The U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesday sided with Samsung in its big-money smartphone patent fight with Apple, throwing out an appeals court ruling that the South Korean company had to pay a $399 million penalty to its American rival for copying key iPhone designs.
The 8-0 ruling, written by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, held that a patent violator does not always have to fork over its entire profits from the sales of products using stolen designs, if the designs covered only certain components and not the whole thing.
The justices sent the case back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington to determine how much Samsung must pay. But they did not provide a road map to juries and lower courts on how to navigate similar disputes in the future.
Apple spokesman Josh Rosenstock said in a statement that the U.S. company remained "optimistic that the lower courts will again send a powerful signal that stealing isn't right."
Samsung told Reuters in a statement the ruling was a "victory for Samsung and for all those who promote creativity, innovation and fair competition in the marketplace."
Following a 2012 jury verdict favoring Apple, Samsung initially was hit with nearly $930 million in penalties, later cut by $382 million, for infringing Apple's iPhone patents and mimicking its distinctive appearance in making the Galaxy and other competing devices.
Samsung in December 2015 paid its Cupertino, California-based rival $548 million. But Samsung took the matter to the Supreme Court, saying it should not have had to make $399 million of that payout for copying the patented designs of the iPhone's rounded-corner front face, bezel and colorful grid of icons that represent programs and applications.
With the products that used iPhone designs, Samsung went on to become the world's top smartphone maker.
Tuesday's ruling followed a ferocious legal battle between the world's top two smartphone manufacturers that began in 2011 when Apple sued Samsung for patent and trademark infringement. It was one of the most closely watched patent cases to come before the top U.S. court in recent years.
The legal dispute centered on whether the term "article of manufacture," on which design patent damages are calculated in U.S. patent law, should be interpreted as a finished product in its entirety, or merely a component in a complex product.
In court papers, Samsung, Apple and the U.S. government all agreed that the term could mean a component.
But Apple urged the Supreme Court to affirm the appeals court's ruling because Samsung presented no evidence that the article of manufacture in this case was anything less than its entire smartphone as sold. Samsung, meanwhile, said that it did not have to present such evidence.
Sotomayor, writing for the unanimous court, said that the law is clear. The term "article of manufacture is broad enough to encompass both a product sold to a consumer as well as a component of that product," she wrote.
PERIOD OF UNCERTAINTY
The justices nevertheless refused to devise a test for juries and lower courts to use to discern what a relevant article of manufacture is in a particular case, a task that could be fraught with difficulty when considering high-tech products.
"No doubt whether with Apple-Samsung, or some other design patent case, we are going to have a period of uncertainty where courts will be trying to formulate a test and what the boundaries are," Richard McKenna, an expert in design rights at the law firm Foley & Lardner in Milwaukee, said in an interview.
In court papers, Apple said its iPhone's success was tied to innovative designs, which other manufacturers quickly adopted in their own products. Samsung, in particular, made a deliberate decision to copy the iPhone's look and many user interface features, Apple said.
Samsung argued that it should not have had to turn over all its profits, saying that design elements contributed only marginally to a complex product with thousands of patented features.
Design patent fights very rarely reach the Supreme Court. It had not heard such a case in more than 120 years.
The case is Samsung Electronics Co, Ltd v. Apple Inc, in the Supreme Court of the United States, No. 15-777.
Reuters
Wed Dec 07 2016
3D-printed Samsung and Apple logos are seen in this picture illustration made in Zenica, Bosnia and Herzegovina on January 26, 2016. - REUTERS pic / Dado Ruvic
Ahli perniagaan rugi lebih RM100,000 akibat 'phone scam'
Pengadu lelaki tempatan berusia 55 tahun itu memaklumkan kerani syarikat miliknya ditipu oleh sindiket phone scam terbabit.
Fotofit suspek simbah asid sedang disiapkan - KPN
Menurut Razarudin, setakat ini, lebih 12 individu telah direkod keterangan.
[TERKINI] Malaysia mengalu-alukan resolusi UNGA
Malaysia mengalu-alukan penerimaan pakai Resolusi Perhimpunan Agung Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu (UNGA) pada Sidang Khas Darurat Kesepuluh yang disambung semula pada 10 Mei 2024.
Putrajaya dalam satu kenyataan pada Sabtu berkata, Malaysia bersama dengan 77 Negara Anggota, mengundi dan menyokong Resolusi itu, sejajar dengan pendiriannya yang tidak berbelah bahagi dan telah lama berpegang pada perjuangan Palestin.
