India has become a battleground over the right to unrestricted Internet access, with local tech start-ups joining the front line against Facebook Inc founder Mark Zuckerberg and his plan to roll out free Internet to the country's masses.
The Indian government has ordered Facebook's Free Basics plan on hold while it decides what to do.
The program, launched in more than 35 developing countries around the world, offers pared-down web services on mobile phones, along with access to the company's own social network and messaging services, without charge.
But critics say the program, launched 10 months ago in India in collaboration with mobile operator Reliance Communications, violates principles of net neutrality, the concept that all websites on the internet are treated equally. It would put small content providers and start-ups that don't participate in it at a disadvantage, they say.
"India is a test case for a company like Facebook and what happens here will affect the roll out of this service in other smaller countries where perhaps there is not so much awareness at present," said Mishi Choudhary, a New York-based lawyer who works on technology and Internet advocacy issues.
Also at stake is Facebook's ambition to expand in its largest market outside the United States. Only 252 million out of India's 1.3 billion people have Internet access, making it a growth market for firms including Google and Facebook.
In a letter seen by Reuters, the heads of nine start-up including Paytm, backed by China's Alibaba Group, and dining app Zomato, have written to the watchdog Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) urging it to ensure Internet access was allowed without differential pricing.
The executives said in the letter, dated Tuesday, that differential pricing for Internet access would lead to a "few players like Facebook with its Free Basics platform acting as gate-keepers".
"There is no reason to create a digital divide by offering a walled garden of limited services in the name of providing access to the poor," they wrote.
Zuckerberg has got personally involved.
"We know that for every 10 people connected to the Internet, roughly one is lifted out of poverty," he wrote in The Times of India newspaper this week. "We know that for India to make progress, more than 1 billion people need to be connected to the Internet.
"What reason is there for denying people free access to vital services for communication, education, healthcare, employment, farming and women’s rights?"
BOTH SIDES
A company spokesman said the aim of Facebook's Free Basics initiative was to give people a taste of what the internet can offer. And Facebook has issued a series of full-page newspaper advertisements and set up billboard banners in an unusual and aggressive campaign to counter the protests.
"Free Basics is at risk of being banned, slowing progress towards digital equality in India," said an advertisement published in Mumbai newspapers on Wednesday, urging Internet users to support the initiative.
Launched last year in Zambia, Free Basics, earlier known as internet.org, has run in to trouble elsewhere on grounds that it infringes with the principle of net neutrality. Authorities in Egypt effectively suspended the service when a required permit was not renewed after it lapsed on Wednesday.
The regulator, TRAI, has asked Facebook and Reliance Communications to suspend Free Basics until a final policy decision is made next month.
"In a democracy you have both sides - you have Facebook spending so much on the campaign and on the other side you have internet activists making their own efforts," TRAI chairman Ram Sevak Sharma told Reuters.
"Our job is to make a policy that is in the interest of telecom operators and end users in India."
Reuters
Sun Jan 03 2016
Motorists ride past a billboard displaying Facebook's Free Basics initiative in Mumbai, India, December 30, 2015. REUTERS/Danish Siddiqui
Man City rangkul kejuaraan kali keempat berturut-turut, atasi pencapaian Man United
Kejayaan terbaru City hadir apabila mereka mengatasi West Ham 3-1 pada hari terakhir.
Sharul Aimy cipta sejarah, rangkul pingat sulung negara pada kejohanan Asia
Atlet berusia 22 tahun itu menyambar gangsa acara melombol dengan mencatatkan 14.466 mata di belakang Carlos Yulo dan Abdulaziz Mirvaliev.
KKDW peruntuk RM1.5 bil dalam RMK12 untuk pembangunan luar bandar Sarawak
Ia bagi memudahkan pelaksanaan pelbagai upaya bagi mencipta masyarakat luar bandar yang kompetitif dan meningkatkan kualiti hidup mereka.
Koperasi dinasihat jangan amal konsep Ali Baba - Saarani
Katanya, tindakan berkenaan bukan hanya merugikan, bahkan ia tidak memberi nilai tambah bagi kemajuan dan pembangunan koperasi tersebut.
Melaka bakal bina litar kereta kawalan jauh bertaraf antarabangsa
Melaka akan membina sebuah litar kereta kawalan jauh bertaraf antarabangsa di atas tapak berkeluasan sehektar berhampiran Pantai Tanjung Bidara di sini, bermula November depan.
RUU Keselamatan Dalam Talian dijangka dibentang hujung tahun ini
Rang Undang-Undang (RUU) Keselamatan Dalam Talian dijangka dibentangkan pada sidang Parlimen selewat-lewatnya hujung tahun ini, kata Timbalan Menteri Komunikasi Teo Nie Ching.
Melaka mohon KPKT bina tapak pelupusan sisa pepejal sektor ICI
Sebanyak 30-40 peratus daripada keseluruhan sisa pepejal yang dibuang ke Tapak Pelupusan Sisa Pepejal Sanitari Sungai Udang adalah sisa ICI.
Zii Jia antara rakan pencetus semangat untuk terus berjuang - Jin Wei
Pengikut media sosial pemain badminton perseorangan wanita profesional Goh Jin Wei mungkin menyedari keakrabannya dengan rakan senegara Lee Zii Jia, Soh Wooi Yik dan Lai Pei Jing.
Sambutan Hari Wesak medium tingkatkan pemahaman antara masyarakat berbilang kaum - Saraswathy
Selain dapat mengeratkan perpaduan ia juga menggalakkan masyarakat untuk lebih mengenali budaya agama lain.
Libatkan diri dalam keusahawanan satu bentuk patriotisme yang tinggi - Ewon
Menceburi bidang perniagaan dan koperasi merupakan satu bentuk patriotisme yang tinggi, menurut Menteri Pembangunan Usahawan dan Koperasi Datuk Ewon Benedick.