Transgenders will no longer be punished for cross-dressing following a landmark Court of Appeal ruling Friday.
A three-man panel led by Justice Mohd Hishamudin Mohd Yunus and Justices Aziah Ali and Lim Yee Lan, ruled that Section 66 of the Syariah Criminal (Negri Sembilan) Enactment 1992 violated Articles 5, 8, 9 and 10 of the Federal Constitution reported the Malaysian Insider.
The report also stated tha the case today can be set as a precedent for other states in the country. Previously, it is an offence for Muslim males to dress and behave as women.
Articles 5(1), 8(1), 8(2), 9(2) and 10(1) of the Federal Constitution ensured fundamental liberties.
The ruling comes on the heels of an appeal sought by three Muslim transgenders to have Section 66 of the Syariah Act declared unconstitutional.
They claimed the provision violates their constitutional right of freedom of expression, movement and their right to live in dignity.
“We are allowing the declaration sought by the (three) appellants and setting aside the decision of the High Court.
“A person’s dress, attire or article of clothing are a form of expression, which in our view is guaranteed under Article 10 (freedom of expression),” he said told The Star.
He also noted that the legal restriction is unreasonable as the appellants suffered from Gender Identity Disorder (GID) which caused them to dress up as women.
The verdict overturns a 2012 High Court ruling, which had dismissed the challenge by the three appellants over their arrest four years ago under the law and said the appellants must adhere to the law as they are Muslims and born male.
Muhammad Juzaili Mohd Khamis, Shukor Jani and Wan Fairol Wan Ismail had been arrested several times for violating the state enactment which led to them filing a judicial review to declare the Syariah Act unconstitutional.
According to the New Straits Times, they named as respondents the Negeri Sembilan state government, its Islamic Affairs department and director, the state Syariah enforcement chief and prosecution head.
Counsel Aston Paiva Phillip represented the appellants while Negeri Sembilan state legal advisor Iskandar Ali Dewa acted for the respondents.
Hishamudin said, the court also found that the Seremban High Court judge had made remarks and findings that were contrary to evidence and tainted by unscientific personal prejudice.
The judge had said that Section 66 would help protect society from homosexual activities that resulted in the spread of HIV.
“The High Court’s remarks are unsupported by, and contrary to, evidence and is tainted by unscientific personal feelings or personal prejudice.
“We wish to stress here that such reasoning is without basis and grossly unfair to the appellants and other male sufferers of GID.
“The present case has absolutely nothing to do with homosexuality. This case is about male Muslims with a medical condition called GID,” Hishamudin told the Malaysian Insider.
He added the judge had also failed to acknowledge medical evidence presented before her.
State authorities had also failed to rebut the medical report presented by psychiatrist Dr Ang Jin Kiat and the expert opinion of consultant psychiatrist Dr Deva Dass on the medical condition.
“The state mufti had tendered his opinion when the dispute landed in the court.
“We wish to make it clear that whether or not Section 66 is consistent with the percepts of Islam is not an issue with the present case,” Hishamudin said.
According to the medical report, the appellants were diagnosed with GID, had undergone hormone treatment and went by feminine names in their daily lives.
“According to psychiatrists, they are actually female in spirit, trapped in a male body and so they cross-dress,” Phillip told the Malaysian Insider.
He added this was not the choice of his clients and that the GID would be etched to them for the rest of their lives.
Astro Awani
Fri Nov 07 2014
Three Muslim transgenders claimed the Syariah Act violated their right to live in dignity. - AFP Photo/Mohd Rasfan
Ada wajah kita tak mahu berpisah, tapi terpaksa melepaskannya - Datuk Red
Menerusi perkongsian itu, Adnan mengatakan ada perkara yang dia terpaksa reda dan menerima takdir yang sudah tertulis untuknya.
Komen jelik nahas helikopter Lumut, peniaga didenda RM23,000
Seorang peniaga dalam talian didenda RM23,000 di Mahkamah Sesyen di sini, selepas mengaku bersalah atas tuduhan memuat naik komen jelik berhubung nahas helikopter TLDM.
Bursa Malaysia dibuka rendah, jejaki prestasi Wall Street
Pada 9.10 pagi, FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI (FBM KLCI) susut 2.29 mata kepada 1,566.96 daripada 1,569.25 ketika ditutup pada Khamis.
AWANI Ringkas: Pesawat ringan mendarat cemas di Subang
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Cambodia Airways mulakan penerbangan terus Phnom Penh-Kuala Lumpur
Syarikat penerbangan Kemboja, Cambodia Airways, secara rasmi memulakan penerbangan terus dari ibu negaranya, Phnom Penh ke KLIA pada Khamis.
Semangat baharu bina ekosistem inovasi lebih dinamik
Perbadanan Pembangunan Teknologi Malaysia, MTDC meneruskan kesinambungan dalam memacu pembangunan teknologi negara, dengan melancarkan Citra MTDC, untuk mewujudkan ekosistem inovasi yang lebih dinamik.
Polis tahan guru disyaki liwat tiga pelajar
Tiga pelajar tahfiz dipercayai menjadi mangsa seks luar tabii apabila didakwa diliwat seorang guru agama dari pusat tahfiz berkenaan sejak dua tahun lalu.
Rumah Terbuka Aidilfitri Selangor di KKB langgar Akta - Bersih
Penganjuran Rumah Terbuka Aidilfitri Peringkat Negeri Selangor yang akan dianjurkan di Pekan Kuala Kubu Bharu Sabtu ini, boleh bercanggah dengan banyak peruntukan dalam Akta Kesalahan Pilihan Raya 1954 (AKPR).
Elak bergantung pada sumber lain, kukuhkan literasi kewangan
Menurut Pengarah Pusat Penyelidikan Keselamatan Sosial, Universiti Malaya, Prof. Datuk Dr Norma Mansor, pendidikan literasi kewangan dalam kalangan masyarakat juga perlu ditingkatkan agar rakyat Malaysia lebih peka terhadap keperluan merancang kewangan mereka.
Teroka pasaran baharu, tingkat perdagangan serantau
Selain lebih banyak perjanjian perdagangan bebas (FTA), beliau turut melihat perdagangan dalam kalangan ASEAN juga wajar diberi penekanan yang lebih lagi.