We, a group of Young Professionals (YP) from across the Malaysian political spectrum and representing various segments of civil society, wish to put on record our disagreement with the holding of the Bersih 4 rally set to be held on 29 and 30 August 2015 in Kuala Lumpur.
The holding of the rally is, according its organisers, ostensibly towards pushing for the holding of free and fair general elections.
However, past experience with the first Bersih rally in 2007, Bersih 2.0 in 2011 and Bersih 3.0 in 2012 would show that this is not to be the case, and that those behind Bersih have consistently made key changes to their demands and have expanded the scope of their movement beyond general elections.
For instance, while the initial Bersih rally in 2007 called for clean-up of the electoral roll, the use of indelible ink, abolition of postal voting and free and fair access to the media for all parties, the second and third Bersih rally added vague references to “strengthening public institutions and stopping dirty politics”, while the fourth rally aims to pressure the Prime Minister to resign on account of RM2.6 billion channelled into his personal account as a donation.
This, among others, could be why there is dwindling support for Bersih 4’s intention to hold yet another rally since many participants of the previous Bersih rallies have indicated that they will not attend, as the organisers themselves have admitted.
While we make no remark with respect to the allegations against the PM, on which investigations are still ongoing, YP strongly condemns the motives behind the holding of the rally, namely the applying of political and social pressure on a democratically elected Prime Minister to resign prior to the conclusion of the ongoing investigations, and the calling of a transitional government to take his place, all of which are undemocratic and unconstitutional.
YP reminds Malaysians that pursuant to Article 43(4) of the Federal Constitution, being Malaysia’s highest law and grundnorm, the power of dismissal of the Prime Minister, being an appointee of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong (YDPA) lies with Parliament vide a vote of no confidence.
Until and unless Parliament decides to pass a motion of no confidence in the Prime Minister, the same, being an appointee of the YDPA pursuant to Article 43(2)(a), holds office at the pleasure of the YDPA pursuant to Article 43(5) of the Constitution and save as otherwise authorised by this apex law, no pressure, be it political, social or economic, can be brought to bear against the PM to force his resignation.
Thus, Bersih 4’s ultimatum to the PM on account of unfinished investigations concerning RM2.6 Billion or by reason that the Malaysian Ringgit continues to fall against the US dollar are wholly invalid and without any legal basis whatsoever and can only be described as a subversion of Malaysia’s democratic process.
Bersih 4’s claim that it is entitled to hold the rally pursuant to Article 10(1)(b) of the Constitution ignores the limitations placed on this right vide Article 10(2)(b) of the same which provides that Parliament may by law impose restrictions where the same affects national security or public order. This Parliament has done vide the Peaceful Assembly Act 2012 and the Public Order (Preservation) Act 1958.
YP notes from media reports that the organisers of Bersih 4 have not complied fully with the requirements of the Peaceful Assembly Act by failing to submit detailed routes to the Police on the route of the Assembly pursuant to the requirement to give notice under section 9(1) of the Act, leading to the Police not to give their approval for the rally.
YP notes that the reason behind this non approval has nothing to do with the criminalisation of the failure to comply with the time limit of 10 days imposed by section 9(5) of the Act, which was declared unconstitutional by the Court of Appeal in the case of Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad v Public Prosecutor, but everything to do with details of the procession routes intended to be used by participants of the rally.
The argument by Bersih 4 and its sympathisers such as the Bar Council vide its Press Release on 22 August 2015 on the applicability of Nik Nazmi’s case are therefore superfluous.
YP also points out that it is ironic that the Bar Council should assert its support for Bersih 4’s so-called aims of desiring clean elections when elections to the Bar Council itself are far from transparent, and that the Bar Council directed members of the Bar in attendance at the last Annual General Meeting (AGM) of the Malaysian Bar to reject a motion put forth by a member of the Bar calling for greater transparency and accountability in the conduct of annual elections to the Council.
YP strongly believes that until the Bar Council, being a statutory body established pursuant to the Legal Profession Act 1976, itself cleans up its own act in this regard, it has no moral ground nor legitimacy to call for free, fair and transparent general elections or greater accountability in respect of other public bodies.
For the aforesaid reasons YP urges all Malaysians who uphold the Federal Constitution and are concerned about maintenance of national security and public order, to make a stand against Bersih 4 and boycott its planned rallies scheduled for 29 and 30 August 2015.
*Young Professionals (YP) are a group of professionals from across the political divide and of all segments of civil society who strongly believe in the Federal Constitution and the social contract as the basis for rule of law and harmonious conduct of interethnic and social relations towards securing andensuring an orderly and better Malaysia for all Malaysians.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Astro Awani’s editorial policy.
Young Professionals
Fri Aug 28 2015
The holding of the rally is, according to Bersih organiser, ostensibly towards pushing for the holding of free and fair general elections.
Debut Sukan Olimpik 'langkah besar' dalam karier Nurul Izzah Izzati
Bintang muda berbasikal trek negara Nurul Izzah Izzati Mohd Asri menyifatkan penampilan sulungnya pada Sukan Olimpik 2024 di Paris sebagai 'langkah besar' dalam kariernya.
