To ensure continued access to justice during the extended Movement Control Order (MCO), criminal proceedings should be continued with restricted access, says legal fraternity.
Prominent lawyer Datuk N. Sivananthan said the authorities should allow criminal courts to operate by allowing only relevant parties such as the judge, prosecutor, lawyer and the accused person to be present.
“Criminal courts should be allowed to function not only for matters involving remand, fresh charges, bail and revision applications but also for matters involving appeals and miscellaneous applications because there is no need for anyone apart from the prosecutor, lawyer and the accused person to be present. No witness need to be present.
“For habeas corpus applications involving individuals detained without trial, the presence of the accused is dispensed with so even fewer people are involved.
"Case management before the registrar and the judge can be done online to further reduce the number of people in court,” he added.
For example, he said, many people were arrested on suspicion of drug use and most could not pay bail, and their cases were being postponed for long periods as they cannot even plead guilty because of the chemist reports cannot be provided.
“So, longer dates are set by the court, and they are then held on remand, adding to the congestion in prisons. I see no reason why, with proper planning, the criminal courts cannot be reopened and I am certain the judiciary is more than able to come up with the necessary protocols consistent with the guidelines set by the Health Ministry,” he said.
The lawyer is of the view that the extension of the MCO had caused tremendous injustice to accused persons (for non-bailable offences) and detained persons under preventive laws.
“Individuals in both categories cannot be released until the proceedings are completed in court and by not allowing the criminal court to operate means all these people have no remedy available to them.
"For those on bail, however, there is no real prejudice since they are basically in the same position as everyone else.
"Therefore, the authorities should allow the courts to operate but restrict access only to those involved in the proceedings and not others,” he said.
Sharing the same sentiment, lawyer Nor Zabetha Muhammad Nor said the authorities may consider alternative ways such as to create a venue in prison to function as a court by allowing the Deputy Public Prosecutor, Magistrate and lawyer to attend the proceedings.
She said it would at least avoid the number of detainees from different prisons or lockups from being brought to court which may pose a risk of COVID-19 infection.
“At the same time, this may reduce congestion in prisons and for the accused person who wants to plead guilty to the charge, it could help them to expedite matters, instead of waiting for new hearing dates after the MCO is lifted, something which is still uncertain.
“They can pay the fines or go to jail based on court decisions that may be shorter than the period they are detained throughout the MCO," Nor Zabetha said.
Most criminal cases including high profile trials have been postponed such as the 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) trial of former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak and his wife Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor as well as the trial of former deputy prime minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi who is facing corruption charges.
Meanwhile, for case management proceedings such as in forfeiture cases involving the Kedah UMNO liaison committee and Habib Jewels Sdn Bhd which were fixed for case management were also vacated following the extension of the MCO.
Last Friday, the judiciary in a statement said during the extended MCO period, parties in civil cases can apply for online trials at the Federal Court and Court of Appeal and the High Court of Malaya, there are additional proceeding lists involving civil cases which can be heard online beginning May 4.
According to a statement, these proceedings are interlocutory appeal hearings, uncontested interlocutory applications, contested interlocutory applications which are brief, and appeals to judges in chambers on the decisions of the deputy registrar or senior assistant registrar.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Mon Apr 27 2020
To ensure continued access to justice during the extended Movement Control Order (MCO), criminal proceedings should be continued with restricted access, says legal fraternity. -Filepix
[KOLUMNIS] Penyesuaian pesakit dengan stoma: 5 perkara yang perlu anda ketahui
STOMA merupakan bukaan usus di bahagian badan pesakit yang terhasil selepas pesakit menjalani pembedahan berkaitan usus.
Pasangan suami isteri, dua lelaki didakwa perdagang wanita Malaysia di Peru
Sepasang suami isteri dan dua lelaki yang dihadapkan ke Mahkamah Sesyen mengaku tidak bersalah atas pertuduhan memperdagang dua wanita Malaysia di Peru.
PM ucap selamat raikan Good Friday, Easter Sunday kepada penganut Kristian
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim mengucapkan selamat menyambut hari Good Friday dan Easter Sunday kepada seluruh penganut Kristian.
