The statement below is reproduced from Dr. Ong Kian Ming's blog.
More than a month ago, on the 11th of June, 2016, the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Malaya was alerted of alleged academic misconduct on the part of some faculty members who were authors / co-authors in a number of scientific publications.
To its credit, the University quickly convened an investigation and found that ‘there were duplication and / or manipulation of almost all the figures (images and graphs) within the original Scientific Reports paper and across three other publications authored by the group of researchers” and called for the authors to retract all four articles.[
The articles were subsequently retracted by the journals in question.
The university’s quick and decisive action sends a strong signal that research fraud is not tolerated in our national research universities and it should be applauded accordingly.
MUST READ: Asia University Rankings: UM up two positions from last year
But larger questions regarding academic integrity and academic fraud remain unanswered.
For example, this specific case of academic fraud was discovered not by an internal probe within the university but because of scrutiny by academics and researchers from outside the country.
The allegations which were first highlighted on twitter was then picked up by blogs such as Microbiome Digest, For Better Science and Science.
MUST READ: Malaysian boys "missing" from our public universities
Elisabeth Bik, a Stanford researcher who recently co-authored a paper titled “The Prevalence of Inappropriate Image Duplication in Biomedical Research Publications”, suggested on Microbiome Digest that not only were the images duplicated within each paper, but that the figures look very similar across papers (despite the papers being about different cancer cells and different compounds!) (see Graphic 1).
Without such scrutiny, would this academic fraud have been discovered?
In addition, were the authors in all four papers (other than Nina Samie who was the lead author in all of the papers) aware that the same study was replicated thrice and submitted to four different journals under different titles?
Was there academic fraud not just in terms of the content published but also in the manner in which the different co-authors may have been duped or worse yet, were complicit partners in this scandal?
What is disconcerting is that this specific case may be the tip of the iceberg of what is poor academic integrity and honesty in our higher education system.
While I believe that a large majority of the 3823 papers which were published by UM students and staff in indexed journals have been done with academic integrity and honesty, it only takes a few bad apples to spoil the barrel.
I have heard of instances of junior faculty and researchers being forced to include the names of their supervisors on academic papers even though their supervisors did not contribute any significant intellectual input or work.
Some supervisors even insist of being named as first author which implies that he or she took the leading role and did much of the work for the publication in question.
MUST READ: Malaysian girls are 'missing' from the job market
In some worse cases of academic fraud, some senior academics even refuse to allow the junior faculty or researcher to put their name in the publication thus claiming all the intellectual credit for himself or herself.
It is not sufficient for UM to merely issue a press statement on this specific instance of academic fraud.
As the oldest and arguably most prestigious academic institution in Malaysia, it should take a leading role when it comes to upholding standards of academic integrity and intellectual honesty.
As such, I call upon the University of Malaya to publish the full proceedings of its internal investigation into this matter and to recommend changes to existing guidelines so these kinds of cases do not happen again.
In addition, UM should also disclose the exact nature of the punishment meted out to the researchers in question so as to send a strong signal to other faculty of the serious consequences of academic fraud.
In addition, I call upon the Minister of Higher Education, Datuk Seri Idris Jusoh, to conduct a comprehensive review of the High Impact Research (HIR) initiative between his Ministry and the University of Malaya.
MUST READ: Ministry to investigate claims of Bangladesh gunmen studying in Malaysia
The authors of three of the papers received two research grants from this initiative which is a collaboration between the Ministry of Education and the University of Malaya to fund projects that will lead to publications in Tier 1 ISI/Web of Science journals.
According to the UM 2014 annual report, the Ministry of Education (MoE) has injected RM590 million into the programme, with additional funding from UM, to fund research projects up till 2016.
Given the large amount of funds dedicated to this initiative and that the fact that two of its research projects were found to be academically fraudulent, it is in the public interest for the funding for all the projects under this initiative to be publicly disclosed and reviewed.
If the Minister is serious about ensuring that our higher education system is ‘Soaring Upwards’, he should take this matter seriously and not try to cover things up.
Dr. Ong Kian Ming is the Member of Parliament for Serdang.
The views expressed here are strictly those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Astro AWANI.
Ong Kian Ming
Tue Jul 26 2016
Is the recent allegation of academic misconduct at a top Malaysian university merely the tip of the iceberg?
Pemilik stesen minyak didenda RM30,000 jual RON95 kepada kenderaan asing
Hakim menjatuhkan hukuman itu ke atas Mohammad Naziruddin Abu Hassan, 61, selaku Orang Kena Saman (OKS) selepas mengaku bersalah atas pertuduhan itu.
Komen jelik tentang nahas helikopter TLDM, peniaga didenda RM23,000
Seorang peniaga dalam talian didenda RM23,000 oleh Mahkamah Sesyen Taiping pada Jumaat, selepas mengaku bersalah atas tuduhan memuat naik komen jelik berhubung nahas helikopter milik Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia (TLDM) di Lumut, yang mengorbankan 10 mangsa.
Lima laluan ditutup sementara sempena hari penamaan calon PRK KKB esok
Jalan yang terlibat bagi penutupan sementara itu ialah Jalan Merdeka, Jalan Abdul Hamid, Jalan Dato Muda Jaafar, Jalan Mat Kilau dan Jalan Kamarudin.
[TERKINI] Mahasiswa bersama Palestin
Sekumpulan mahasiswa Universiti Malaya yang berang dengan tindakan Institut Pengajian China, Universiti Malaya (UM) menjemput individu pro-Zionis untuk menyampaikan seminar ilmiah, akhirnya turun berdemonstrasi bagi menyuarakan bantahan mereka terhadap Zionis dan sokongan mereka terhadap perjuangan membebaskan Palestin.
#AWANInews
#AWANInews
[TERKINI] Sarjana ‘berkualiti rendah’ tak patut dijemput - PM Anwar
Universiti Malaya sebelum ini menerima kecaman kerana membenarkan Gilley menyebarkan propaganda Zionis dan menuduh ahli politik Malaysia yang menyokong perjuangan Palestin menyebarkan kebencian terhadap Yahudi.
AWANI Ringkas: Peniaga didenda RM23,000, komen jelik nahas
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Thailand, 17 lagi negara gesa pembebasan segera tawanan di Gaza
Pemimpin 18 negara dalam satu kenyataan bersama menggesa pembebasan segera semua tawanan termasuk warganegara mereka sendiri yang ditahan Hamas di Gaza.
Kes jongkong emas: Saibulrijal didakwa lagi guna dokumen palsu
Mohd Saibulrijal Mohd Saad, 46, mengaku tidak bersalah selepas semua pertuduhan dibaca di hadapan Hakim, Azrul Darus.
TSMC akan hasilkan cip 1.6nm menjelang 2026
Menurut TSMC, teknologi 1.6mm akan memberikan peningkatan prestasi sehingga 8-10% untuk voltan yang sama serta pengurangan penggunaan kuasa antara 15-20% pada kelajuan yang sama.
Anak syarikat SPNB berdepan tindakan penggulungan
Syarikat Wiradani Development Sdn Bhd telah menyerahkan notis untuk menggulung SPNB Aspirasi pada 3 Mei tahun lepas.