court lawyer, said there had been a slow attitudinal shift within the judiciary as gender-sensitivity training increases and awareness grows. But advocates say more must be done, including gender equity on the bench. Only a small percentage of judges in India's high courts are women, and there is only one female judge on the Supreme Court.
"The habits of patriarchy die hard — in any country," Nundy said.
Since the mediation order, the victim and her daughter, now 7, have taken refuge at a women's shelter. Over the weekend, they watched cartoons together as evening drew in.
The woman, soft-spoken and dressed in a traditional shalwar kameez outfit, said she was shunned after the birth of her daughter and struggled to find employment, working briefly in a knitting mill and doing other odd jobs. Both the victim, who left school in 10th grade, and her daughter are now in school.
A mediation hearing in her case has been set for Monday, and women's groups are planning to protest. Ramaseshan said the victim should simply not show up, because mediation requires both parties to participate willingly. And she is not.
"I do not want to see him at any cost, for any reason," the woman said. "Even if it is mandatory, I will not go."
The Washington Post
Fri Jul 10 2015
When Madras High Court Judge P. Devadass recently let a rapist out of prison on bail so he could "mediate" with his victim, it caused an uproar among legal scholars and women's rights activists.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Isu akademik, Khairul Azhari mahu fokus pilihan raya
Calon PN bagi PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu, Khairul Azhari Saut enggan mengulas kontroversi melibatkan kelayakan akademiknya yang tular.
AWANI Ringkas: Pertembungan PKR, PN, PRM & Bebas
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Piala Asia B-23: Empat senario Indonesia buru tiket Olimpik Paris
Indonesia kini boleh bermimpi untuk beraksi di pentas Sukan Olimpik Paris tahun ini kerana mereka sekurang-kurangnya telah dijamin aksi playoff menentang Guinea.
KPJ Healthcare, Trustr bergabung untuk revolusi penjagaan kesihatan
Kolaborasi itu akan memfokuskan kepada memanfaatkan rangkaian kesihatan digital inovatif Trustr yang dipacu teknologi AI.
UMT bakal miliki rumah alumni bernilai RM2.2 juta
Universiti Malaysia Terengganu (UMT) merancang memiliki rumah alumni sebagai pusat sehenti, bagi memperkukuh jaringan kerjasama dengan bekas pelajar, industri dan universiti.
Piala Thomas: Pengalaman Aaron Chia-Soh Wooi Yik gagal ditandingi beregu Hong Kong
Hanya 26 minit sahaja diperlukan bekas juara dunia, Aaron Chia-Soh Wooi Yik untuk memastikan Malaysia meraih mata kedua dalam saingan Piala Thomas pagi tadi.
Piala Thomas: Lee Zii Jia beri mata pertama buat Malaysia!
Pemain perseorangan profesional negara, Lee Zii Jia berjaya meraih kemenangan ke atas Lee Cheuk Yiu 21-18, 21-18 dalam perlawanan Kumpulan D pagi tadi.
Filem Oppa beri kesedaran jenayah love scam
Filem kesedaran mengenai jenayah LOVE scam bertajuk 'Oppa' bakal menemui anda pada 9 May ini dengan membawa mesej tentang penipuan dalam talian yang seringkali menyasarkan golongan wanita.
[INFOGRAFIK] Calon Perpaduan | N.06 Kuala Kubu Baharu
Apa yang perlu anda tahu tentang calon Perpaduan bagi PRK N.06 Kuala Kubu Baharu.
[INFOGRAFIK] Calon Perikatan Nasional | N.06 Kuala Kubu Baharu
Apa yang perlu anda tahu tentang calon Perikatan Nasional bagi PRK N.06 Kuala Kubu Baharu.
PRK KKB: MIPP jamin PN akan terima undi terbesar kaum India
Punithan berkata, pihak lawan dilihat mula menunjukkan kebimbangan dan rasa takut dengan kekuatan yang dimiliki PN ketika ini.
Parti politik India perhebat dekati pengundi, bagi pusingan pertama pilihan raya kebangsaan
Modi berkata kerajaannya terus berusaha untuk pembangunan ekonomi wilayah timur laut itu.
Pakistan sambut Aidilfitri hari ini, Bangladesh dan India rai Khamis
Umat Islam di Pakistan dan Sri Lanka meraikan Aidilfitri pada Rabu manakala mereka yang berada di Bangladesh dan sebahagian besar India akan menyambut perayaan itu Khamis.
15 pekerja maut bas terjunam dalam lombong di tengah India
Sekurang-kurangnya 15 pekerja terbunuh selepas bas yang membawa mereka terjunam ke dalam lombong di tengah India pada Selasa malam.
Harimau Muda atasi India 2-1
Skuad bawah 23 tahun (B-23) kebangsaan menundukkan India 2-1 pada aksi persahabatan tertutup di Stadium Bola Sepak Kuala Lumpur, malam tadi.
Doktor terpendek di dunia
Tiada siapa sangka seorang lelaki di India dinobatkan doktor terpendek di dunia apabila hanya mempunyai ketinggian tiga kaki atau 91 sentimeter.
Zii Jia dedah resipi kalahkan bekas juara dunia
Dalam aksi di Birmingham itu, Zii Jia memperagakan aksi bertenaga untuk menundukkan juara dunia 2021 dalam masa 33 minit permainan.
Umat Islam di Bangladesh, India dan Pakistan mula berpuasa pada Selasa
Arab Saudi mengumumkan anak bulan kelihatan pada Ahad dan Isnin merupakan hari pertama Ramadan.
Pelan Tindakan Masyarakat India akan diteliti semula
Satu sesi libat urus bersama pelbagai pihak berkepentingan termasuk kumpulan fokus akan diadakan bulan ini.
AirAsia sasar hak trafik dua hala ke beberapa bandar di India
Tumpuan untuk meluaskan rangkaian penting bagi AirAsia kerana bandar utama di India telah mencapai puncak pengembangan.