Putrajaya dalam satu kenyataan pada Sabtu berkata, Malaysia bersama dengan 77 Negara Anggota, mengundi dan menyokong Resolusi itu, sejajar dengan pendiriannya yang tidak berbelah bahagi dan telah lama berpegang pada perjuangan Palestin.
Sebuah video serangan ke atas Israel dikeluarkan Hamas
Sebuah rakaman dikeluarkan Hamas pada Jumaat, mendakwa melakukan serangan ke atas tentera Israel di kawasan kejiranan di Bandar Gaza dan melepaskan bom di Beersheba, Israel.
Sebuah kenyataan pada video yang disiarkan di Telegram oleh Sayap Bersenjata Hamas, menunjukkan serangan ke atas sekumpulan penembak tepat Israel di selatan kejiranan Al-Zaytoun di Bandar Gaza dan pengeboman ke atas "bandar yang diduduki" Beersheba.
Sebuah kenyataan pada video yang disiarkan di Telegram oleh Sayap Bersenjata Hamas, menunjukkan serangan ke atas sekumpulan penembak tepat Israel di selatan kejiranan Al-Zaytoun di Bandar Gaza dan pengeboman ke atas "bandar yang diduduki" Beersheba.
[INFOGRAFIK] N.06 Kuala Kubu Baharu, calon PN, Khairul Azhari Saut
Berikut adalah sedikit infografik berkenaan calon PN, Khairul Azhari Saut. Sila klik video untuk berita selanjutnya.
PRK KKB: Berkerusi roda, bertongkat demi pilih wakil rakyat
Kerusi rodanya meluncur perlahan memasuki pusat pengundian selepas melakukan perjalanan 500 meter dari kediamannya.
[INFOGRAFIK] N0.6 Kuala Kubu Baharu, calon Perpaduan, Pan Sock Tao
Berikut adalah sedikit infografik berkenaan calon Perpaduan, Pan Sock Tao. Sila klik video untuk berita selanjutnya.
OpenAI dilapor bakal lancar pembantu maya mampu kenal objek, imej
Peranti seperti Rabbit AI dan Humane AI Pin didakwa mempunyai kemampuan yang sama tetapi gagal melakukannya dengan pantas atau konsisten.
Pasangan warga emas redah 200 km demi PRK Kuala Kubu Baharu
Abdul Rahim Bidin dan Noraini Mansor bergerak selepas subuh dan selesai membuang undi di SJKC Khing Ming sekitar jam 8.30 pagi.
Buletin AWANI Khas: Kuala Kubu Baharu memilih
Apple mohon maaf selepas iklan iPad Pro guris perasaan
Apple memohon maaf kerana menghasilkan iklan itu kerana ia dilihat sebagai bersikap tidak sensitif terhadap artis.
Apple perkenal cip pemprosesan Apple M4
Apple M4 hadir dengan 4 teras CPU prestasi bersama 6 teras CPU efisien, selain 10 teras GPU untuk penawaran grafik yang baik melaluinya.
Apple sedang bangunkan cip kendiri untuk jalankan perisian AI
Cip AI kendiri ini akan digunakan di pusat data Apple dengan ini
Google bayar Apple hingga AS$20 bilion pada 2022, kekal enjin carian utama Safari
Google sedia bekerjasama dengan Apple untuk menjadi enjin carian utama dan pembayaran dilihat meningkat dari tahun ke tahun.
Apple dijangka tambah ciri AI pada Safari melalui iOS 18
Ciri kecerdasan buatan pada Safari kelak akan memudahkan beberapa proses pelayaran.
Apple Pencil baharu hadir dengan sistem haptik
Apabila digunakan pada skrin iPad, pengguna boleh merasakan tindak balas haptik seakan menggunakan pensel sebenar.
iPad Pro mungkin dijana dengan cip Apple M4 terbaharu, fokus ciri AI
Cip Apple M4 dijangka memfokuskan kepada keupayaan enjin neural yang disertakan bersama dengannya membolehkan ia menawarkan ciri AI yang lebih baik.
Apple perkenal HomePod, HomePod Mini di Malaysia, harga bermula RM529
Kedua-duanya akan mula dijual 10 Mei 2024 untuk pasaran tempatan.
Apple dalam perbincangan guna teknologi OpenAI dalam iOS 18 - Laporan
iOS 18 akan membawakan perubahan paling besar untuk sistem operasi iPhone tahun ini dan integrasi sistem AI akan akhirnya didedahkan.
'Made in Malaysia' - Apple punyai 19 kilang pembekal di negara ini
Malaysia merupakan salah satu negara yang mempunyai beberapa kilang pembekal yang menawarkan komponen kepada Apple.