IS CHINA - under President Xi Jinping - Southeast Asia’s new hegemon?
Pundits like to compare President Xi to an emperor. Such talk has increased post the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China in Beijing and the APEC Summit in Danang, Vietnam, where he was widely praised.
Many people regard Xi as one of China’s most powerful leaders - equalling or indeed, surpassing his recent predecessors, Deng Xiaoping and Mao Zedong.
Also, with Donald Trump's America in full-retreat, the prospect of a “Pax Sinica” - of a China-led world order looms as an increasing possibility.
Inevitably everyone - and especially in Southeast Asia - has been scrambling for parallels in China’s history, looking to the past for clues to a Xi Jinping-led future.
Sombre, dignified and impressive, Xi has inspired countless personality profiles.
Certainly, his rise to prominence, cold-blooded elimination of rivals and the imposition of his personality on the country more than matches the ambition and ruthlessness of some of China's most distinguished historical leaders.
Given that China was once - and arguably still is - an empire, the tendency has been to compare him to previous emperors.
Indeed, many see a restored, reinvigorated “Chinese Empire” (with a red tint) under Xi as a crucial component of the geopolitical shift to the Asia-Pacific.
There are certainly many candidates for historical precedents for Xi. His consolidation of power, expansion of China’s influence and strong emphasis on national identity have led some to compare him to the Qing dynasty’s greatest emperors: Kangxi, Yongzheng and Qianlong.
Yongzheng, in particularly, was known for his crackdown on corruption and financial reforms - things that Xi is also pursuing.
Others believe that he resembles the Ming dynasty’s Yongle emperor, who re-established Beijing as the imperial capital, undertook extensive construction projects and more importantly, launched the Zheng He voyages to Southeast Asia and beyond.
Looking further back, one can point to extensive contacts between the Middle Kingdom and our region to the Song and even the Tang dynasties, especially the latter which saw I Ching make his famous journeys to Srivijaya.
The possible parallels are endless - indeed, they often tell us more about the agenda and anxieties of the person who is making the comparison rather than what the China of the 21st Century and Xi might really do.
For Southeast Asia however, the important question is whether these leaders and their dynasties were net positives for our region?
Did we benefit from stronger trade and economic ties?
Did the region’s relations with China - which, let’s not forget, was essentially a “tributary” system, with the empire always on top and other nations as “barbarian” supplicants - work to our benefit?
It’s important to note that China’s relations with the region were never 100% benign or disinterested - whatever the era.
The Zheng He voyages, for instance, also included the sacking of the Srivijaya capital of Palembang in 1407, ostensibly to quell the activities of Chinese pirates in the region.
Both the Ming and Qing dynasties launched repeated incursions into Vietnam (1407-1427 as well as 1788 and 1789 respectively) and Burma (four incursions each between 1382-1449 and 1765-1769).
The level of attention Southeast Asia has gotten from China has also varied through the centuries.
The Qing emperors’ focus was often mostly, if not exclusively on their Central Asia ancestral hinterland.
Most of China’s dynasties tended to move inwards, especially towards the end of their eras.
Certainly, whatever influence China had in Southeast Asia was arguably lost to the march of Western colonialism, in tandem with its own decline and decadence.
It is also highly-significant that the 1911 Revolution, which overthrew the Qing dynasty and the Chinese monarchy was decisively-backed by Overseas Chinese in Southeast Asia, many of whom came there after the Qing’s humiliation via the Opium Wars (1839-1842 and 1856-1860) and Taiping Rebellion (1850-1871).
The point is this: Southeast Asia does not want hegemons.
We prefer a China that's strong but a little distracted by its own internal affairs.
That way, we in the region can play the Great Powers against one another. We want them to vie for our support and attention, not the other way around.
No one is denying the need to engage China: economically, politically and culturally.
But an all-powerful Xi Jinping and an emboldened China is not in Southeast Asia’s interest.
Xi’s admirers who are keen to hail him as the “new Yongzheng” should also bear in mind that the Qing Emperor's reign marked a turning point in Chinese history, as the Middle Kingdom faltered under the misguided policies that began in his era.
So while China seems on the upswing now, another stumble could well be in the offing – especially if the looming debt crisis and growing domestic income inequalities are not resolved.
Looking at history, maybe that’s not such a bad thing for Southeast Asia after all.
Follow Karim Raslan on Twitter @fromKMR / Instagram @fromkmr
Karim Raslan
Fri Dec 01 2017
China's change to constitution has made Xi Jinping the most powerful leader since Mao. Xinhua Photo
[TERKINI] Ketua Polis Negara paling lama meninggal dunia
Bekas Ketua Polis Negara, Tun Mohamed Hanif Omar, meninggal dunia pada usia 85 tahun di kediamannya di Shah Alam pada 2.15 pagi Sabtu.
Pasangan suami isteri tidak sangka dua kali tolak tawaran, masih ada rezeki tunai haji tahun ini
Selepas surat tawaran berada di dalam tangan, dia dan isteri giat membuat persiapan demi memastikan mereka memperoleh haji yang mabrur.
Lelaki bertindak bakar diri di luar Mahkamah New York
Seorang lelaki bertindak membakar dirinya di luar mahkamah New York di mana perbicaraan bagi kes bekas presiden Amerika syarikat Donald Trump sedang berjalan
Perlu isyhtihar jika bawa lebih S$20,000
: Semua pengembara yang memasuki atau meninggalkan Singapura membawa mata wang fizikal dan instrumen boleh niaga (CBNI) dengan nilai lebih 20 Ribu Dolar Singapura atau bersamaan dalam mata wang asing.