Raja Salman jalani pemeriksaan kesihatan di Hospital Jeddah
Pemeriksaan itu yang diadakan pada Rabu (24 April), dijangka berlangsung beberapa jam.
Dua maut kereta terbabas dan terbalik di Kuala Krai
Kedua-dua mangsa tidak sedarkan diri dan mangsa tersepit berjaya dibawa keluar dari kereta pada jam 4.11 petang.
Penganjuran Hari Perpaduan di sekolah bantu tingkat persefahaman antara kaum - Saraswathy
Penganjuran Hari Perpaduan di sekolah menjadi platform terbaik untuk meningkatkan semangat perpaduan dalam kalangan pelajar sekolah, kata Timbalan Menteri Perpaduan Negara K. Saraswathy.
MITI: RM58.91 juta diagihkan kepada PKS pada suku pertama bagi automasi dan pemodenan
Jumlah peruntukan bagi pinjaman mudah itu ialah RM150 juta untuk 30 syarikat dalam sektor pembuatan dan perkhidmatan berkaitan pembuatan.
2,214 stesen pengecas EV dipasang, MITI kekal sasaran 10,000 menjelang 2025
Ia sebahagian komitmen MITI untuk membangunkan infrastruktur pengecasan EV dan mencapai sasaran 10,000 titik pengecasan menjelang 2025.
Harimau Muda kurang 'kerja rumah' hadapi Piala Asia B-23 2024 - Penganalisis
Menerusi pemerhatian di laman media sosial, timbul cakap-cakap netizen yang lebih terarah kepada perjalanan kesemua pemain negara kendalian Juan Torres Garrido ke Qatar sekadar 'makan angin'.
UMNO aktifkan 'war room' bantu calon Kerajaan Perpaduan - Ahmad
Ahmad berkata UMNO juga akan melaksanakan kempen bagi membantu calon berkenaan dengan bersungguh-sungguh.
Pelepasan air terawat Fukushima digantung kerana terputus elektrik
Pelepasan air radioaktif terawat ke laut dari loji janakuasa nuklear Fukushima yang lumpuh digantung pada Rabu berikutan gangguan bekalan elektrik separa, kata pengendali loji itu.
Prabowo rasmi diisytihar Presiden Indonesia
Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya Umum (KPU) secara rasmi akan mengisytiharkan Prabowo Subianto sebagai Presiden Indonesia dipilih, dalam satu majlis pada Rabu, seperti yang dijadualkan.
Bersih gesa lantik segera pengerusi baharu SPR
Bersih mendesak kerajaan supaya segera melaksanakan reformasi pelantikan pengerusi Suruhanjaya Pilihan Raya (SPR), Tan Sri Abdul Ghani Salleh dan meminda Akta Kesalahan Pilihan Raya 1954.
Kerajaan Perpaduan terbuka kepada rekomendasi, saranan Bersih - PM Anwar
Kerajaan Perpaduan terbuka kepada sebarang rekomendasi atau saranan daripada Gabungan Pilihan Raya Bersih dan Adil (Bersih).
AMK sambut baik usaha agenda reformasi
Angkatan Muda Keadilan Malaysia (AMK) menyambut baik usaha konstruktif berkaitan agenda reformasi selaras dengan idealisme dan perjuangan parti.
Himpunan Bersih terkawal, enam Ahli Parlimen terima memorandum
Mohammed Taufiq memaklumkan pihak kerajaan komited dalam memenuhi tuntutan yang dibuat oleh Bersih dan rakan-rakan NGO yang lain.
Peserta himpunan Reformasi 100 Peratus berkumpul, hantar memorandum ke Parlimen
Perhimpunan anjuran Bersih itu mula berhimpun sejak jam 8 pagi bagi mendesak kerajaan menunaikan janji untuk melaksanakan 100 peratus pembaharuan.
Bersih tetap adakan perhimpunan, hantar notis di IPD Dang Wangi
Bersih akan menghantar permohonan berhubung penganjuran Perhimpunan Tuntut Reformasi 100 Peratus kepada Ibu Pejabat Daerah (IPD) Dang Wangi, Kuala Lumpur hari ini.
Himpunan #Reformasi100peratus bukan demonstrasi besar - Pengerusi Bersih
Perhimpunan #Reformasi100peratus yang dianjurkan oleh Gabungan Pilihan Raya Bersih dan Adil (Bersih) pada 27 Februari akan datang bukan suatu demonstrasi besar-besaran.
Pengampunan Najib: Pemuda UMNO bidas Bersih
Pemuda UMNO berkata, pendirian NGO itu jelas berbeza dengan apa yang berlaku dalam kes Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim sebelum ini.
Pengampunan Najib: 'Keputusan beri kesan besar kepercayaan rakyat kepada sistem keadilan negara' - Bersih
Bersih mendesak bekas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Najib Razak, menjalani hukuman penuh seperti yang telah diputuskan oleh mahkamah tertinggi negara sebelum ini.
Bersih sokong Akta Penggal Tetap Parlimen, dapat jamin kestabilan politik
Bersih menyokong penggubalan Akta Penggal Tetap Parlimen yang dapat menjamin penggal Parlimen kekal hingga habis tempoh iaitu sehingga 18 Disember 2027 sekali gus memastikan kestabilan politik negara