Universities in North America have something called the tenure system where professors are appointed and are then guaranteed academic freedom.
Once they achieve tenure, they cannot be pressured to leave their positions as an academician for any reason (well, it’s very difficult to be sacked, let’s just say that).
They can conduct unconventional research, teach in creative ways and make comments based on research and knowledge that they are considered experts in.
Basically, it gives them the confidence and assurance that they are the intellectual elite who have a responsibility to contribute to society without any prejudices.
Of course, to achieve tenure isn’t something easy and simple. The process is long and highly-scrutinised. It takes into consideration peer reviews, superiors, and so much more.
Unfortunately, there is no such system in Malaysia. Hence, our country’s academicians are never free from pressurising factors that can prejudice their work.
A few years ago, Prof. Dr. Aziz Bari was suspended from his position at the International Islamic University and subsequently lost it for statements he made on the politics of the state.
And a few months ago, Prof. Datuk Dr. Mohammad Redzuan Othman had to leave his position as UMCEDEL’s (UM Centre for Democracy and Elections) director, allegedly for research findings that were unfavourable.
His post as the dean of UM’s Faculty of Arts and Social Science was also not renewed even though he had been voted for by his colleagues.
This week, Associate Prof. Dr. Azmi Sharom from UM had to appear in court as he was charged for sedition based on a statement he made in a news article regarding the Selangor menteri besar crisis.
All this might give the impression that Malaysian academicians do not have freedom of expression. And if academicians are not given that freedom, how as a society do we progress?
In my humble opinion, be it right or wrong the statement made by an academic, he or she makes it based on the knowledge and experience as an academic.
Other people can then join the debate and discussion, hence creating an environment of intellectual discourse that will lead to a more developed society.
But maybe that is where the danger lies. Creating intellectual discourse and debate among the members of a society could breed dissent. And that, I guess, needs to be avoided at all cost.
So the best first step would be to curb the academicians and intellectuals. Then, the average people in society would not have knowledge to base their thinking on.
Prophet Muhammad once said:
“Whoever conceals knowledge would be muzzled on the Day of Resurrection with a muzzle of fire.”
He also said:
“He is not from my followers, he who does not respect his elders, who does not show mercy to the young and who does not give due right to a scholar.”
So what does that say of us as a society if we start muzzling our academics? And if even academicians are muzzled, what does that mean for us ordinary people?
Zan Azlee
Thu Sep 04 2014
If they start muzzling academics, who will be next?
Misi menamatkan kemarau Piala Thomas di Chengdu diteruskan
Menang besar atau balik, itu situasi menanti pasukan badminton lelaki negara yang berhasrat untuk mengukir nama mereka dalam sejarah.
Break the Siege Freedom: Sampai bila misi ini akan ditangguhkan?
Penangguhan sekali lagi Misi Break the Siege Freedom Flotilla to Gaza terus menimbulkan tanda tanya kepada delegasi terlibat, sampai bila ia akan ditangguhkan.
Sehingga ke saat, rakan setugas Syaff Shukri memaklumkan, belum ada sebarang keputusan daripada Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) berhubung perkara ini.
#AWANI745
#IsraelCuak
Sehingga ke saat, rakan setugas Syaff Shukri memaklumkan, belum ada sebarang keputusan daripada Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) berhubung perkara ini.
#AWANI745
#IsraelCuak
Citra MTDC - Pengukuhan struktur untuk bina ekosistem lebih dinamik
Perbadanan Pembangunan Teknologi Malaysia, MTDC meneruskan kesinambungan dalam memacu pembangunan teknologi negara, dengan melancarkan Citra MTDC, untuk mewujudkan ekosistem inovasi yang lebih dinamik.
#AWANI745
#AWANI745
348 ditahan atas pelbagai kesalahan dadah
Polis menahan 348 individu termasuk 11 wanita dalam Ops Hawk yang dijalankan di seluruh negeri ini selama tiga hari bemula Selasa.
PM Anwar pulangkan elaun Pengerusi Khazanah, tegaskan sekali lagi tidak terima gaji
Anwar berkata beliau memulangkan elaun sebagai pengerusi Khazanah Nasional Berhad yang diterimanya dan sekali lagi menegaskan tidak menerima gaji bagi jawatan Perdana Menteri.
Ringgit ditutup kukuh berbanding dolar AS
Pada 6 petang, ringgit meningkat kepada 4.7650/7710 berbanding dolar AS daripada 4.7745/7775 ketika ditutup pada Khamis.
[TERKINI] Elaun masuk akaun bank tapi saya tak mahu - PM
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim memaklumkan, beliau memulangkan semula elaun diterimanya sebagai Pengerusi Khazanah Nasional Berhad.
Usia Persaraan: KWSP disaran sediakan pinjaman untuk akaun 1 penyimpang
KWSP disaran untuk lebih kreatif bagi membantu penyimpan capai jumlah ideal untuk zaman persaraan, iaitu sekitar RM240,000.
Penganalisis Ekonomi Dr Barjoyai Bardai mencadangkan KWSP pertimbang beri pinjaman untuk akaun 1, dengan syarat ia tidak boleh diganggu.
#AWANI745
Penganalisis Ekonomi Dr Barjoyai Bardai mencadangkan KWSP pertimbang beri pinjaman untuk akaun 1, dengan syarat ia tidak boleh diganggu.
#AWANI745
MoF tiada rekod surat kelulusan Najib
Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur diberitahu, Kementerian Kewangan tidak mempunyai pengetahuan mengenai dua surat kelulusan yang ditandatangani oleh Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak selaku Menteri Kewangan.
#AWANI745
#AWANI745
Kes saman Ahmad Zahid terhadap Muhyiddin selesai secara baik
Kes saman yang difailkan Timbalan Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi terhadap bekas Perdana Menteri Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, selesai secara baik di Mahkamah Tinggi hari ini.
Sabah Memilih: SPR akan perketat SOP
Laluan khas akan disediakan bagi golongan warga emas berusia 70 tahun ke atas.
Profesor UM cabar kesahihan Akta Hasutan 1948
Pensyarah Undang-Undang Universiti Malaya, Prof Azmi Sharom memfailkan permohonan untuk mengkaji semula perlembagaan Akta Hasutan 1948 di Mahkamah Sesyen hari ini.
Akta Hasutan: Kes Azmi Sharom akan disemak semula - Gani Patail
Peguam Negara, Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail berkata, keputusan mengenai penyemakan semula itu juga akan dimuktamadkan dalam masa terdekat.