The proposed changes to Syariah Courts (Criminal Jurisdiction) Act 1965 (Act 355) or RUU 355 that seeks to enhance the Syariah Court punishment has brought about strong public reactions in the country.
A public debate, hosted by NGO group, BEBAS on Friday night has gathered four lawyers to discuss the motion of RUU 355, if it should be made into law.
The speakers; Aidil Khalid and Lukman Sheriff Alias are those in favor for the motion while Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan and Haris Ibrahim were against the motion.
ON RUU 355
Lukman, who first took the floor, introduced and explained the RUU 355.
"In short, RUU 355 is a short law to amend the existing law. The law that existed 33 years ago. It seeks to increase the limit of sentencing of existing offenses," said Lukman.
He believes, a fair argument on this issue should be about the 'limits' of the punishment because it is subjective.
Ambiga, however thinks the RUU 355 is too focused on punishment, without defining the offences under the RUU 355.
"The offence must be clearly defined and this RUU does not define any offence.
"I believe there are problems with RUU 355. Even if you say it's constitutional, there are other problems. I personally think it must be looked again.
"The best way to protect everyone is to state it in the legislation, if you state it clearly in the legislation, then you assuage the fears,"said Ambiga.
RUU 355 AND NON MUSLIMS?
Other issues highlighted in the debate is also on how the amendments will or will not impact the non-Muslims in the country.
According to the Constitution, Ninth Schedule, State List stipulates that the Syariah court is to have jurisdiction only over persons professing the religion of Islam.
"For the last 60 years, how many non Muslims have been convicted or prosecuted for not fasting during Ramadan, or not going to Friday prayers? None.
"None, and it will not be applied to non Muslims in the future as well because of the constitutional safeguards," said Lukman.
Ambiga then argues that being charged is different from being affected.
"If you look at the conversion cases that have taken place. When it plays out it does impinge, and those cases goes unsolved for many many years.
"How about the ISA, the promises that it will not be abused, what happens? It happened," said Ambiga.
RUU 355 AND HUDUD?
Ambiga, acknowledging that the RUU 355 does not involve punishment such as stoning or death sentence, believes it still involves other hudud laws.
"In my view, this does cover hudud offenses. Hudud is covered by this amendments. It wouldn't have been covered before, but is covered now.
"So for that reason, I would argue it goes against the basic structure of our federal constitution, and therefore, unconstitutional," said Ambiga.
Lukman however said, RUU 355 does not introduce hudud, because of the constitutional restrictions.
"The RUU 355, to say it introduces a new hudud law, it cannot be because we have constitutional restrictions.
"Hudud has been around for decades. Malaysian Muslims are already used to the syariah laws.
The proposal to amend this act has been listed at this term's Dewan Rakyat sitting.
At the same time, Deputy Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi has also confirmed that the Barisan Nasional government will table RUU 355.
The bill seeks to amend the Act, also known as Act 355 or RUU355, to empower Islamic courts to enforce punishment, except for the death penalty, provided in Syariah laws for Islamic offences listed under state jurisdiction in the Federal Constitution.
Dania Zainuddin
Sat Mar 18 2017
Ambiga then argues that being charged is different from being affected.
Kemajuan pembinaan ECRL di empat negeri cecah purata 65 peratus - Loke
Kemajuan pelaksanaan projek ECRL yang merangkumi Kelantan, Terengganu, Pahang, dan Selangor telah mencapai purata 65 peratus setakat April.
Sekurang-kurangnya 15 maut di Sulawesi
Sekurang-kurangnya 15 terbunuh akibat banjir dan tanah runtuh di dua daerah Sulawesi Selatan.
Perayu jemaah haji sudah terima panggilan
Mereka yang layak selepas membuat rayuan sudah menerima panggilan, dengan penerbangan pertama ke Tanah Suci dijadualkan pada 9 Mei ini.
10,000 wanita terbunuh sejak Israel mengganas
Israel terus menyasarkan wanita dalam serangan tanpa henti rejim Zionis di Semenanjung Gaza, kata Agensi Kerja dan Bantuan Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu bagi Pelarian Palestin (UNRWA) pada Jumaat.
