The Federal Court’s recent ruling over the test for locus standi, where a person now needs at least a genuine interest in an issue but not longer needs to prove to have his rights affected by it, shows that the country would be seeing an increase of public interest in litigation.
Lawyer Syahredzan Johan said this is especially true when it comes to judicial reviews.
“This is a positive development as the decision shows that we are a society that are maturing and we want to hold the government accountable,” Syahredzan told Astro AWANI.
Syahredzan said the civil society is definitely ready to pursue matters of public interest actively in the court of law, but there are other factors to be considered such as the cost of litigation.
“As long as someone who wants to take action in court can take care of the cost, he can bring the matter to court.
“However, this does not mean that the floodgate of people demanding for judicial review has been opened. This is because, at the end of the day, the decision cannot be utilized for ‘any flimsy reason’.
“Having a genuine interest in the case is still the first hurdle in any case. It just makes it that much more easier for people to satisfy the locus standi, that’s all,” he said.
Another lawyer Yusmadi Yusoff echoed this sentiment saying that public interest was used as a benchmark in the court’s decision.
“The decision shows that the public interest factor has moved a step further . It is a decision that is welcomed,” he said.
However, Yusmadi cautioned that the decision should be used constructively.
“This means even if a person who shows a genuine interest in a particular issue can take legal action, there are still other procedures to be followed.
“The decision benefits those who are involved in public litigation and needs attention from NGOs and activists,” he said.
On Wednesday, the Federal Court had reviewed the test for locus standi, ruling that a person needs at least a genuine interest in an issue but not longer needs to prove to have his rights affected by it.
The Federal Court came to the findings when deciding over a suit between Malaysian Trades Union Congress (MTUC) against the Government for access to the concessionaire agreement involving Syarikat Bekalan Air Selangor Sdn Bhd (Syabas) and an audit report.
Justices Datuk Hasan Lah ruled that for an applicant to pass the “adversely affected” test, the applicant has to at least show that he has a real and genuine interest in the subject matter.
“However, it is not necessary for the applicant to establish infringement of a private right or the suffering of special damage,” said Justice Hasan.
The panel also set aside the test of locus standi (legal standing) as per the 1988 Supreme Court decision in the case of Lim Kit Siang versus United Engineers (M) Bhd, where Lim asked for a declaration that the letter of intent issued by the government to UEM to construct the North-South Highway was invalid.
The Supreme Court had ruled Lim had no locus standi as he had failed to show that his private right had been infringed or he had suffered a special damage.
However, the panel unanimously upheld the Court of Appeal’s decision to deny MTUC access to the documents as the Audit Report was an official secret document, on the ground that it was tabled before and deliberated by the Cabinet.
The five-man bench, which also included Chief Justice Tun Arifin Zakaria, Chief Judge of Malaya Justice Tan Sri Zulkefli Ahmad Makinudin, Justices Datuk Hashim Yusoff and Datuk Suriyadi Halim Omar, made no order to costs as the case was of public interest.
The applicants (MTUC and the 12) had on Jan 15, 2007, applied for a judicial review for accessing the concessionaire agreement between Syarikat Bekalan Air Selangor (Syabas) and the Federal and state governments.
On June 28, 2010, the High Court allowed their judicial review, ruling that the disclosure of the documents would not be detrimental to national or public interest.
However, on Feb 25, 2011, the Court of Appeal, in a 2-1 majority decision, overruled the High Court’s decision and held that MTUC and the 12 water consumers did not have the legal right of access to the audit report and water concession agreement.
T K Letchumy Tamboo
Thu Feb 13 2014
KBS kembali beri tumpuan ke sekolah
Kementerian Belia dan Sukan akan berbincang dengan Kementerian Pendidikan dalam usaha melahirkan lebih ramai atlet berpotensi pada masa depan.
“Saya tak benarkan Diana buat bariatrik” - Farid Kamil
Farid lebih yakin hanya cara semula jadi lebih selamat untuk menurunkan berat badan.
Pemandu bas kilang ditahan, rempuh penunggang motosikal sehingga maut
Mangsa meninggal dunia di tempat kejadian selepas mengalami kecederaan parah di kepala.
Gagal capai sasaran, kerajaan tak boleh pandang ringan
Kegagalan Kerajaan untuk mencapai sasaran 30 juta pendaftar menjelang hujung bulan 3 ini harus dijadikan sebagai satu isyarat bahawa masih ada segelintir yang skeptikal tentang sistem Pangkalan Data Utama (PADU).
Kerajaan harus ambil cakna tentang keraguan orang ramai tentang sistem PADU sebagai satu mesej.
Menurut Presiden Persatuan Pengguna Siber Malaysia, Siraj Jali, masalah ini tercetus akibat kurangnya komunikasi yang cermat dan akhirnya,ia tercetus sebuah pemahaman yang bersegmen dan kompleks.
Kerajaan harus ambil cakna tentang keraguan orang ramai tentang sistem PADU sebagai satu mesej.
Menurut Presiden Persatuan Pengguna Siber Malaysia, Siraj Jali, masalah ini tercetus akibat kurangnya komunikasi yang cermat dan akhirnya,ia tercetus sebuah pemahaman yang bersegmen dan kompleks.
Arab Saudi dipilih pengerusikan Suruhanjaya Status Wanita (CSW) ke-69
Arab Saudi dipilih sebulat suara pada Rabu untuk mempengerusikan badan wanita Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu, Suruhanjaya Status Wanita (CSW).
Tokoh Wartawan Negara 2014, meninggal dunia
2014, Datuk Ahmad Rejal Arbee meninggal dunia di kediamannya 2 pagi Jumaat
ICJ arah Israel ambil tindakan atasi kebuluran di Gaza
ICJ berkata, rakyat Palestin di Gaza menghadapi keadaan hidup yang teruk, kelaparan dan kebuluran semakin meruncing.
Penipuan kewangan: Pengasas FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried dipenjara 25 tahun
Pengasas FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried dijatuhi hukuman penjara 25 tahun kerana penipuan mata wang kripto yang disifatkan sebagai salah satu penipuan kewangan terbesar dalam sejarah Amerika Syarikat.
OIC perlu tubuh pasukan pengaman
OIC perlu menubuhkan pasukan pengaman bagi menangani isu-isu berbangkit seperti penindasan ke atas rakyat Palestin.
Kekejaman zionis: PM Mustafa bentuk kabinet baharu Palestin
Perdana Menteri Palestin, Mohammad Mustafa membentuk kabinet baharu di mana beliau juga akan berkhidmat sebagai Menteri Luar.
Politik Sabah: GRS adalah parti politik maka Hajiji ada parti - Masidi Manjun
Kenyataan mengelirukan mengenai dakwaan Ketua Menteri Sabah, Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor tidak berparti selepas meninggalkan Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (Bersatu) merupakan kenyataan tidak berasas.
Hakim tarik diri, rayuan Anwar terhadap saman berkaitan pengampunan ditangguh
Pendengaran rayuan tersebut hari ini di hadapan panel tiga hakim Mahkamah Rayuan telah ditangguhkan.
Azmin Ali, Zahid Md Arip gagal cabar laporan AG mengenai 1MDB
Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali dan Muhammad Zahid Md Arip hari ini gagal mencabar tindakan Ketua Audit Negara mengklasifikasikan laporan audit 1MDB sebagai rahsia rasmi.
Anina tiada hak perundangan saman Najib berhubung derma RM2.6 bilion - Peguam
Anina bukan seorang pegawai awam UMNO dan oleh itu tidak mempunyai locus standi untuk memfailkan saman mengikut Seksyen 9(c) Akta Pertubuhan 1966.