The Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs (IDEAS) welcome the government’s decision to relax the rules for the movement control order and provide the economy with much needed room to adjust and recover. We recognise that the implementation of the conditional movement control order (CMCO) is not a decision that was made lightly given the ongoing COVID-19 risk to public health.
The control measures in place thus far were able to contain the spread of Covid-19 and the medical system proved to be effective in handling the treatments; in fact, Malaysia recorded one of the highest recovery rates in the world (70.6%). The restarting of the economic system through CMCO is necessary in order to avoid irreversible woes to the production structure and to the employment situation.
But the CMCO announcement made by Prime Minister Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin on 1 May 2020 caught the public by surprise, not least the state governments. The Prime Minister had hinted at a prolonged period of MCO in his previous televised addresses while the MITI Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali had just allowed approved economic sectors to resume full operations one week ago. Confusion and fear arise if the relaxing of the movement control is premature in light of daily reports on confirmed cases of the coronavirus, albeit at an improved rate.
A better timeline might have been chosen, in order to get businesses and individuals to properly familiarize with the necessary standard operating procedures (SOPs), which at the same time needs to be clear and of simple implementation, to guarantee both compliance and smooth operations.
More importantly, disagreements between the federal and state governments on the perceived readiness for economic operations to fully resume starting 4 May 2020 raises the question if there was adequate consultation on the part of the federal government for exiting the MCO with a strategy.
There are several conflicting reports in the media as to whether the state governments were indeed consulted on the matter. It is possible they were briefed as to the federal government's approach, but whether or not the states agreed is left vague. Public health, sanitation and the prevention of infectious diseases fall under the Concurrent List in the Federal Constitution 1957, which means both the federal and state governments are given equal authority to decide upon these areas. While the federal law of Prevention and Control of Infectious Diseases Act 1988 exists, all laws must be applied in accordance with the Federal Constitution.
Clearly, there is a lack of consensus between the two tiers of government. Including states in the decision-making process is not just constitutionally required; it is also practical. Based on the principles of federalism and subsidiarity, the federal government should only decide on tasks that cannot otherwise be decided upon at a more local level. State and local governments have a greater knowledge of their communities' situation in their respective areas, and with the information from the Ministry of Health on red and green zones, they would be able to make better-informed decisions and gradually relax restrictions by geographic zone, in accordance with exposure risk that may differ from state to state. States would be able to determine and clearly communicate an exit strategy jointly with the federal government, with the necessary support from all sides.
In the interest of public transparency on such an urgent issue, our leaders should put aside their political differences. Consultations on the Covid-19 crisis with state governments must be meaningful, and opinions are given equal weightage, as these decisions have major public health and economic implications.
The way in which the “exit strategy” will be defined, implemented, and managed is very much important in reshaping Malaysia’s level of competitiveness in the new normal for the global economy.
Media Statement
Tue May 05 2020
The way in which the 'exit strategy' will be defined and implemented is very much important in reshaping Malaysias level of competitiveness. - FILEpic
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: Misi sekali lagi ditangguhkan, dijangka berlepas pada Jumaat
Ketika ini lokasi kapal memulakan pelayaran akan ditukarkan ke satu lokasi yang akan diumumkan dalam masa terdekat.
Pihak produksi masih terima Naim Daniel jika ubah fikiran
Ketua saluran Astro Ria, Norzeha Mohd Salleh memberitahu bahawa pihak produksi masih lagi memberi ruang kepada penyanyi tersebut untuk mempertimbangkan semula tawaran yang diberikan.
The Hardest Singing Show cabar kreativiti penyanyi tempatan
Program The Hardest Singing Show mencari satu juara yang mampu menyahut cabaran kreativiti luar limitasi.
Pekerja Ahli Parlimen EU disyaki jadi pengintip China
Polis Jerman telah menahan seorang pekerja ahli politik Parlimen Eropah Alternative for Germany (AfD) kerana disyaki menjadi pengintip China.
Amaran ribut hujan tahap tertinggi dikeluarkan di Guangdong, selatan China
Lebih 100,000 orang sudah dipindahkan akibat hujan lebat dan banjir yang boleh membawa maut di selatan China.
