PKR vice-president Mohd Rafizi Ramli was today ordered to pay RM200,000 in damages to National Feedlot Corporation Sdn Bhd (NFCorp) executive chairman Datuk Seri Dr Mohamad Salleh Ismail and his company for defaming them over the purchase of a property in KL Eco City, Bangsar.
High Court Judicial Commissioner Azizul Azmi Adnan made the decision after allowing Mohamad Salleh and NFCorp's suit against Mohd Rafizi, who was the first defendant.
Azizul ordered Mohd Rafizi to pay damages of RM150,000 to Mohamad Salleh and RM50,000 to his company.
The court also ordered Mohd Rafizi to pay costs of RM100,000 to the plaintiffs (Mohamad Salleh and NFCorp).
However, the court dismissed Mohamad Salleh and NFCorp's suit against Malaysiakini, which was named as second defendant, and ordered the plaintiffs to pay cost of RM50,000 to the news portal.
In the suit filed on June 3, 2013, Mohamad Salleh and NFCorp, claimed that on March 7, 2012, Mohd Rafizi had made a defamatory statement at a media conference at the PKR Office on the purchase of KL Eco City properties and was published by Malaysiakini on the same day.
He said the suit was filed because of losses incurred due to the lies, misleading information, disclosure of confidential banking information and slander made by the defendants.
Mohamad Salleh sought general, exemplary and aggravated damages, as well as interests, costs and other relief deemed fit by the court.
He also sought an injunction to prevent the defendants from continuing to mislead and deceive the public on the issue.
Azizul in his judgment said the statements made by Mohd Rafizi were defamatory and he had alleged that public funds had been misappropriated.
"'Seleweng' (misappropriation), in my view, is a serious allegation than 'salahguna' (misuse) and the latter may be the result of mere negligence or lack of care, whereas 'seleweng', as mentioned earlier, implies an element of dishonesty," he said, adding that Mohd Rafizi had not verified the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in the document.
""Even if the words 'dijadikan jaminan' can be read to mean 'use as leverage' rather than 'guarantee', in my view, the use of the word 'diselewengkan' (misappropriated) suggests that public funds were somehow put at risk by reason of the fact that the funds had been use as leverage to obtain personal loans," he said.
Azizul also said that there was no evidence that public funds were somehow used as collateral or security or otherwise put at risk, even if the contention of Mohd Rafizi was accepted that he only meant that the funds disbursed to NFCorp has been used as leverage.
"I find that the statements issued by Mohd Rafizi were also defamatory of the second plaintiff (NFCorp), as they suggest that the second plaintiff had misused the proceeds of the government loan by allowing its directors to raise financing by leveraging on the deposit," the judge said.
He further said that in the circumstances of this case, it was not seriously in dispute that the nature of allegations against the plaintiffs were serious, and were suggestive of conduct that might potentially have penal consequences.
While for the second defendant, Azizul said the court found that the effect of the reporting by the Malaysiakini, when viewed as whole and evaluated objectively, was to report the fact that the statements had been made at the press conference convened by Mohd Rafizi, rather than for the purposes of persuading the reader or viewer of their contents.
"I am of the view that the video clip was faithful recording of the actual events that had taken place, lending support to the finding that the trust of the reporting was to show the fact that the statements had been made by Mohd Rafizi.
"I am also of the view that the reporting had been done in a fair, disinterested and neutral way," Azizul said before dismissing the plaintiffs claim against Mkini Dotcom, which is the owner of the Malaysiakini news portal.
Meanwhile, Mohamad Salleh in a statement to the media said, finally, the truth had prevailed.
"Since late 2011, the Malaysian Government, NFCorp, its directors and my wife have had to endure a spate of unwarranted vicious attacks by the opposition and those out to take advantage against us.
Today, the air is cleared," he said. -- Bernama
Bernama
Mon Oct 31 2016
A Nov 24, 2015 file photo of Mohamad Salleh (right) with wife Datuk Seri Shahrizat Abdul Jalil and son Izmir at the KL Sessions Court after the court discharged and acquitted Mohamad Salleh of CBT charges. - BERNAMApic
Malaysia berupaya sertai pasaran koko global - Johari
Johari berkata Malaysia adalah di antara pemain koko utama dunia terutamanya di peringkat pertengahan dan hiliran.
Karnival TEKUN Madani sempena Pesta Kaamatan di Kuala Penyu
Pada karnival itu juga, KUSKOP akan melancarkan projek Tamu Desa bagi Sabah untuk tahun 2023.
Pendekatan berhemah, waspada perlu dalam kes babitkan wartawan Bloomberg - Johan Jaaffar
Tan Sri Johan Jaaffar menggesa pihak polis untuk mengambil pendekatan berhemah, penuh waspada dan penuh pemahaman dalam mengendalikan kes membabitkan seorang wartawan Bloomberg, Ram Anand.
Filipina, AS tembak 'tentera penceroboh' dalam latihan di Laut China Selatan
Tentera Amerika Syarikat dan Filipina melepaskan tembakan peluru berpandu dan artileri ke arah pasukan 'tentera penceroboh' dalam latihan perang di pantai utara Filipina pada Isnin.
