Amid the largest refugee crisis in Europe since the Balkan Wars of the 1990s, a tide of thousands of asylum-seekers is reaching the continent's shores faster than they can be accommodated.
So far, the European Union's 28 nations have been unable to agree on a solution. Ahead of a European Commission proposal Wednesday for a system to spread asylum-seekers across all E.U. countries, here are a few of the options Europe is considering:
1) Doing nothing.
Europe tried to make a plan to share out refugees earlier in the summer. At the time, they were talking about only 40,000 people. But that failed after many countries, especially in eastern and central Europe, bridled at being required to take in a set number of refugees. Now the proposal is expected to be triple that — amid deep doubts about nations' ability to come to an agreement.
Pros: Few, but that doesn't mean it won't happen. Each European leader answers to his or her own electorate, which sometimes makes broad E.U. deals very difficult. The status quo is good for countries that don't like refugees and under current E.U. rules can deport asylum-seekers back to the first E.U. country they entered. That's almost always Greece, Italy or Hungary, which are buckling under the influx.
Cons: "If Europe fails on the question of refugees, then it won't be the Europe we wished for," said German Chancellor Angela Merkel, who has thrown open her nation's doors to asylum-seekers. She warned that without a Europe-wide plan, individual nations might need to reimpose border controls, a major blow to European unity. And with some nations far more generous to refugees than others, human smugglers will prosper, ferrying asylum-seekers to Germany and Sweden, with potentially tragic consequences.
2) Quotas.
This is what European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker will propose Wednesday. He'll suggest relocating 120,000 asylum-seekers from the front-line nations of Greece, Italy and Hungary and spreading them across Europe, according to European accounts of the draft plans. Together, Germany, France and Spain would take more than half of them, according to a rough draft published by Spain's El Pais newspaper. The remainder would be spread across the rest of Europe.
Pros:It would help reduce the burden on those three European nations that are on the edges of the European Union and have buckled under the weight of the more than 400,000 asylum-seekers who have arrived so far this year. And though the proposal would fall far short of the numbers needed to address the full scale of the problem, it would still set up a system that could later be expanded. Nations that have resisted hosting refugees, such as Slovakia, may be able to send money instead as a compromise measure.
"Considering the current politics, it is the most pragmatic idea on the table right now," said Elizabeth Collett, the director of the Brussels-based Migration Policy Institute Europe.
Cons: It's a drop in the bucket. Germany plans to take in 800,000 asylum-seekers this year, and says it's ready for 500,000 a year for the next several years. Facing those numbers, the E.U. plan simply doesn't do enough. And there are many thorny questions to work out: What happens when an asylum-seeker who has family in France gets assigned to Lithuania instead? In a Europe without borders, how would policymakers ensure the refugees stay put? And what happens to asylum-seekers who arrive beyond the quotas? Do they pile up in refugee camps on Europe's edges, or do they simply keep pushing through to Western Europe?
And many nations, especially in Eastern and Central Europe, are opposed to quotas.
"I do not consider them any real solution to the migration crisis," Czech Prime Minister Bohuslav Sobotka said Monday, according to the Czech News Agency.
3) Military action against the smugglers who bring help refugees get to Europe.
Britain and others have been pushing for U.N. Security Council authorization to deploy navies to board and intercept the flimsy boats that set sail across the Mediterranean from Libya and Egypt to Europe's shores. The boats, operated by human smugglers, are dangerous, frequently sinking during the passage. More than 2,700 migrants have died this year.
Pros: The plan would discourage the smugglers, who often have ties to organized crime and profit tremendously from the some of the world's most vulnerable populations. Fewer boats crossing the Mediterranean would reduce the immediate crisis for Europe and might discourage some of the economic migrants coming illegally from Africa and South Asia. And a stepped-up naval presence in the Mediterranean might make search-and-rescue operations more successful when smugglers' ships capsize.