Jabatan Perbendaharaan AS lawat Malaysia, Singapura minggu depan
Pegawai tertinggi sekatan Jabatan Perbendaharaan Amerika Syarikat (AS) akan ke Singapura dan Malaysia minggu depan, dalam usaha menyekat saluran dana kepada Iran dan proksinya selain pengelakan sekatan terhadap Russia.
PM Anwar rasmi Taman Rekreasi Madani Woodlands
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hari ini merasmikan Taman Rekreasi Madani Woodlands di Ipoh bagi kemudahan rekreasi dan riadah orang ramai.
Isu boikot: Teliti situasi, pandangan sebelum ambil tindakan
Ia susulan kenyataan Mufti Negeri Perak, Datuk Seri Wan Zahidi Wan Teh yang berkata tindakan boikot terhadap kedai serbaneka KK Mart , sebenarnya bertentangan dengan sunnah Rasulullah SAW.
ASNB lancar platform Ria, raih RM6 juta pelaburan
ASNB melancarkan Penasihat Pelaburan Robo (Ria) secara berperingkat sejak 11 Mac lalu menerima 60,000 pengguna platform itu.
AWANI Ringkas: Penumpang selamat, pesawat ringan terhempas
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
CAAM sahkan pesawat ringan terhempas di Tanjung Malim
Pihak Berkuasa Penerbangan Awam Malaysia (CAAM) mengesahkan pesawat Cessna 172N Skyhawk erhempas di Felda Gunung Besout, Tanjung Malim, Perak pada Sabtu.
Mahkamah Syariah, undang-undang Islam tidak akan terkubur. Ini apa yang anda perlu tahu
Hari ini, Mahkamah Persekutuan memutuskan Parlimen dan Badan Perundangan Negeri tidak boleh membuat undang-undang melangkaui senarai perundangan dalam Jadual Kesembilan Perlembagaan Persekutuan.
Hudud: Keutamaan pastikan kerajaan stabil, tunggu keadaan mengizinkan - Mohd Amar
Antara matlamat perjuangan Pas adalah untuk melaksanakan syariat Islam, termasuklah undang-undang hudud.
"Jangan tanya bila nak buat hudud" - Pas Kelantan
Kerajaan Perikatan Nasional ketika ini masih 'tidak kukuh', jadi jangan ditanya bila hudud akan dilaksanakan, kata Pas Kelantan.
Terlalu awal bercakap soal Rang Undang-undang 355 - Mohd Amar
Dalam masa dua bulan ini tidak boleh terlalu mengharapkan suatu benda yang besar.
PBB bidas Brunei laksana hukuman hudud
PBB bidas kerajaan Brunei kerana mahu laksana undang-undang hudud yang antara lain merejam pelaku homoseksual.
Hudud: Brunei laksana hukuman rejam sampai mati April ini?
Memetik kenyataan pihak berkuasa negara itu, beberapa portal antarabangsa sejak semalam mendakwa hukuman tersebut akan mula dikuatkuasakan mulai minggu depan.
Pasangan gay kedua di Aceh disebat di khalayak ramai
Sepasang lelaki homoseksual disebat lebih 80 kali secara terbuka di wilayah Aceh, Indonesia pada Jumaat kerana melakukan hubungan seks sejenis.
Tiada perbahasan RUU 355 dalam Dewan Rakyat
Datuk Takiyuddin Hassan bertanyakan soal masa hadapan pembentangan RUU 355 memandangkan usul itu sudah dibentangkan namun masih belum dibahaskan.
Tukang potong tangan sudah ada bagi kesalahan curi - Mohd Amar
Kerajaan negeri Kelantan sudah mempunyai senarai individu yang akan melaksanakan hukuman potong tangan yang terdiri daripada pakar bedah jika hukum hudud dilaksanakan kelak.
Hukum hudud: Kelantan tunggu lampu hijau - MB
Kelantan belanjakan RM1 juta setahun melengkapkan sistem perundangan mahkamah syariah, membangunkan prasarana dan menjalankan kempen.