In the minutes after Caitlyn Jenner's Vanity Fair cover went public yesterday, the Associated Press made a big whoopsie: They tweeted — and then deleted — a message in which they referred to Jenner as a "he."
"Misgendering," as this practice is known is the LGBT community, isn't just a style error in violation of AP's own rules — it's a stubborn, long-time hurdle to transgender acceptance and equality, a fundamental refusal to afford those people even basic grammatical dignity. In fact, almost any time a transgender person is in the news, online errors like this run rampant. And because I cover the Internet, which is nothing if not a merry-go-round of hysteria, I knew that with Jenner, it would happen again.
So, Monday afternoon, a friend and I cobbled together a rudimentary Twitter bot to quietly, politely correct misgendering errors like the AP's. You might've heard of it. It tweets under the handle @she_not_he.
The bot was designed by moi and coded, in its second iteration, by the brilliant Andrew McGill (which is why it improved markedly around 6 p.m.). It essentially searches for mentions of "Jenner" and "he," screens out a series of terms that turn up false positives, and then sends the offending tweeter a polite, robotic correction.
Since a string of online outlets discovered the bot Monday night, it's gained pretty steady steam: 1,300 Twitter mentions and 800 followers, as of this writing. We suspect the Interest will fade down as the news cycle moves on. But for a span of hours, sitting behind the controls of @she_not_he, I got a very unusual, up-close look at the conversation around Jenner's transition — and the way social media impacts these narratives more generally.
See, there are four distinct types of people who respond to an automated, misgender-correcting bot. You have your bot-haters, who are perhaps justified in their hate. ("This is spam," "You can't read," etc.) You have your irredeemable, stomach-turning transphobic folks, who are rarely justified in anything. ("Shut up, he's an it now anyway.") You have your fans, your improbable followers, all tweeting praise-hands and #followfridays.
Best of all, though, are the reformees. There are very, very few of them, admittedly — but particularly in the beginning, before the bot went viral, we saw strings of well-meaning @-replies from tweeters around the country, tweets that apologized for ignorance or explained that they hadn't previously known about these things.
This is extraordinary, when you think about it; or at least it seems so to me. Our online dialogues have become so toxic, so militarized, that it's rare to change a mind or meet in the middle or otherwise agree reasonably on just about anything. Complaints about "ethics in journalism" flare into destructive doxing campaigns. SWAT teams descend on teenage kids who thought they were playing a friendly video game. Academic disagreements become Twitter wars. And the comments section of literally every Washington Post politics story — seriously, go look — devolves into ungrammatical, ad-hominem attacks, a grim pageant of "you're dumb" and "look in the mirror" and other uncalled-fors.
Is it possible to "politely correct" misgendering, in this environment? Is it possible to talk politely about anything? The overwhelming bulk of the @-replies to @she_not_he bear out my skepticism on this issue, as does the prevailing research. According to a recent survey from Pew, more than one in four Facebook users has defriended a relative or acquaintance over their political beliefs.
And yet, there were those few precious apologizers, the ones who said sorry, that they'd "get it right" next time. In some ways, their heartfelt responses to a dumb Twitter bot aren't just surprising or gratifying. They're kind of, sort of, revolutionary.
I don't want to overstate the importance of what was basically a Twitter stunt, of course. @She_not_he will shortly fade from Internet memory, soon to be overtaken by another misgendering scandal, another Twitter bot.
But there's the seed of a suggestion here — that maybe compromise and dialog are possible on the Internet. After all, as one transgender woman tweeted to @she_not_he, life — online and off — it "is about treating others with respect."
The Washington Post
Wed Jun 03 2015
The bot searches for mentions of "Jenner" and "he," and then sends the offending tweeter a polite, robotic correction.
[TERKINI] Sarjana ‘berkualiti rendah’ tak patut dijemput - PM Anwar
Universiti Malaya sebelum ini menerima kecaman kerana membenarkan Gilley menyebarkan propaganda Zionis dan menuduh ahli politik Malaysia yang menyokong perjuangan Palestin menyebarkan kebencian terhadap Yahudi.
AWANI Ringkas: Peniaga didenda RM23,000, komen jelik nahas
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Thailand, 17 lagi negara gesa pembebasan segera tawanan di Gaza
Pemimpin 18 negara dalam satu kenyataan bersama menggesa pembebasan segera semua tawanan termasuk warganegara mereka sendiri yang ditahan Hamas di Gaza.