Cons: Stopping smugglers doesn't address the root causes of the refugee crisis. It just displaces the burden to other countries. And in some ways, these plans are a solution to yesterday's problem. Over the course of this year, the bulk of migrant traffic to Europe has shifted westward to the Balkans: asylum-seekers make a short sea hop from Turkey to nearby Greek islands, then travel to Western Europe overland through Macedonia, Serbia and Hungary. The naval plans wouldn't do anything about that at all.
4) Resettling refugees directly from camps surrounding Syria, and from Syria.
Remember "Schindler's List?" Or the U.S. efforts to resettle refugees from Vietnam in the 1970s? This would be the 21st-century equivalent, more or less: E.U. diplomats handing out visas on the ground in the countries where more than 4 million Syrian refugees have settled.
Pros:This is arguably the most humane option, since it would make an end-run around smugglers. Refugees could simply get on a plane from Turkey, Lebanon or Jordan and fly straight to Europe, saving the danger of a smuggled, overland trip that sometimes costs up to $10,000. It's what British Prime Minister David Cameron suggested Monday when he said Britain would take in 20,000 Syrian refugees directly from the Middle Eastern camps over the next five years.
"We want to encourage people not to make that dangerous crossing in the first place," Cameron said.
Cons: Realistically, there's little political support in Europe to do this on a scale that would actually relieve pressure on the camps. Cameron's commitment over the next five years is equivalent to what Germany took in this weekend alone. And it's not clear that handing out visas in the region would stop the separate overland flow to Europe. That's because the most vulnerable refugees typically jump to the front of the line for resettlement schemes such as the British one. The asylum-seekers currently coming to Europe by land are the ones with the resources to pay a sometimes hefty price to smugglers.
"When you are facing a humanitarian disaster, when you are facing the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, when you say, 'I think we can resettle 25 people,' people would just laugh in your face," said Elspeth Guild, a migration specialist at the Brussels-based Center for European Policy Studies
5) Bring peace to Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq and Eritrea.
Those are the conflict-ridden countries that are supplying the bulk of the asylum-seekers to Europe. If there wasn't violence there, Europe wouldn't have a refugee problem.
Pros:Everyone's happy.
Cons: Not going to happen anytime soon.
The Washington Post
Wed Sep 09 2015
With some nations far more generous to refugees than others, human smugglers will prosper, ferrying asylum-seekers to Germany and Sweden.
SPR India tuntut maklum balas aduan terhadap Modi, Rahul Gandhi
Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya India hari ini memaklumkan pihaknya sudah meminta maklum balas daripada parti pemerintah Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) dan parti pembangkang, Kongres.
Penguin maharaja berdepan kepupusan akibat pencairan ais
Spesies penguin terbesar di dunia, penguin maharaja terus berdepan ancaman apabila habitatnya terjejas akibat perubahan iklim. Selain pernah disifatkan bakal pupus menjelang tahun 2050, saintis dari Pusat Penyelidikan British Antarctic Survey pada Khamis memberitahu perubahan iklim memberi kesan terhadap kecairan ais di wilayah beku Antartika yang menjadi habitat buat koloni penguin maharaja.
ANCC2024: Astro, NACSA bekerjasama anjur 'coding challenge'
Diilhamkan daripada komitmen Astro dan NACSA untuk memupuk langkah keselamatan siber yang proaktif, pertandingan itu juga bertujuan untuk menormalisasikan navigasi digital yang selamat dalam ruang siber.
Suhu cecah 42 Celsius, Bangladesh tutup semua sekolah sehingga Sabtu ini
Suhu panas melampau sehingga mencecah 42 Celcius memaksa kerajaan Bangladesh menutup operasi persekolahan yang melibatkan 33 juta pelajar di negara itu.
PM Haiti serah surat peletakan jawatan
Perdana Menteri Haiti, Ariel Henry akhirnya menyerahkan surat peletakan jawatan pada Khamis selepas tidak henti berdepan tekanan antarabangsa bagi mengawal kekacauan kumpulan pengganas di negara itu. Surat rasmi peletakan jawatan yang ditandatangani Ariel Henry diserahkan di Los Angeles dan dikongsi pejabat Perdana Menteri Haiti bersamaan tarikh majlis presiden peralihan ditubuhkan.
