The Court of Appeal on Thursday declared that Section 9(5) of the Peaceful Assembly Act (PAA) 2012 that punishes an organiser who failed to give the 10-day notice to police before a gathering, is constitutional.
Court of Appeal president Tan Sri Md Raus Sharif who chaired a three-panel member held that Section 9(5) was valid and enforceable.
"We are of the opinion that Section 9(5) is valid and does not violate Article 10 of the Federal Constitution," said Justice Md Raus who sat with Justices Datuk Mohd Zawawi Salleh and Datuk Zamani A. Rahim.
He said the court was unable to agree with the earlier ruling by the Court of Appeal on April 25, last year, in the case of Seri Setia assemblyman Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad, which declared Section 9(5) was unconstitutional.
Therefore, he said, the panel had to depart from the earlier ruling.
The court made the ruling after allowing the prosecution's appeal against the acquittal of Johor PKR executive secretary R. Yuneswaran on a charge of unlawfully organising a "Blackout 505" rally in 2013.
Yuneswaran, 28, was fined RM6,000 by the Sessions Court in Johor Bharu on Sept 26, 2013, which found him, as the organiser of the rally, guilty on the charge of failing to give prior notice of at least 10 days to the Southern Johor Bharu district police chief, on the event.
He was alleged to have committed the offence at the PKR office in Jalan Beladau 19, Taman Puteri Wangsa, Ulu Tiram, Johor, around 8.30pm on May 15, 2013.
On Aug 24 last year, however, he was acquitted by the Johor Bharu High Court which ruled that it was bound by a Court of Appeal decision in Nik Nazmi's case, which declared Section 9(5) of the PAA, unconstitutional.
The High Court also dismissed the prosecution's application to refer the constitutional questions to the Federal Court.
Yesterday, the Court of Appeal upheld the Sessions Court's decision and set aside the ruling by the High Court.
"We have no reason to disturb the sentence by the Sessions Court. We affirm the conviction and the order of the lower court," said Justice Md Raus. Yuneswaran paid the fine.
Outside the court, Yuneswaran's lawyer R. Sivarasa told reporters that with this ruling the organiser can now be charged and punished under Section 9(5) if they failed to give the 10-day notice to police before a gathering.
He said the panel also had not answered two questions raised by counsel during the hearing of the appeal.
"Lawyers and the public will be confused because there are two conflicting judgments from the same court. One said unconstitutional, the other one said is constitutional, which one should we follow?" he said.
Bernama
Fri Oct 02 2015
The court made the ruling after allowing the prosecution's appeal against the acquittal of Johor PKR executive secretary R. Yuneswaran on a charge of unlawfully organising a "Blackout 505" rally in 2013.
Kerajaan Persekutuan kaji cadangan wujud hospital di Pengerang - Azalina
Hospital tersebut akan memudahkan penduduk mendapatkan rawatan memandangkan Pengerang semakin pesat membangun.
AWANI Ringkas: Reformasi gaji di Malaysia
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Piala Thomas: Lee Zii Jia beri mata pertama buat Malaysia!
Kemenangan straight set benarkan Malaysia raih mata pertama dalam aksi peringkat kumpulan saingan Piala Thomas berdepan Hong Kong.
AWANI Pagi: Filem Oppa semai mesej PDRM banteras jenayah scam
Ikuti diskusi bersama Pengarah Jabatan Siasatan Jenayah Komersial (JSJK) Bukit Aman, Datuk Seri Ramli Mohamed Yoosuf akan berkongsi mesej disemai PDRM dalam membanteras jenayah scam yang berleluasa ketika ini.
Pusat penamaan calon PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu dibuka
Pusat penamaan calon bagi PRK DUN Kuala Kubu Baharu (KKB) di Dewan Serbaguna dan Kompleks Sukan Daerah Hulu Selangor dibuka pada jam 9 pagi ini.
EPL: "Ada sesiapa jangka kami bakal muncul juara?"
Klopp belum sedia nilai musim terakhir bersama Liverpool.
AWANI Pagi: Break the Siege - Pelayaran ditangguhkan, apa seterusnya?
Misi Freedom Flotilla to Gaza, yang sepatutnya memulakan pelayaran minggu lalu, akhirnya ditangguhkan atas pelbagai faktor. Wartawan kami di Istanbul, Syaff Syukri akan kongsi perancangan seterusnya misi ini.
Polis tahan lelaki bersama pil Yaba bernilai lebih RM12,000
Polis menahan seorang lelaki bersama 823 biji pil yaba bernilai lebih RM12,000 di sebuah bangsal kereta di Rantau Panjang.
PM Anwar ke Riyadh sempena Mesyuarat Khas Forum Ekonomi Sedunia
Mesyuarat Khas bertemakan "Global Collaboration, Growth and Energy Development" akan dihadiri oleh Ketua-ketua Negara dan Kerajaan serta pemimpin industri.
Proses penamaan calon berlangsung 9 pagi ini
Pilihan Raya Kecil (PRK) Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Kuala Kubu Baharu (KKB) membuka tirai hari ini dengan bermulanya proses penamaan calon di Dewan Serbaguna Dan Kompleks Sukan Daerah Hulu Selangor.
Perhimpunan 'Blackout 505': Rafizi dan tiga lain didenda RM1,950
Naib Presiden PKR Mohd Rafizi Ramli dan tiga yang lain masing-masing didenda RM1,950 oleh Mahkamah Sesyen bagi kesalahan menganjurkan perhimpunan 'Blackout 505'.
Nik Nazmi didakwa anjur Perhimpunan Blackout 505
Pertuduhan yang dikemukakan terhadap Nik Nazmi, 33, hari ini merupakan kali ketiga dia didakwa terhadap pertuduhan sama.
Chegubard dilepas tanpa membebaskan daripada tuduhan anjur perhimpunan
Mahkamah Sesyen di sini hari ini melepas tanpa membebaskan bekas Ketua Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) cabang Rembau Badrul Hisham Shaharin atau dikenali sebagai 'Chegubard' daripada tuduhan
Blackout 505: Dua anggota parlimen pohon dilepas tanpa dibebaskan
Hakim bagaimanapun menangguhkan keputusannya selepas membenarkan permohonan Timbalan Pendakwa Raya untuk menangguhkan perbicaraan kes itu.
Ahli Parlimen Bukit Katil didakwa berhubung Blackout 505
Dia didakwa menyertai perhimpunan yang diadakan di tempat larangan iaitu dalam perkarangan Masjid Ar-Rahman Universiti Malaya pada 22 Jun.
Blackout 505 belum berakhir - Anwar
Ketua Umum Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim hari ini melaporkan bahawa himpunan Blackout 505 masih belum berakhir.