Kes jongkong emas: Saibulrijal didakwa lagi guna dokumen palsu
Mohd Saibulrijal Mohd Saad, 46, mengaku tidak bersalah selepas semua pertuduhan dibaca di hadapan Hakim, Azrul Darus.
TSMC akan hasilkan cip 1.6nm menjelang 2026
Menurut TSMC, teknologi 1.6mm akan memberikan peningkatan prestasi sehingga 8-10% untuk voltan yang sama serta pengurangan penggunaan kuasa antara 15-20% pada kelajuan yang sama.
Anak syarikat SPNB berdepan tindakan penggulungan
Syarikat Wiradani Development Sdn Bhd telah menyerahkan notis untuk menggulung SPNB Aspirasi pada 3 Mei tahun lepas.
Bekas CEO 7-Eleven, Hishammudin Hasan dilantik terajui Al-Ikhsan
Al-Ikhsan Sports Sdn Bhd melantik Datuk Hishammudin Hasan sebagai ketua pegawai eksekutif (CEO) baharunya berkuat kuasa 17 April.
'Inflasi diunjur meningkat suku kedua kesan pelarasan cukai perkhidmatan, rasionalisasi subsidi'
Momentum inflasi diunjur meningkat pada suku kedua tahun ini kesan daripada pelarasan cukai perkhidmatan serta rasionalisasi subsidi bahan api.
Kontroversi UM: Sarjana ‘berkualiti rendah’ tak patut dijemput - PM Anwar
Anwar menyindir ahli akademik AS yang terbabit dalam kontroversi pro-Israel sebagai sarjana berkualiti rendah dan tidak mempunyai pencapaian luar biasa atau istimewa.
Agong, Raja Permaisuri zahir ucapan Ulang Tahun Keputeraan kepada Sultan Terengganu
Ucapan itu dizahirkan Seri Paduka Baginda berdua menerusi poster yang dimuat naik di Facebook Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar hari ini.
Elon Musk mungkin kenakan caj untuk pengguna X baharu, sebelum boleh lakukan perkongsian
Ia dikatakan mungkin adalah satu-satunya cara mengatasi masalah bot spam, apatah lagi dengan pelbagai kebolehan teknologi AI.
Penduduk baik pulih bot, sedia hadapi banjir di Tumpat
Persiapan penduduk dengan bot sangat penting dalam menempuh sebarang kemungkinan lebih buruk pada musim tengkujuh.
Pengotor antara punca Aceh enggan terima etnik Rohingya
Kehadiran pelarian Rohingya didakwa mengganggu kehidupan seharian penduduk, selain muak dengan sikap mereka yang gagal berasimilasi.
Kapal pengangkut selamatkan 68 pendatang di Laut Aegean
Kesemua penumpang tidak cedera dan mereka dipindahkan ke kapal pengangkut oleh pengawal pantai.
Penduduk mula sediakan bot, rak tinggi sebagai persediaan hadapi banjir
Kawasan kampung itu antara 'hotspot' banjir justeru penduduk sudah mula mengambil inisiatif membuat persiapan awal.
Bot terbalik langgar ikan paus, lima maut
Bot yang membawa 11 penumpang itu terbalik di perairan Goose Bay, kira-kira 15 kilometer selatan Kaikoura.
40 bot nelayan asing dilupuskan jadi tukun tiruan
Kaedah penenggelaman bot-bot nelayan asing sebagai tukun tiruan merupakan inisiatif dalam memulihara dan menggalakkan biodiversiti marin.
Anggota APMM Sabah didakwa terima rasuah
Tertuduh didakwa menerima wang itu sebagai balasan untuk tidak mengambil tindakan ke atas bot yang mempunyai lesen bot tamat tempoh.
1.03 tan daun ketum tidak sempat keluar muara Kuala Kedah
Bot tersebut dikesan menuju keluar dari muara Kuala Kedah dalam keadaan gelap dan mencurigakan sekitar jam 6.30 pagi.
Sudah lali, penduduk kampung beli bot hadapi banjir
Ternyata pelaburan penduduk kampung itu tidak sia-sia, bahkan mampu menyelamatkan harta benda dan nyawa keluarga tersayang.