Singapura rampas 1.5 tan produk segar dan makanan proses dari Malaysia
Kira-kira 1.5 tan produk segar dan makanan diproses yang diimport secara haram dari Malaysia dirampas Agensi Makanan Singapura (SFA).
AWANI Ringkas: Jumlah hari tol percuma kekal
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Kemarau: KADA anggar 40,000 tan metrik hasil padi terjejas
Kawasan tersebut sangat kering, mengakibatkan tanah merekah dan tanaman rosak teruk.
Pemuda Dong warisi perniagaan buah kabung
Proses mendapatkan buah yang turut dikenali sebagai buah nau dalam kalangan masyarakat utara itu rumit dan memerlukan kesabaran tinggi.
[KOLUMNIS] Malaysia perlu bijak tangani isu diplomatik, jangan biarkan dibuli negara besar
Sekiranya Malaysia hendak mengekalkan status sebagai sebuah negara berkecuali di samping menjaga kepentingan ekonomi negara, kepimpinan negara perlu untuk mempertahankan kedaulatan negara.
Ada keperluan pinda Seksyen 21 Akta Polis - KPN
Terdapat keperluan untuk PDRM melakukan pindaan terhadap Seksyen 21 Akta Polis 1967, yang berkaitan dengan tugasan mengiring di jalan raya.
Kegiatan haram di KL: Lebih daripada seorang pegawai kanan polis dipercayai terlibat - Azam Baki
Lebih daripada seorang pegawai kanan Polis Diraja Malaysia dipercayai terlibat dalam aktiviti melindungi kegiatan haram di ibu negara, tegas Ketua Pesuruhjaya SPRM Tan Sri Azam Baki.
'Saya percayakan Jho Low sebab dia sudah miliki wang berjuta' - Jasmine Loo
Bekas peguam 1MDB memberitahu Mahkamah Tinggi Kuala Lumpur pada Jumaat bahawa tidak terlintas di fikirannya ahli perniagaan dalam buruan Jho Low adalah seorang penipu.
Utusan Malaysia mohon maaf kepada pembaca
Portal berita tempatan Utusan Malaysia memohon maaf selepas menerbitkan artikel berhubung pengampunan bekas Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak.
Najib tidak maklumkan terbitan bon AS$3.5 bilion kepada Kabinet
Mahkamah Tinggi hari ini diberitahu Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak tidak memaklumkan Kabinet mengenai terbitan bon AS$3.5 bilion.
Najib disyaki terima AS$681 juta untuk beli undi PRU13 - SPRM
Seorang pegawai penyiasat SPRM memberitahu Mahkamah Tinggi di sini pada Selasa bahawa, Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak disyaki menerima AS$681 juta untuk membeli untuk PRU13 pada 11 tahun lalu.
Najib belanja RM80,000 untuk ubat cegah kanser pada 2013 - Pegawai penyiasat
Mahkamah diberitahu bahawa Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak membelanjakan RM80,000 pada 2013 untuk suplemen dan vitamin bagi pencegahan kanser daripada wang derma.
Muhyiddin titipkan doa buat Najib
Semalam, Menteri Kesihatan, Dr Zaliha Mustafa dalam sidang media di Parlimen turut mengesahkan masalah kesihatan yang sedang dihadapi Najib.
Berita tempatan pilihan sepanjang hari ini
Berikut adalah berita yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang Selasa, 15 Ogos 2023.
1MDB: Kerajaan sita, lucut hak harta lebih RM83 juta
Kerajaan sudah menyita dan melucut hak pelbagai harta bernilai lebih RM83 juta berkait kes penyelewengan dana 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) setakat ini.
SPRM percaya Jho Low sembunyi di Macau - Laporan
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) percaya bahawa ahli perniagaan dalam buruan Low Taek Jho atau Jho Low bersembunyi di Macau.
Kes pinda laporan audit 1MDB: Rayuan pendakwaan ditetapkan untuk satu lagi tarikh pengurusan kes pada 21 Julai
Rayuan pihak pendakwaan terhadap pembebasan bekas Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Najib Abdul Razak dan bekas ketua pegawai eksekutif 1MDB Arul Kanda Kandasamy dalam kes meminda laporan audit 1MDB.