Jokowi dan anaknya bukan lagi ahli PDIP
Presiden Indonesia Joko Widodo atau Jokowi dan anaknya, bakal naib presiden Gibran Rakabuming Raka, bukan lagi ahli parti terbesar negara itu selepas mereka menyokong calon pesaing yang juga pemenang pilihan raya Prabowo Subianto.
Lima migran maut ketika cuba memasuki Perancis
Lima termasuk seorang kanak-kanak, maut dalam cubaan menyeberangi Selat Inggeris dari Perancis pada Selasa.
Polis New York lakukan penahanan himpunan lewat malam
Polis New York bertindak melakukan penahanan membabitkan peserta yang terlibat dalam himpunan solidariti terhadap Palestin di Universiti New York (NYU) pada lewat malam Isnin. Penahanan itu dibuat selepas mereka didakwa mengingkari arahan amaran pihak universiti untuk bersurai dan mengosongkan plaza yang menjadi tempat mereka berkumpul.
Break The Siege: Ada kemungkinan lokasi pelepasan kapal ditukar
Jawatankuasa Pemandu Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC), Kamarul Zaman Shaharul Anwar memaklumkan, wujud kemungkinan lokasi pelabuhan bagi pelepasan kapal yang terlibat dalam misi Break the Siege of Gaza Freedom Flotilla ditukar.
Benarkan syarikat milik bukan Islam cetak Al-Quran, pengarah syarikat didenda
Seorang pengarah syarikat percetakan dijatuhi hukuman denda RM8,000 atau penjara lima bulan oleh Mahkamah Majistret Petaling Jaya pada Selasa selepas mengaku salah tidak mematuhi syarat-syarat lesen untuk mencetak atau menerbitkan Teks al-Quran, bulan lepas.
Bersatu Tanjong Karang digantung
Bersatu Tanjong Karang digantung susulan ketua bahagiannya menyatakan sokongan kepada Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim.
Kutipan hasil Selangor dijangka meningkat RM100 juta mulai tahun depan - MB
Kerajaan Selangor menjangkakan kutipan hasil negeri tersebut meningkat sekitar RM100 juta selepas memperkenalkan tiga langkah baharu.
PN puji inisiatif MITI lancar rangka kerja i-ESG
Mohamed Azmin memuji inisiatif Kementerian Pelaburan, Perdagangan dan Industri (MITI) melancarkan rangka kerja Alam Sekitar, Sosial dan Tadbir Urus Industri Nasional (i-ESG).
Azmin Ali nafi dakwaan keluar kenyataan berunsur fitnah terhadap Lim Guan Eng
Mohamed Azmin menafikan dakwaan beliau mengeluarkan sebarang kenyataan berunsur fitnah terhadap Lim Guan Eng ketika berucap pada kempen PRU15.
Mohamed Azmin minta Speaker tarik larangan pakai baju Melayu
Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali meminta Speaker baharu, Lau Weng San, menarik semula peraturan kepada semua Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) berhubung pemakaian baju kebangsaan.
Pembangkang tubuh jawatankuasa portfolio, semak imbang peranan Exco Selangor
Mohamed Azmin berkata peranan 10 ADUN PN dalam portfolio itu bertujuan memastikan perbincangan dan perbahasan semasa sidang Dewan Undangan Negeri (DUN) Selangor lebih berfokus.
Azmin dilantik Ketua Pembangkang DUN Selangor
Pengumuman itu dibuat Speaker DUN Selangor, Lau Weng San pada Mesyuarat Pertama (Angkat Sumpah) Penggal Pertama DUN Selangor ke-15.
Nahas Elmina: Azmin Ali sertai solat jenazah Shahrul Kamal
Azmin juga memaklumkan beliau sempat bertemu dengan bapa Allahyarham yang juga bekas juruterbang.
Kes Muhyiddin: Pertuduhan AMLA tidak boleh berdiri sendiri - Mohamed Azmin
Azmin menegaskan, oleh kerana kesalahan utama atau predikat telah dibatalkan, maka pertuduhan AMLA tidak boleh berdiri secara sendiri.
'Azmin berjaya raih simpati pengundi' - KJ
Menurut Khairy, walaupun Azmin dilabel sebagai pengkhianat, namun PRN kali ini memberi kejutan apabila undi masyarakat Melayu mula beralih kepada Perikatan Nasional (PN).