Smartphone app Telegram, favoured by the Islamic State (Daish) group thanks to the encrypted messaging it offers, is proving a headache for French anti-terror investigators.
The free-to-download instant messenger, which allows people to exchange messages, photos and videos in groups of up to 5,000 people, has attracted some 100 million users since its launch in 2013.
And there are a couple of features that make it particularly attractive to militants, who can not only rest assured that their private messages are out of the reach of intelligence officials, but can disperse propaganda on YouTube-like public channels.
After Daish gunmen and suicide bombers massacred 130 people in Paris in November, Telegram blocked dozens of public channels that were being used to spread extremist messages.
But Russian Internet guru Pavel Durov, who founded Telegram with his brother Nikolai, insisted that not even he has the power to intercept users' private chats.
In France, which has suffered a string of further militant assaults since the Paris carnage, investigators are still dealing with fallout from the communications of a Daish member suspected of using Telegram to direct people to carry out attacks.
Rachid Kassim, a 29-year-old Frenchman who has regularly appeared in Daish propaganda videos shot in Syria or Iraq, was able to urge some 300 contacts to commit attacks on home soil, notably publishing a list of targets and scenarios for how to carry them out.
Among his contacts were Larossi Abballa, who knifed to death a senior policeman and his partner in the Parisian suburbs in June, and two teenage extremists who slit the throat of an elderly priest in a northern French church in July.
Kassim has been back in the news this week after it emerged that female militants suspected of plotting to blow up a car filled with gas cannisters near Paris' Notre Dame cathedral were on his contact list.
Unable to get past Telegram's impenetrable encryption, the best intelligence officials can hope for is to sneak into extremist chatrooms by posing as militants -- but they're bound to attract suspicion unless they talk the talk convincingly.
"Infiltrating is possible, but you have to be a good actor and have a lot of cultural and religious awareness to get away with it," one investigator said.
$300,000 code-cracking challenge
So confident is Telegram in its encryption, it has offered up to US$300,000 to anyone who manages to crack its system.
Moreover, the app has a feature that allows users to set messages to auto-destruct, making it impossible to recover them later for use in investigations.
Even in the realm of public militant propaganda on Telegram, it is "practically impossible to track the millions of messages that are exchanged every hour", one investigator lamented.
French intelligence chief Patrick Calvar described the app in May as "the main network used by terrorists".
"We bump into encryption problems on a daily basis, as the means of communication multiply along with the amount of data that we have to gather," he said, adding that encryption is "a major question that only international conventions can decide on".
The use of such apps, which soared after Edward Snowden's revelations of mass US surveillance in 2013, has sparked debate over the balance between Internet users' right to privacy and the need for security agencies to protect the public.
Last month the interior ministers of France and Germany urged the European Commission to regulate encrypted messaging apps.
Telegram's makers said after the Paris attacks that they were "disturbed" it was being used by jihadists, but they are staunchly pro-privacy and have blasted Internet giants Facebook and Google for giving data to third parties.
French investigators say they do not even know who within the Berlin-based company they should legally petition for information that could help piecing together a case, such as confirmation that a suspect is the holder of a particular Telegram account.
"We do not know who in Telegram to send our requests to -- there is no judicial entity or legal department like there is at Apple or Microsoft," one investigator complained.
Agencies
Tue Sep 13 2016
Even the founders of Telegram insisted that they don't have the power to intercept users' private chats. - www.techspot.com/Files
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Hina anggota TLDM terkorban, polis siasat Saifuddin Shafik
Polis menyiasat pemilik akaun, Saifuddin Shafik yang dipercayai memuat naik hantaran jelik berkaitan insiden kemalangan melibatkan helikopter TLDM.
SSPA terbaik pernah diperkenalkan kerajaan - PM Anwar
Beliau berkata, usaha tersebut diharap dapat menjadi motivasi buat penjawat awam untuk meningkatkan produktiviti, dan memberikan perkhidmatan terbaik kepada rakyat.
Kes model sambilan bunuh teman lelaki: Tarikh baharu sebutan ditetap 28 Mei
Mahkamah Majistret menetapkan 28 Mei ini sebagai tarikh baharu sebutan kes seorang model sambilan wanita yang didakwa membunuh teman lelakinya.
