The High Court has set Nov 10 for a decision on the application by Datuk Azhar Azizan Harun and Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said and two others to strike out the legal suit by former Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad and four others to challenge the legitimacy of the appointments of Azhar and Azalina as Dewan Rakyat Speaker and Deputy Speaker, respectively.
Judge Datuk Ahmad Kamal Md Shahid fixed the date after hearing lengthy submissions from both parties today.
Last July 23, Dr Mahathir and his son, who is former Kedah Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Mukhriz, together with former Education Minister Dr Maszlee Malik, Kubang Pasu Member of Parliament Datuk Wira Amiruddin Hamzah and Sri Gading Member of Parliament Datuk Dr Shahruddin Md Salleh filed an originating summons to challenge the appointments of Azhar and Azalina.
The five plaintiffs also named Deputy Speaker, Datuk Mohd Rashid Hasnon and Dewan Rakyat secretary, Nizam Mydin Bacha Mydin as the third and fourth defendants.
At the outset, lawyer Amer Hamzah Arshad, representing Azhar and Mohd Rashid, submitted that his clients had acted within the powers conferred on them by the Federal Constitution and the Standing Orders of the Dewan Rakyat.
He also said that the validity of the election of Azhar and Azalina in the Dewan Rakyat could not be questioned by the court pursuant to Article 63(1) of the Federal Constitution.
Amer Hamzah said the appointment of the first defendant (Azhar) as Dewan Rakyat Speaker was in accordance with its Standing Orders while the third defendant (Mohd Rashid) had acted within the powers conferred on him at all material times and he had the right to exercise all the powers of a Speaker pursuant to Article 57(3) of the Federal Constitution and Standing Orders.
“Therefore, all decisions and rulings made by the third defendant during the Parliament sitting was final and shall not be open to appeal pursuant to Standing Order No. 43 and No. 99 of the Dewan Rakyat.
“All decisions made by the first and third defendants shall not be questioned and the originating summons should be rendered obviously unsustainable,” he said.
Lawyer Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdulla who acted for the five plaintiffs said Article 63 (1) was not an absolute barrier and the court still had jurisdiction to adjudicate any decision or ruling of the Dewan Rakyat where such decision or ruling had been made with no jurisdiction or power, and/or such decision was unlawful and when the Dewan Rakyat exceeded its constitutional or legal limit.
He also submitted that the Dewan Rakyat had no jurisdiction or power to appoint Azhar and Azalina as Dewan Rakyat Speaker and Deputy Speaker, respectively on grounds that the plaintiffs and other Members of Parliament were barred from nominating their candidates.
“There were two candidates for the respective posts as at July 13, so the debate and voting process must be held but neither debate nor voting process had been done in this particular case. Since the Dewan Rakyat had no jurisdiction or power to do what it had done on July 13, this court has the necessary jurisdiction to intervene,” he said, adding that the court should have dismissed the application by the defendants.
In the originating summons, the five plaintiffs are seeking a declaration that the Dewan Rakyat Speaker’s post has been vacant since July 13 and that the appointments of Azhar and Azalina are invalid because they are unconstitutional and/or contrary to the Federal Constitution and/or Standing Orders 3,4, 6 and 47 of the Dewan Rakyat and/or the rule of law.
The plaintiffs are also seeking a declaration that the 14-day period for each member to nominate the candidates for the Speaker and Deputy Speaker’s posts began from the date the motion to vacate the posts of Speaker and/or Deputy Speaker was passed.
They are also seeking an order for the Speaker and Deputy Speaker if the posts were vacated during a sitting, to undergo the process of nomination, debate and voting by an adequate number of MPs to make it a valid appointment process.
Among the reasons given by the plaintiffs in their summons is that the action of the third defendant (Mohd Rashid) who made the ruling after informing that there was only one candidate for the Dewan Rakyat Speaker’s post was invalid as no chance was given by Mohd Rashid and the fourth defendant (Nizam Mydin) to all MPs to nominate and/or debate or vote for the purpose of appointing the new Speaker within 14 days before the sitting could proceed.
The plaintiffs also claim that the action of the fourth defendant to proclaim and call Azhar and Azalina to take the place of Speaker and Deputy Speaker respectively was contrary to the Federal Constitution and/or Standing Orders of the Dewan Rakyat, and was therefore invalid.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Sep 22 2020
Judge Datuk Ahmad Kamal Md Shahid fixed the date after hearing lengthy submissions from both parties today. -Bernama
Baki stok simpanan air di empat empangan pada paras kritikal - NADMA
Empat empangan air di Johor, Pulau Pinang dan Kedah menunjukkan penurunan paras simpanan sumber air mentah pada paras kritikal setakat semalam susulan cuaca panas.
Pesawat Maritim Malaysia bantu padam kebakaran di Miri
Maritim Malaysia telah mengatur gerak pesawat Bombardier CL-415 miliknya, bagi membantu dalam operasi memadamkan kebakaran hutan tanah gambut secara bersepadu.
Polis tahan lelaki bakar mercun di tengah jalan raya
Polis menahan seorang pembantu bengkel yang disyaki membakar mercun di tengah jalan raya, ketika perarakan pengebumian berdekatan sebuah pasar raya di Banting, Selangor, semalam.
