Having freedom of religion also means freedom to choose ones faith or to leave a religion, even if that person was a Muslim.
Such is the view of the panelists in a Bar Council-organised forum on Saturday, which discussed about legal issues surrounding Islam and the secular nature of the Federal Constitution.
“The concept of ‘no coercion in faith’ rings hollow if a Muslim is only able to convert into Islam but is not able to leave the faith,” said Islamic Renaissance Front (IRF)founder Dr Ahmad Farouk Musa.
Ahmad Farouk reasserted that the Quranic verse meant that anyone can freely choose what he or she believes in.
“Faith is of the same fabric as love. As long as you can’t enforce love, you can’t enforce faith. If you prevent someone for leaving a religion… means you are trying to create a community of hypocrites. It defeats the purpose, what is the point of it?”
Ahmad Farouk said that Muslims should not be proud to have the ‘number’ of believers, as opposed having true Muslims of quality.
The same verse was made controversial late last year when it was reported that PKR leader Nurul Izzah Anwar suggested that Islam permitted Muslims to denounce their religion in the name of freedom of religion.
However, Nurul later said that her statements were twisted by Malay dailies and threatened to sue.
“We had Nurul Izzah making such as statement, and I am trying to reassert the same thing. It
should be both ways,” he said.
“There shall be no coercion in matters of faith. Whatever you do, ultimate purpose is faith in the religion, not because of this bumiputera status. Your conversion I don’t think it is real conversion if it is forced.”
“Faith is something that is not between you and state, or society. It is between you and God.
“The issue of people who have converted to decide to leave Islam and they were prevented. The law says you can convert to be a Muslim but you cannot convert out. To me, as an Islamic activist and as a person who hold fast to this principle of freedom of religion, that should not be the case.”
Ahmad Farouk further said that freedom to believe in God also meant “freedom in sin”, referring to moral policing happening in Malaysia.
“For Muslims to be true Muslims, they must live in a secular, a state that does not enforce how Islam is being practiced on its citizens.”
“If someone refrains from taking alchohol, for example, it is a moral choice. Means that reasons he refuses to drink is not because he is afraid of JAKIM or what, but because there is God,” he said.
Meanwhile, Syarie lawyer Nizam Bashir argued that enforcing religion was doing injustice to Islam.
“It makes no sense to force someone to do something. It is fundamental in Islam. If you are preventive someone from leaving the religion, that’s injustice to Islam, and doing injustice to God. Freedom is God given,” he said.
Nizam said that a person converts into Islam for many reasons, including marriage, and said that it was “unfortunate” that the current legislation that prohibits from being with each other on whatever faith.
“It is next to impossible for a Christian to marry a Muslim,” said Nizam.
Nizam also agreed with a participant who said that there is no laws on murtad(apostasy) and said that the problem with making apostasy a crime was that the state has to recognize that the person was no longer Muslim.
“If you assume that apostacy that it is a crime in Islam. How do you go to court to ask to commit a crime? Usually the charge is on ‘insult to Islam”.
Lawyer Malik Imtiaz Sarwar concurred, and explained the Catch-22 situation: “Once they charge you for apostacy, they recognize that you are no longer Islam, so they no longer have jurisdiction [in the Syariah court].”
Among the reasons people convert, said Malik, included people were uncomfortable with ‘state-defined Islam’, those who were practicing other religions but was registered as Muslims in one way or another, or those who embraced Islam for the purpose of marriage.
“Those who leave the religion for another religion altogether are very very few,” he said.
Teoh El Sen
Mon Jul 08 2013
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Jenazah dibawa ke lokasi pengebumian
Lapan jenazah anggota TLDM selesai disolatkan di Batalion Kedua Rejimen Renjer Diraja kira-kira jam 5.40 petang pada Rabu.
Kes tembak KLIA: Suspek didakwa lagi esok
Hafizul Hawari, 38, didakwa di Mahkamah Sesyen Kota Bharu, Kelantan atas tujuh pertuduhan termasuk memiliki senjata api, 15 April lalu.
Freedom Flotilla to Gaza: Misi melalui perairan antarabangsa, bukan Israel - Huwaida Arraf
Misi Break the Siege of Gaza Freedom Flotilla yang dijadual memulakan pelayaran pada Jumaat ini tidak akan menggunakan laluan di perairan Israel.
Upacara penghormatan terakhir
Bersama kita wartawan Umavathi Ramayah yang kini berada di Masjid Salahuddin Al Ayubi Taman Melati.
Sultan Selangor adakan pertemuan dengan PM Anwar di Seri Perdana
Sultan Selangor Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah berkenan berangkat ke kediaman rasmi Perdana Menteri di Kompleks Seri Perdana, Putrajaya.
Upacara penghormatan terakhir mengikut tradisi tentera laut
Ridauddin Daud membawakan perkembangan terkini penghomatan terakhir kepada 10 mangsa insiden helikopter TLDM yang terhempas di Lumut.
MB Perlis maklum anak ditahan, serah kepada SPRM untuk siasat
Mohd Shukri berkata beliau mengetahui berita mengenai penahanan anaknya oleh SPRM dan menyerahkan kepada pihak berkuasa untuk menjalankan siasatan.
Semua jenazah dibawa keluar dari HRPB
Semua jenazah anggota Tentera Laut Diraja Malaysia (TLDM) yang maut dalam nahas helikopter di Pangkalan TLDM Lumut dibawa keluar daripada Jabatan Forensik Hospital Raja Permaisuri Bainun (HRPB) pada jam 4.35 petang pada Rabu.
Polis tumpaskan sindiket seludup dadah ke Sarawak
Polis menumpaskan sindiket penyeludupan dadah ke Sarawak dengan penahanan dua buruh binaan dan merampas pelbagai dadah bernilai RM1.76 juta di dua lokasi berasingan, pada Isnin lepas.
Buka tirai edisi ke-13, komited jadi pemacu WST2040
Ekspo dan Forum ASIAWATER secara rasmi membuka tirai penganjuran kali ke-13 di Pusat Konvensyen Kuala Lumpur untuk tiga hari dari 23 hingga 25 April 2024.