The High Court here today ruled that the nine cash withdrawals by a witness sufficed as credible evidence to establish the ingredients of the offence of receiving gratification by former Felda chairman Tan Sri Mohd Isa Abdul Samad.
Justice Mohd Nazlan Mohd Ghazali, in his judgment, said in respect of all the nine charges faced by Mohd Isa under Section 16 (a) (A) of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) Act, the series of cash withdrawals by a prosecution witness, a shareholder and director of JV Evolution Sdn Bhd, Azizi Abdul Wahab, which caused the cash to finally be given to the accused as stated in all the nine charges.
JV Evolution Sdn Bhd was the agent appointed by Gegasan Abadi Properties Sdn Bhd (GAPSB), whom former director was Ikhwan Zaidel, 60, for the sale of Merdeka Palace Hotel and Suites (MPHS) by GAPSB, the owner of the hotel at that time.
“Ikhwan then handed over the cash to Mohd Isa’s special officer, Muhammad Zahid Md Arip, who finally gave the cash to the accused as stated in all the nine charges.
“In view of the evidence of the receipt of the cash by the accused, I, therefore, invoke the statutory presumption under Section 50 of the MACC Act for the defence to rebut and show that the gratification in the form of the cash was not received corruptly and that it was not obtained as a reward for the accused’s involvement in the approval by the board of Felda Investment Corporation Sdn Bhd (FICSB) of the purchase of MPHS,” he said.
The judge said the prosecution had successfully adduced credible evidence proving each and every essential ingredient of the offence of accepting gratification under Section 16 (a) (A) of the MACC Act as framed in the nine charges, in relation to any of which if unrebutted or unexplained, would warrant a conviction.
“A prima facie case has therefore been made out against the accused in respect of each of the nine charges under Section 16 (a) (A) of the MACC Act,” he said.
The court however acquitted Mohd Isa of one criminal breach of trust (CBT) charge he faced involving the same hotel after finding the prosecution failed to prove prima facie case against him on the charge.
Elaborating his judgment on the CBT case, Justice Mohd Nazlan said the minutes of the 10th meeting of the board of FICSB on April 29, 2014, clearly showed that the purchase of MPHS at RM160 million was in fact approved by the FICSB board of directors, and in fact was not disputed.
“Even if the accused as a director of FICSB may have been entrusted with the funds of the company, he cannot under the law be said to have committed CBT on the disposal of company funds for the purchase of MPHS,” he said.
The judge added this was because not only did the accused alone as FIC chairman or director not have the requisite authority to approve the purchase, but the purchase was approved by the entire board consisting of seven directors, five of whom including the accused and FICSB former chief executive officer, Mohd Zaid Abdul Jalil, who attended the said meeting.
“There is lack of evidence of the accused having influenced or asked the other members of the board of FICSB to approve the said purchase,” he said.
“The minutes of the relevant meeting also did not record any discussion on the matter. Neither did the main company secretary who recorded the minutes hear anything to that effect,” said the judge.
Justice Mohd Nazlan added that criminal liability under CBT could not be founded on the disposal of company funds by FICSB to finance the purchase of MPHS without the approval of FELDA if the payment for the said the purchase has been consented to by FELDA.
“The prosecution has failed to establish a prima facie case against the accused in relation to the single CBT charge. The accused is therefore ordered to be discharged and acquitted from this CBT charge,” said the judge.
On the CBT charge, Mohd Isa was alleged to have approved the hotel purchase for RM160 million without the approval of Felda’s board of directors and was charged with committing the offence at Menara Felda, here on April 29, 2014.
The charge was framed under Section 409 of the Penal Code, which carries a maximum jail term of 20 years, together with whipping and a fine, upon conviction.
After the verdict was delivered, Mohd Isa, 71, said he would testify under oath from the witness box for the nine graft charges against him, where he will be subject to cross-examination by the prosecution.
Justice Mohd Nazlan ordered Mohd Isa to enter his defence on Aug 17, 18 and 19.
The former Menteri Besar of Negeri Sembilan was accompanied by his wife Puan Sri Bibi Sharliza Mohd Khalid and his family members.
Mohd Isa was represented by Datuk Sallehuddin Saidin, while the prosecution is led by deputy public prosecutor Afzainizam Abdul Aziz.
On Dec 14, 2018, Mohd Isa pleaded not guilty on one count of CBT and nine corruption charges.
All the bribery offences were allegedly committed at Level 49, Menara Felda, Platinum Park, Persiaran KLCC near here between April 29, 2014, and Dec 15, 2015.
When met outside the courtroom, Mohd Isa said he will enter his defence for the nine corruption charges involving over RM3 million brought against him.
“I was slapped with 10 charges. For the CBT charge, I was acquitted and discharged, so I will enter my defence for the remaining nine charges of corruption and I have chosen to do so by giving sworn evidence from the witness box,” he told reporters.
