The International Monetary Fund on Wednesday admitted to significant failures in the first Greek rescue that forced a second, larger bailout and left the country in a deep recession.
However, the global lender placed much of the blame on its Greek and European partners, saying they were unprepared for the crisis and the harsh choices -- including a deep debt restructuring -- that may have made the first bailout work better.
The IMF said in a review of the 2010 rescue that it overestimated both Greece's debt sustainability and Athens's ability to implement structural reforms.
It said there were some problems coordinating with the European Commission and the European Central Bank, its troika partners in the 110 billion euro ($144 billion) program, and that they lacked expertise and harmonized goals.
The European Commission was more focused on European issues than the Greek situation alone, it said.
"The Fund's program experience and ability to move rapidly in formulating policy recommendations were skills that the European institutions lacked," it added.
The IMF, which has been assailed by member countries for committing huge funds to what some fear is an open-ended rescue, defended its actions as necessary to keep the Greek crisis from spreading through Europe and elsewhere.
"Given the danger of contagion, the report judges the program to have been a necessity, even though the Fund had misgivings about debt sustainability," it said.
At the time there was "a tension between the need to support Greece and the concern that debt was not sustainable with high probability."
That forced the Fund to lower its own standards to approve the bailout, but even then, it admitted, it used data that was too optimistic.
The result was the much more drastic second rescue last year, which included the sweeping debt restructuring rejected the first time around.
"There were also notable failures. Market confidence was not restored, the banking system lost 30 percent of its deposits, and the economy encountered a much deeper-than-expected recession with exceptionally high unemployment," the review said.
"Public debt remained too high and eventually had to be restructured... Competitiveness improved somewhat on the back of falling wages, but structural reforms stalled and productivity gains proved elusive."
The IMF's mea culpa came in the wake of an earlier admission that the troika's push for tough austerity to radically reduce Athens' deficit was based on poor assumptions that have left the country in a protracted recession.
In the past several months the IMF has urged the European Commission and the European Central Bank to ease some of the austerity conditions of the second bailout to try and turn the Greek economy around.
In a remarkable admission, the Fund said the troika members had significant problems harmonizing their aims and roles, in part due to the Europeans' lack of experience in sovereign rescues.
"The Greek program was also subject to considerable uncertainty as the euro area policy response evolved," it said.
"For example, the initial euro area position that debt restructuring was off the table was eventually reversed, although this took a considerable length of time."
There was no clarity over which troika member was responsible for what, and the European Commission was more focused on ensuring compliance with EU standards than on figuring out how to revive Greek growth, the review said.
But the two sides were also understandably split on their focus, as the IMF traditionally deals only with single country economies in its rescues.
Meanwhile the European authorities, with Greece a member of the single currency union, "emphasized the extent of possible spillover effects within Europe."
The IMF also pointed to the European Union's bureaucratic approach.
"The EC tended to draw up policy positions by consensus, had enjoyed limited success with implementing conditionality under the Stability and Growth Pact, and had no experience with crisis management," it said.
AFP
Wed Jun 05 2013
Siklon Hidaya hampiri Tanzania
Tanzania berada dalam keadaan berjaga-jaga pada Sabtu apabila Siklon Hidaya bergerak menghampiri kawasan pantai, membawa bersamanya hujan lebat, angin kencang dan ancaman ribut.
Polis buru dua suspek kes tembak di Pasir Mas
Polis sedang memburu dua suspek disyaki terlibat dalam kes tembakan di Kampung Alor Pinggan, Gelang Mas, awal pagi tadi.
Kabinet belum bincang kenaikan harga petrol dan diesel, laporan media asing tidak betul - Fahmi
Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil hari ini berkata Kabinet belum berbincang mengenai kenaikan harga minyak petrol dan diesel.
Piala Thomas: China buat kemarau 10 tahun Malaysia ke final berterusan
Penantian 10 tahun skuad badminton negara untuk ke final Piala Thomas berterusan apabila tewas 1-3 kepada China dalam aksi separuh akhir di Chengdu sebentar tadi.