Rakaman dashcam puting beliung di Nebraska
Visual yang anda saksikan tadi adalah rakaman video kamera papan pemuka (dashcam) yang menunjukkan detik puting beliung di Nebraska pada 26 April lalu.
Rakaman itu menunjukkan puting beliung dahsyat itu memusnahkan bangunan di Lincoln di Nebraska.
Rakaman itu menunjukkan puting beliung dahsyat itu memusnahkan bangunan di Lincoln di Nebraska.
Kenakan sekatan, hanti eksport senjata ke Israel - OIC
Pertubuhan Kerjasama Islam (OIC) mengecam 'pembunuhan beramai-ramai' di Gaza dan menggesa 57 negara anggotanya mengenakan sekatan ke atas Israel dalam resolusi yang diterima pakai pada penghujung sidang kemuncaknya di Gambia pada 5 Mei.
Qantas Airways sedia bayar penalti 100 juta dolar Australia
Qantas Airways berkata pada Isnin bersetuju untuk membayar penalti sebanyak A$100 juta dolar Australia untuk menyelesaikan tuntutan mahkamah susulan kes menjual tiket yang telah dibatalkan.
Putin angkat sumpah untuk penggal kelima pada selasa
Majlis itu yang dijadualkan berlangsung di Kremlin, menandakan permulaan penggal selama enam tahun untuk pentadbiran Putin yang memenangi 87 peratus undi semasa Pilihan Raya Presiden yang berlangsung pada Mac.
Faisal kini dirawat di ICU, perlu jalani beberapa pembedahan
Pemain skuad kebangsaan, Faisal Halim, kini menjalani rawatan di Unit Rawatan Rapi (ICU) susulan kejadian disimbah asid di sebuah pasar raya di Kota Damansara, Petaling Jaya.
Jemaah wanita dinasihat kurangkan pergerakan jika disahkan hamil
Ada nasihat siberikan Pengarah Operasi Madinah (Perubatan) Dr Mahyin Kudong kepada jemaah haji wanita yang disahkan hamil semasa musim haji baik sebelum atau selepas tiba di Tanah Suci.
NFCorp: 12 tahun difitnah, akhirnya kebenaran ditegakkan - Mohamad Salleh
Mohamad Salleh bersyukur selepas mahkamah melepas dan membebaskan beliau dan tiga anaknya daripada semua pertuduhan berhubung projek Pusat Fidlot Kebangsaan.
Kes NFCorp: Mahkamah Tinggi lepas dan bebas Mohamad Salleh, tiga anak
Hakim memutuskan NFCorp perlu mengembalikan sejumlah pinjaman yang tidak digunakan sebanyak RM33 juta kepada Kerajaan.
Mahkamah Rayuan tangguhkan keputusan rayuan saman NFCorp terhadap Public Bank
Penangguhan dibuat selepas peguam yang mewakili NFCorp, Mohamad Salleh dan tiga anak syarikat serta bank itu mengakhiri hujahan.
NFCorp: 'Saya yang rugi bukan kerajaan' - Mohamad Salleh
Mohamad Salleh, 74, berkata ini kerana wang NFCorp telah dirampas dan kerajaan menggantungkan projek tersebut.
Mahkamah Persekutuan tangguh keputusan rayuan Pengerusi Eksekutif NFCorp
Mahkamah Persekutuan menangguhkan keputusan rayuan Pengerusi Eksekutif NFCorp Datuk Seri Dr Mohamad Salleh Ismail dan syarikatnya dalam saman fitnah yang difailkan terhadap Rafizi Ramli.
Suami Shahrizat Jalil, 2 anak berdepan tuntutan saman Maybank Singapore
Maybank Singapore, yang juga merupakan plainitif memfailkan saman itu di pejabat pendaftar Mahkamah Tinggi di sini pada 19 Julai lalu.
Kes rayuan BAFIA Rafizi dan Johari 15 Nov ini
Mahkamah Tinggi menetapkan 15 November depan untuk keputusan rayuan Rafizi Ramli dan Johari Mohamad terhadap sabitan dan hukuman mereka mengikut BAFIA, tahun lalu.
NFCorp, Mohamad Salleh gagal dalam saman terhadap Public Bank
Hakim Su dalam penghakimannya berkata kesemua plaintif gagal membuktikan kes itu terhadap defendan (Public Bank) berdasarkan imbangan kebarangkalian.
NFCorp akan lunas baki pinjaman tertunggak dalam 3 bulan - Pengerusi
NFCorp akan membayar balik baki tertunggak pinjaman kepada kerajaan, kata pengerusinya Datuk Seri Mohamad Salleh Ismail.
Rafizi diperintah bayar ganti rugi RM200,000 kepada Mohamad Salleh
Rafizi Ramli diperintahkan membayar ganti rugi RM200,000 kepada Pengerusi Eksekutif NFCorp Datuk Seri Dr Mohamad Salleh Ismail dan syarikatnya.