Usaha kumpulan minoriti serang dasar kerajaan perlu dibendung - Ahmad Zahid
Ahmad Zahid menyifatkan kumpulan minoriti itu umpama 'biawak hidup' kepada sebarang perancangan memajukan negara.
NADMA laksana pembenihan awan di Papar, Lahad Datu dan Tawau
Operasi itu dilaksanakan bagi mendapatkan sumber air mencukupi di kawasan tadahan hujan ekoran cuaca panas.
Sultan Selangor berkenan lancar Tabung Pembangunan Ehsan Selangor-Gaza
Sultan Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah hari ini berkenan melancarkan Tabung Pembangunan Ehsan Selangor-Gaza.
PADU: Keraguan pengguna patut menjadi satu mesej yang kerajaan kena faham - Pakar
Masalah itu tercetus akibat kurangnya komunikasi yang cermat dan akhirnya, ia membawa kepada pemahaman yang bersegmen dan kompleks.
Jumlah korban serangan di dewan konsert Rusia meningkat kepada 143
Jumaat lepas, sekumpulan lelaki bersenjata melepaskan tembakan rambang di Dewan Bandaraya Crocus, Krasnogorsk dalam Wilayah Moscow.
Kerjasama dua hala India-Malaysia bergantung kepada kepercayaan, kebolehpercayaan bersama - Menteri Luar
Memupuk kepercayaan dan kebolehpercayaan bersama sebagai asas untuk kerjasama dua hala antara India dan Malaysia adalah sangat penting, kata Menteri Luar India, Dr S. Jaishankar.
AWANI 7:45 [28/03/2024] - 75 peratus pemegang akaun keldai | Sakit mata, sakit hati | Bayar agihan pendapatan | Elak serbuan saat akhir
#AWANI745 malam ini bersama Essan Yahya;
1. Scammer! Dalam tiga bulan, lebih empat ribu ditahan
2. Hati jadi sakit, lambakan kereta terbiar depan rumah... Gempur745 siasat
3. PNB agih pendapatan RM0.67 bilion
4. Tambahan 300 kaunter PADU seluruh negara
1. Scammer! Dalam tiga bulan, lebih empat ribu ditahan
2. Hati jadi sakit, lambakan kereta terbiar depan rumah... Gempur745 siasat
3. PNB agih pendapatan RM0.67 bilion
4. Tambahan 300 kaunter PADU seluruh negara
Kabinet setuju mula proses pinda Akta Hasutan
Kabinet memberi persetujuan untuk memulakan proses meminda Akta Hasutan bagi mengekang provokasi terhadap isu kaum, agama dan raja (3R).
Kerajaan fokus beri rawatan terhadap individu cuba bunuh diri - Azalina
Penghapusan Seksyen 309 Kanun Keseksaan tahun lepas memberi peluang baharu, di samping menggalakkan mereka untuk dapatkan rawatan.
Dewan Rakyat kecoh: 'Saya berpuasa.. sabarlah' - Azalina
Dewan Rakyat kecoh apabila penggulangan Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said mengenai RUU Kekebalan Bidang Kuasa Negara Asing 2023 dicelah Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin.
Azalina saran guru bantu banteras jenayah seksual kanak-kanak
Warga pendidik khususnya guru disaran memberi kerjasama melaporkan kejadian jenayah seksual membabitkan kanak-kanak sekolah.
Cadangan penambahbaikan Akta 711 dijangka dibentang di Parlimen tahun ini - Azalina
Cadangan penambahbaikan bagi Akta 711 yang antara lain melibatkan mekanisme pemusatan penerimaan aduan kelakuan tidak wajar, dijadual untuk dibentangkan di Dewan Rakyat pada tahun ini.
Pembiaya litigasi pihak ketiga antara fokus RUU Kekebalan Bidang Kuasa Asing bacaan kali kedua
Tindakan ini bukan sahaja menggugat integriti sistem perundangan, tetapi juga boleh memberi kesan buruk kepada masyarakat dan negara secara keseluruhan.
Tuntutan AS$15 bilion United Tausug Citizens terhadap Sabah 'membimbangkan' - Azalina
Tuntutan sebanyak AS$15 bilion (RM70.2 bilion) yang dikemukakan oleh United Tausug Citizens (UTC) ke atas Sabah perlu ditangani dengan segera oleh Malaysia.
Tuntutan UTC: Jangan persoalkan kedaulatan Sabah dalam Malaysia - Hajiji
Sebarang tuntutan luar terhadap negeri Sabah tidak akan diiktiraf oleh kerajaan negeri mahupun rakyat.
Malaysia-UK bincang keperluan wujud mekanisme pengawalan pembiayaan ligitasi pihak ketiga
Keperluan mewujudkan mekanisme pengawalan pembiayaan litigasi pihak ketiga adalah antara inti pati perbincangan dua hala Malaysia-UK.
Cadangan gubal Akta Parlimen Berpenggal tetap masih dalam kajian - Azalina
Cadangan untuk menggubal Akta Parlimen Berpenggal Tetap masih dalam peringkat kajian terperinci, kata Menteri di Jabatan Perdana Menteri (Undang-undang dan Reformasi Institusi) Datuk Seri Azalina Othm