RTS JB-Singapura di landasan tepat
Perkambangan pembinaan Projek RTS Johor Bahru-Singapura dilihat berada pada landasan tepat.
Rakyat Israel sudah mula misi bina penempatan kekal di Gaza
Sekumpulan warga Israel yang bermalam di sempadan berarak memasuki Gaza pada pagi Khamis dengan matlamat untuk membuka penempatan kekal di wilayah itu. Dalam poster kumpulan itu yang tular di media sosial, tertera slogan 'tentera telah mendudukinya, maka kami akan menetap disitu'.
Malaysia sebuah negara selamat - Kedutaan AS
Kedutaan Amerika Syarikat di Malaysia menyangkal dakwaan dangkal Profesor Bruce Gilley yang mengatakan Malaysia adalah negara tidak selamat dilawati.
Memetik laporan Free Malaysia Today, pihak kedutaan berkata tiada perubahan kepada nasihat perjalanan yang kekal pada tahap satu, iaitu tahap paling rendah daripada empat tahap.
Memetik laporan Free Malaysia Today, pihak kedutaan berkata tiada perubahan kepada nasihat perjalanan yang kekal pada tahap satu, iaitu tahap paling rendah daripada empat tahap.
Menteri Luar Malaysia perkukuh hubungan dengan China
Menteri Luar Datuk Seri Mohamad Hasan mengadakan perbincangan substantif dengan rakan sejawatannya, Wang Yi, dalam lawatan pertama beliau ke China sejak memegang jawatan itu pada Disember 2023.
Kakitangan bakal terima tunggakan gaji dalam tempoh 30 bulan
Isu tunggakan gaji membabitkan 20 bekas kakitangan Kedah Agro Holdings Berhad (KAHB) selama sembilan bulan dijangka selesai dalam waktu terdekat selepas kesemua mereka akan menerima bayaran secara berperingkat dalam tempoh 30 bulan berjumlah RM337,000.
COVID-19: Manfaat vaksin mRNA melebihi risiko radang jantung
Pertubuhan Kesihatan Sedunia (WHO) berkata pada Jumaat, vaksin mRNA berkesan mengurangkan kes kemasukan ke hospital dan kematian.
COVID-19: Penghormatan terakhir buat mangsa wabak di Jerman
Steinmeier berkata, walaupun memahami keadaan berdepan memerangi pandemik itu, rakyat tidak sepatutnya alpa kepada mangsa yang terkorban serta ahli keluarga mereka.
COVID-19: Kelonggaran sekatan baharu di UK
Setakat ini kerajaan UK belum ada data jelas mengenai keberkesanan vaksin COVID-19 terhadap gelombang jangkitan baharu.
COVID-19: Semua negara yang bersedia akan terima vaksin - WHO
Ihor Perehinets yakin vaksin baru akan tersedia dan diluluskan untuk kegunaan kecemasan oleh WHO tahun ini dan semua negara akan dapat memperolehinya.
EU larang eksport sisa plastik mulai tahun depan
Negara pengimport seperti Malaysia perlu menjelaskan kepada EU sebarang syarat-syarat yang ditetapkan untuk mengimport sisa plastik dari Eropah.
Safawi Rasid bintang terbaru Portimonense
Pemain berumur 23 tahun itu dilabel sebagai pemuda terbaik negara dengan kedua-dua pasukan mencapai kesepakatan untuk Safawi berkelana ke Eropah
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berita antarabangsa pilihan sepanjang hari ini
BWF batalkan Terbuka Switzerland, Kejuaraan Eropah
Kedua-dua kejohanan itu sebelum ini diletakkan sebagai 'ditangguhkan' sehingga tarikh yang bersesuaian.
Kawasaki: WHO gesa doktor fahami, lakukan intervensi rawatan
Penting untuk mendeskripsikan sindrom klinikal ini dengan segera dan berhati-hati agar dapat difahami sebab serta akibatnya, dalam proses membangunkan intervensi rawatan.
May offer to quit fails to move key opponents of her Brexit deal
British Prime Minister Theresa May offered on Wednesday to quit in a bid to get her European Union divorce deal passed.