Pengisytiharan CBNI ini supaya membantu usaha Singapura membanteras aktiviti jenayah seperti pengubahan wang haram dan Keperluan sedemikian adalah kebiasaan di banyak negara.
Pengisytiharan CBNI ini supaya membantu usaha Singapura membanteras aktiviti jenayah seperti pengubahan wang haram dan Keperluan sedemikian adalah kebiasaan di banyak negara.
G7 tekad, untuk redakan perang di Asia Barat, Ukraine-Rusia
Isu peperangan di Ukraine dan Asia Barat mendominasi mesyuarat Menteri Luar Kumpulan G7,terdiri daripada Amerika Syarikat, Itali, Kanada, Perancis, Jerman, Jepun dan Britain.
Sidang kemuncak menteri luar itu berakhir sejurus selepas serangan Israel ke atas Iran dikatakan sebagai tindakan balas terhadap serangan dron dan peluru berpandu Iran baru-baru ini ke atas Israel.
Sidang kemuncak menteri luar itu berakhir sejurus selepas serangan Israel ke atas Iran dikatakan sebagai tindakan balas terhadap serangan dron dan peluru berpandu Iran baru-baru ini ke atas Israel.
Lari fokus, abai kesihatan antara masalah utama jemaah
Beberapa masalah jemaah haji Malaysia, antaranya terlalu tumpukan kepada ibadat sunat dan abai soal kesihatan dikumpul hasil pemerhatian bekas petugas Tabung Haji (TH) sepanjang lebih 30 tahun berkhidmat. Namun, semua masalah ditangani secara bijak oleh petugas TH yang menggalas tanggungjawab.
Bekas Ketua Polis Negara Tun Hanif Omar meninggal dunia
Allahyarham difahamkan menghembuskan nafas terakhir pada jam 2.15 pagi tadi.
Kes Audrey Fang: Penyiasat temukan bukti dalam bilik hotel suspek
Peguam keluarga mangsa meminta warga Singapura itu yang tidak dinamakan di hantar ke penjara dahulu sebelum perbicaraan.
Kursus Perdana Haji secara berperingkat di seluruh negara bermula hari ini sehingga 5 Mei
TH anjur Kursus Perdana Haji secara berperingkat di seluruh negara bermula hari ini di Masjid WIlayah Persekutuan sehingga 5 Mei ini, di mana ia merupakan kursus terakhir bagi bakal jemaah haji sebagai platform ulang kaji dan pelengkap kepada kursus-kursus sebelum ini.
White House enggan komen serangan Israel ke atas Iran
Jurucakapnya White House berkata Amerika Syarikat tidak mahu komen tentang perkara itu kerana dari awal lagi mereka tidak ingin terlibat secara langsung atas perang antara Iran dan Israel, atas kerisauan peningkatan suhu konflik di Asia Barat.
Ceritalah: Sejarah berulang dengan gunung berapi Taal
Pemandangan ketika Taal meletup dan imej-imej semarak debu yang besar dan menakutkan naik ke arah langit diiringi dengan kilatan guruh dan petir yang disebarkan ke seluruh dunia oleh media sosial.
Ceritalah: Tuntutan China atas Laut China Selatan - ASEAN harus bersatu
Pada tahun 2016, pemimpin-pemimpin dunia memandang Beijing dan beliau sebagai suatu hab alternatif - bagi suatu pendekatan terhadap ekonomi dan politik global yang berprinsip dan seimbang.
Ceritalah ASEAN - Joko Anwar: Cemerlang atas usaha sendiri
Tarikannya dan citra jenakanya menyembunyikan suatu minda yang amat bekerja keras dan berfokus.
Ceritalah - Perang dadah Duterte: Rakyat suram sambut Krismas
Kerana enggan kekal diam dan menerima takdir berdarah anaknya, Normita terpaksa meninggalkan rumahnya dan sekarang tinggal bersama seorang sanak saudaranya di bahagian lain bandar itu.
Ceritalah ASEAN - Aung San Suu Kyi: Lannister atau Stark?
Aung San Suu Kyi dari Myanmar - anak seorang jeneral, mengetuai sebuah negara amat rapuh telah menjadi musuh Tatmadaw (tentera) untuk menjadi apologis atau, lebih teruk lagi, pemudah mereka.
Ceritalah ASEAN - Plastik: Patut dikekalkan atau dihapuskan?
Gabungan pendapatan dari 50 firma petrokimia teratas dalam tahun 2018 adalah ASD926.8 bilion, jauh melebihi industri penapisan berjumlah ASD400 bilion.
Ceritalah Indonesia - Jawa: Mengenai bahasa dan perpaduan
Secara berasingan, kesemua tujuh presiden Indonesia mempunyai darah Jawa - termasuk BJ Habibie kelahiran Sulawesi yang baru meninggal. BJ Habibie adalah separuh Jawa.
Ceritalah - Enam hari di laut: Suatu pelayaran di atas Nggapulu
Dari saat para penumpang menaiki feri lapan tingkat itu, Nggapulu menjadi suatu mikrokosmo republik itu sendiri.
Ceritalah Indonesia - Anak muda memberontak: Apa mereka mahu?
Antara 23 dan 30 September, Hamzah adalah salah seorang daripada ribuan pelajar yang membuat bantahan di luar Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat (DPR) menghidupkan semula ingatan pada waktu Reformasi.
Ceritalah: Gelombang kemasukan pelancong India ke Asia Tenggara
Sementara ekonomi India mungkin menghadapi kemerosotannya sendiri, pelancong dari gergasi Asia Selatan itu menjadi kuasa yang semakin perlu diiktiraf di rantau Asia Tenggara.