AWANI 7:45 [04/05/2024] – Warisi banyak hutang | Terhempas di kawasan ladang | Keadaan cuaca tidak menentu | Pergaduhan dua kumpulan
Laporan berita padat dan ringkas #AWANI745 bersama Irfan Faruqi
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- PM dedah ada pemimpin tak puas hati kenaikan gaji penjawat awam
- Pesawat terhempas, semua terselamat
- Panas melampau di utara, banjir di selatan, cuaca terkini di Malaysia
- 28 lelaki ditahan pergaduhan dua kumpulan di Butterworth
Tumpuan #AWANI745 malam ini:
- PM dedah ada pemimpin tak puas hati kenaikan gaji penjawat awam
- Pesawat terhempas, semua terselamat
- Panas melampau di utara, banjir di selatan, cuaca terkini di Malaysia
- 28 lelaki ditahan pergaduhan dua kumpulan di Butterworth
Wan Azizah ingatkan ahli PKR bersatu teruskan perjuangan parti
Dr Wan Azizah berkata peringatan tersebut penting kerana perpecahan boleh merosakkan parti yang ditubuhkan dengan semangat reformasi itu.
KBS masih kenal pasti lokasi sesuai bina velodrom terbuka - Hannah
Sukan berkenaan merupakan antara yang menyerlah serta menyumbang pingat di kejohanan dalam dan luar negara.
Fakulti AI pertama negara dirasmikan 10 Mei ini - Zambry
Di peringkat permulaan, Fakulti Kecerdasan Buatan bermula di UTM dan ada juga konsortium dengan universiti yang lain juga.
Cabang eksekutif harus putuskan untuk keluarkan perkataan 'negeri' daripada DUN Sarawak - Speaker
Cabang eksekutif Sarawak harus memutuskan sama ada mengeluarkan perkataan 'negeri' daripada Dewan Undangan Negeri Sarawak, kata Speaker Tan Sri Mohamad Asfia Awang Nassar.
PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu: Calon Bebas lancar manifesto, kemuka 20 tawaran
Calon Bebas Nyau Ke Xin hari ini melancarkan manifesto Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu (KKB) yang mengandungi 20 tawaran.
EU setuju luaskan sekatan ke atas Iran
Menurut Ketua Dasar Luar EU, Josep Borrell, perkara itu dipersetujui mesyuarat Menteri Luar blok tersebut.
Dunia rekodkan suhu terpanas sejak 1850
Punca utama haba luar biasa adalah pelepasan gas rumah hijau yang disebabkan oleh manusia, kata Perkhidmatan Perubahan Iklim Copernicus EU.
Mampukah EU selamatkan hutan dan pastikan pekerjaan di Malaysia terjamin?
Langkah EU melarang sebarang aktiviti import barangan yang dikaitkan dengan penebangan hutan dianggap sebagai standard baharu yang bagus untuk iklim, bagi sesetengah pihak.
Lawatan PM ke Jerman: Awali Ramadan dengan misi pelaburan
Kunjungan ke Jerman merupakan lawatan balas kepada Scholz yang melawat Malaysia pada Februari tahun lalu.
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Antara pelbagai berita luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
EU denda Apple RM9.2 bilion, salah guna kawalan App Store
Apple melalui terbitan akhbar, menyatakan mereka akan melakukan rayuan terhadap keputusan ini.
Apple akan didenda AS$500 juta oleh EU kerana amalan anti persaingan
Kini menurut laporan Financial Times, EU akan mengenakan denda $500 juta ke atas Apple atas amalan anti persaingan mereka.
Malaysia di landasan tepat untuk dapat pengiktirafan MSPO daripada EU - TPM Fadillah
Malaysia berada di landasan tepat untuk mendapat 'lampu hijau' daripada Kesatuan Eropah (EU) bagi mengiktiraf piawaian Pensijilan Minyak Sawit Mampan Malaysia (MSPO) dalam masa terdekat.
Peralihan tenaga: Malaysia komited kerjasama dengan EU - Fadillah
Malaysia menyatakan komitmennya untuk bekerjasama dengan Kesatuan Eropah (EU) khususnya dalam pemindahan teknologi untuk peralihan tenaga dan keselamatan air di negara ini.
Malaysia sambut baik cadangan EU anjur persidangan keamanan antarabangsa mengenai konflik Palestin-Israel
Malaysia menyambut baik cadangan Kesatuan Eropah (EU) untuk mengadakan persidangan keamanan antarabangsa mengenai konflik Palestin-Israel.