Meanwhile, Salehuddin said his client will take the witness box to give sworn evidence to rebut all allegations that he had received the money as charged.
The lawyer said by opting to give sworn evidence, his client had proved that was ready to be cross-examined by the prosecution.
“If the prosecution had any question, Tan Sri Mohd Isa will be there to answer them,” he said.
Meantime, Afzainizam, when contacted, said he will seek further instruction from the Attorney-General on whether or not to file an appeal against the court’s decision on the CBT charge.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Jun 16 2020
The court however acquitted Mohd Isa of one criminal breach of trust (CBT) charge he faced involving the same hotel after finding the prosecution failed to prove prima facie case against him on the charge. - Photo Astro AWANI
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Hina anggota TLDM terkorban, polis siasat Saifuddin Shafik
Polis menyiasat pemilik akaun, Saifuddin Shafik yang dipercayai memuat naik hantaran jelik berkaitan insiden kemalangan melibatkan helikopter TLDM.
Kes model sambilan bunuh teman lelaki: Tarikh baharu sebutan ditetap 28 Mei
Mahkamah Majistret menetapkan 28 Mei ini sebagai tarikh baharu sebutan kes seorang model sambilan wanita yang didakwa membunuh teman lelakinya.
Pantau Agenda Reformasi: Misi Break The Siege: Freedom Flotilla to Gaza
Pantau Agenda Reformasi hari ini membawakan Profesor Hubungan Antarabangsa di Fakulti Undang-Undang dan Hubungan Antarabangsa di UNISZA, Prof Dr Mohd Afandi Salleh, yang juga merupakan bekas peserta misi Flotilla ke Gaza pada 2018, berkongsi pengalamannya ketika ditahan pihak rejim Israel sewaktu misi tersebut. Antara lain perbincangan tertumpu ke arah aspek hubungan antarabangsa serta undang-undang di perairan antarabangsa.
Nahas helikopter Lumut: Mindef pertimbang keperluan teliti SOP latihan udara - Mohamed Khaled
Mindef akan mempertimbangkan keperluan untuk meneliti semula SOP latihan udara membentuk formasi penerbangan lintas hormat bagi mengelak tragedi.
Keselamatan siber: Keterangkuman, kepelbagaian perkasa sumbangan wanita
Wanita harus mula memberi fokus dan penekanan terhadap keterangkuman dan kepelbagaian perspektif bagi membolehkan mereka menangani cabaran industri dengan berkesan.
Penyerang Kamal Adli dijatuhkan hukuman lebih 2 tahun oleh mahkamah Singapura
Lelaki yang menyerang pelakon Malaysia, Kamal Adli menggunakan belantan tahun lepas, dijatuhkan hukuman penjara dua tahun, empat bulan dan dua minggu.
Peruntukan pembangkang: Terserah Muhyiddin untuk persoal keikhlasan kerajaan - Fadillah
Beliau enggan melayani sindiran bekas Perdana Menteri yang juga Pengerusi Perikatan Nasional, Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin tentang isu tersebut.
SPRM jangka ada beberapa tangkapan isu tuntutan palsu anak menteri besar - Azam
SPRM akan membuat beberapa tangkapan lagi, berhubung kes melibatkan anak seorang menteri besar bagi membantu siasatan kes tuntutan palsu berjumlah RM600,000.
SPRM akan panggil beberapa lagi individu bantu siasatan
Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM) akan memanggil beberapa lagi individu bagi membantu siasatan dakwaan pemalsuan dokumen tuntutan berjumlah RM600,000 melibatkan lima individu termasuk anak seorang Menteri Besar.
Pak Lah stabil, masih perlukan rehat secukupnya
Mantan Perdana Menteri, Tun Abdullah Ahmad Badawi dimasukkan ke Institut Jantung Negara (IJN), di sini, pada Rabu setelah mengalami small spontaneous pneumothorax.
Buat masa ini, keadaan beliau dilaporkan stabil dan masih dirawat di Unit Penjagaan Koronari (Coronary Care Unit).
Buat masa ini, keadaan beliau dilaporkan stabil dan masih dirawat di Unit Penjagaan Koronari (Coronary Care Unit).
Women for zero corruption
If Latheefa Koya's appointment as the new MACC chief goes unchallenged, Malaysia will see the first woman leading the war against corruption.
[OPINION] Opportunity from chaos
The biggest clandestine threat is the evaporation of the middle class across the developed world.
PM, Kabinet, Ketua Institusi perlu isytihar harta - Akhbar Satar
Datuk Akhbar Satar turut mencadangkan supaya proses tersebut turut dilakukan pasangan masing-masing dan ahli keluarga terdekat.
China to alter law as it steps up fight against graft fugitives
China plans to change its law to allow judgments to be delivered in corruption cases even when the suspects do not appear in court.
Presiden FIFA: Pemilihan semula Sepp Blatter disambut sinis
Ikrar Blatter bebaskan FIFA dari kemelut rasuah antara yang jadi sindiran.