Pantau Agenda Reformasi: Misi Break The Siege: Freedom Flotilla to Gaza
Pantau Agenda Reformasi hari ini membawakan Profesor Hubungan Antarabangsa di Fakulti Undang-Undang dan Hubungan Antarabangsa di UNISZA, Prof Dr Mohd Afandi Salleh, yang juga merupakan bekas peserta misi Flotilla ke Gaza pada 2018, berkongsi pengalamannya ketika ditahan pihak rejim Israel sewaktu misi tersebut. Antara lain perbincangan tertumpu ke arah aspek hubungan antarabangsa serta undang-undang di perairan antarabangsa.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Mindef pertimbang keperluan teliti SOP latihan udara - Mohamed Khaled
Mindef akan mempertimbangkan keperluan untuk meneliti semula SOP latihan udara membentuk formasi penerbangan lintas hormat bagi mengelak tragedi.
Keselamatan siber: Keterangkuman, kepelbagaian perkasa sumbangan wanita
Wanita harus mula memberi fokus dan penekanan terhadap keterangkuman dan kepelbagaian perspektif bagi membolehkan mereka menangani cabaran industri dengan berkesan.
Penyerang Kamal Adli dijatuhkan hukuman lebih 2 tahun oleh mahkamah Singapura
Lelaki yang menyerang pelakon Malaysia, Kamal Adli menggunakan belantan tahun lepas, dijatuhkan hukuman penjara dua tahun, empat bulan dan dua minggu.
Peruntukan pembangkang: Terserah Muhyiddin untuk persoal keikhlasan kerajaan - Fadillah
Beliau enggan melayani sindiran bekas Perdana Menteri yang juga Pengerusi Perikatan Nasional, Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin tentang isu tersebut.
SPRM jangka ada beberapa tangkapan isu tuntutan palsu anak menteri besar - Azam
SPRM akan membuat beberapa tangkapan lagi, berhubung kes melibatkan anak seorang menteri besar bagi membantu siasatan kes tuntutan palsu berjumlah RM600,000.
SPRM akan panggil beberapa lagi individu bantu siasatan
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) akan memanggil beberapa lagi individu bagi membantu siasatan dakwaan pemalsuan dokumen tuntutan berjumlah RM600,000 melibatkan lima individu termasuk anak seorang Menteri Besar.
Daesh mengaku tanggungjawab letupan di Filipina
Militan Daesh yang mempunyai pengaruh di selatan negara itu, mengesahkan menerusi Telegram, anggotanya telah meletupkan bom tersebut.
3 jalani hukuman gantung di Iraq terlibat pengeboman Daesh ragut 300 nyawa
Perdana Menteri Iraq Mohammed al-Soudani menyifatkan hukuman itu "adil" semasa pertemuan dengan keluarga mangsa.
Empat terbunuh dalam serangan di masjid di Iran
Sekurang-kurangnya empat orang terbunuh selepas dua lelaki bersenjata menyerang masjid Shah Cheragh di Shiraz, lapor Agensi Berita Jerman (dpa) memetik media Iran pada Ahad.
KKD beri perhatian bendung penyebaran ekstremis militan
Fahmi Fadzil berkata ia supaya penyebarannya tidak terus berleluasa mempengaruhi umat Islam dalam negara.
Ketua Daish mati dalam operasi AS di Syria
Presiden AS, Joe Biden berkata pada Khamis bahawa Ketua Daish, Abu Ibrahim al-Hashimi al-Qurashi membunuh diri dengan menggunakan bahan letupan ketika askar-askar unit khas AS menyerbunya di Syria.
Operasi risikan halang perkembangan ideologi pengganas - Penganalisis
Operasi risikan dan tangkapan dari pihak berkuasa yang proaktif telah berjaya menghalang perkembangan ideologi pengganas.
AS tamatkan misi pertempuran di Iraq selepas 18 tahun
Presiden Demokrat itu sedang menyelesaikan misi pertempuran Amerika dalam dua perang yang dimulakan oleh Presiden George W Bush sewaktu pentadbirannya.
Cabaran berganda ESSCom tangani COVID-19 dan keselamatan
Sejak tahun lepas, ESSCom, berdepan 'cabaran berganda yang luar daripada kebiasaannya' dalam usaha memastikan keselamatan di ESSZone terus terjamin.
Sokong, edar barangan berkaitan Daesh, penjual cendol dipenjara 16 tahun
Dia didapati bersalah atas sembilan pertuduhan, antaranya memiliki dan mengedar barangan berkaitan pengganas Daesh serta memberi sokongan kepada kumpulan itu.
Bekas penyampai televisyen Afghanistan maut dalam letupan bom kereta
Setakat ini polis masih belum mengenal pasti identiti dua lagi mangsa yang terbunuh dalam letupan itu.