The High Court on Monday struck out the suit by 102 taxi drivers against the Land Public Transport Commission (SPAD) over the Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane services as they had used the wrong avenue to institute legal action against SPAD.
Judge Datuk Su Geok Yiam said the plaintiffs also failed to produce a reasonable cause of action against SPAD as the defendant in the lawsuit.
The court made the decision after allowing the application by SPAD to strike out the suit filed by the group of taxi drivers who claimed that SPAD had failed to be proactive in banning the activities and operations of the online taxi service providers.
"The plaintiffs should have initiated their action through Rule 53 of the Rules of Court 2012, that is, by filing for a judicial review and not through a writ of summons and statement of claims.
"The plaintiffs' claims are clearly unsustainable as Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane were not named as defendants together with SPAD in the writ of summons although the plaintiffs had made a lot of allegations against them (Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane)," said the judge, who also ordered all the plaintiffs to pay RM5,000 in costs to the defendant.
Justice Su also said that the plaintiffs failed to show that they had a locus standi to pursue the suit against SPAD.
She said according to SPAD's statement of defence, it had taken appropriate actions including arresting and charging individuals who broke the law by allowing their cars to be used to provide services to the public illegally.
"The plaintiffs' failure to provide details of the defendant's (SPAD) negligence has caused shame and prejudice to SPAD and tarnished its reputation," the judge said after hearing the submissions by lawyer R. Kengadharan, representing all the 102 taxi drivers, and lawyer Ben Syazmin, acting for SPAD.
On Dec 30, 2015, the Klang Valley Taxi Drivers Action Committee chairman, Zailani Isausuludin, 51, and 101 taxi drivers filed the suit against SPAD.
They demanded, among others, a declaration order for SPAD to ban the Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane services obtainable via online, stating that such a service did not come under the Land Public Transport Act 2010.
They asked for an injunction for SPAD not to legitimise the activities and operations of the three online taxi service providers, and to issue a guideline and circular subject to agreement on the terms of banning their services and operations.
In their statement of claims, the taxi drivers alleged, among others, that the Uber, Grabcar and Blacklane operations had adversely affected the local taxi service industry due to the latter's lower fares charged than the fares of metered taxis.
Kengadharan, when met by reporters, said they would file an appeal to the Court of Appeal against the High Court's decision.
More than 100 taxi drivers attended the court proceeding yesterday. -- Bernama
Bernama
Mon Sep 26 2016
The court ruled that the taxi drivers had used the wrong avenue to institute legal action against SPAD.
Niaga AWANI: Prestasi Bursa Malaysia setakat 18 April 2024
Indeks petunjuk pasaran itu yang dibuka tinggi naik 0.05 mata kepada 1,535.05, bergerak antara paras 1,532.95 dan 1,541.88 sepanjang sesi dagangan.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
Niaga AWANI: Prestasi ringgit setakat 18 April 2024
Ketua Ahli Ekonomi Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid berkata ringgit meningkat sedikit hari ini, seiring penurunan kecil Indeks Dolar AS (DXY) sebanyak 0.10 peratus kepada 106.153 mata.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
Niaga AWANI: Cukai & subsidi: Merungkai dasar tidak popular, strategi komunikasi berkesan
Berdasarkan laporan Ipsos, semakin ramai rakyat Malaysia kini percaya bahawa negara tidak mempunyai hala tuju yang betul. Ipsos mendedahkan lebih separuh rakyat Malaysia secara khusus menyatakan kebimbangan utama mereka tentang pembetulan kewangan dan politik. Kupasan lanjut bersama Pengarah Program MBA, Putra Business School (PBS), Prof Madya Dr. Ahmed Razman Abdul Latiff untuk bantu memahami laporan dan kebimbangan ini.
#NiagaAWANI
#NiagaAWANI
AWANI Pagi: Sports Dentistry: Bersukan dan berekreasi dengan selamat
Ketahui perihal Sports Dentistry, yang memberi tumpuan kepada pencegahan dan rawatan akibat dari kecederaan atau masalah pergigian dialami individu bersukan. Kupasannya bersama Dr Siti Salwa binti Idris Pakar Pergigian Restoratif, Klinik Pergigian Kuala Lumpur 8.30 pagi nanti.
Niaga AWANI: Data & Statistik: Cukai salah satu daripada lima kebimbangan utama rakyat Malaysia
Ia meningkat dengan ketara sejak Mac 2023. Penduduk global mempunyai
kebimbangan yang sama, tetapi rakyat Malaysia tidak begitu bimbang tentang jenayah dan kekerasan berbanding purata global.
#NiagaAWANI
kebimbangan yang sama, tetapi rakyat Malaysia tidak begitu bimbang tentang jenayah dan kekerasan berbanding purata global.
#NiagaAWANI
Banjir di Melaka: Lebih 300 petugas JKM siap siaga
Petugas JKM akan ditempatkan di pusat pemindahan sementara bagi membantu mangsa banjir khususnya memastikan aspek kebajikan dan keselesaan mereka.
Juventus kaji semula keputusan diarah bayar Ronaldo RM50 juta
Mahkamah timbang tara arah Juventus bayar gaji tertunggak 9.8 juta euro kepada Ronaldo.
Freedom Flotilla ke Gaza: Aktivis Malaysia berlepas ke Istanbul
Kesemua 19 anggota rombongan itu terdiri daripada doktor, aktivis kemanusiaan dan pengamal media.
AWANI Ringkas: Aktivis Malaysia sertai Misi Flotila ke Gaza hari ini
Ikuti rangkuman berita utama yang menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari di Astro AWANI menerusi AWANI Ringkas.
Kami sedia membantu - Penyokong Kedah
Dia berpandangan bahawa ada cara yang lebih baik untuk menangani masalah itu dengan menegaskan penyokong sedia membantu.